# Noise Advisory Board – May 8, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Noise Advisory Board
**Date:** May 8, 2023 1:00 PM EDT (2023-05-08T13:00:09-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4777/noise-advisory-board-may-8-2023
**Outcome:** The Noise Advisory Board voted unanimously to continue meeting monthly and decided to present its annual report recommendations to the Environment and Safety Committee on June 27.

## Summary

**Meeting Overview**
The City of Asheville Noise Advisory Board convened on May 8, 2023, to review staff reports, discuss procedural changes, and coordinate upcoming presentations to city leadership. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a review of noise complaint data, and updates on ongoing working groups regarding decibel measurements and adjacent noise issues.

**Key Decisions**
The board voted unanimously to approve the minutes from the previous meeting. Additionally, the board voted unanimously to continue meeting on a monthly basis. This decision was made with the understanding that the specific decision to hold a meeting would be finalized at the agenda-setting meeting, contingent upon whether there were sufficient agenda items to warrant a session.

**Discussion Highlights**
During the staff check-in, the Chair asked if the reported noise complaint numbers reflected the removal of duplicate filings; the Noise Administrator confirmed the figures were still raw data. The board noted that only one sound exceedance permit had been applied for in 2023 to date.

The board discussed the timeline for presenting their annual report recommendations to the Environment and Safety Committee. They decided to target the June 27 committee meeting rather than May 23, allowing more time to prepare slides and align with city staff. Councilwoman Mosley noted that she did not see the board on the May agenda for that committee, suggesting June was the more likely timeframe.

Regarding the decibel investigation, the working group provided a detailed update on low-frequency noise measurements, the development of a measurement calendar, and the process for obtaining property waivers from complainants. Rick Freeman explained that the group is unlikely to recommend an ordinance change solely to add a DBC limit, but rather to introduce a modifier to the DBA measurement when a compliance officer observes heavy DBC. He emphasized that the group would not move toward recommending ordinance language changes until they had engaged with sound producers, stating, "It would be suicide to just try to pop that into city council without having some discussion."

On the topic of meeting frequency, Rick Freeman proposed continuing monthly meetings, stating, "If it were possible, according to the rules, I'd propose we continue to meet every month... the decibel working group is going to pick up its pace... I think we need to keep meeting every month so that we can tell you what we learned and you can send us in a new direction."

**Follow-ups**
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. The Chair stated she would speak with Ben Woody, Assistant City Manager, after the meeting to confirm the date for the Environment and Safety Committee presentation. The Chair and a board member agreed to meet after the session to create the slides for that presentation, with a deadline of June 20.

Regarding the adjacent noise task force, a board member stated she would reach out to the Chair to determine if an update needed to be placed on the June agenda, as they had not met to prepare one due to the Chair being out of town. Additionally, a board member stated he would work with Mark Matheny, Director of Development Services, prior to the next agenda-setting meeting to ensure staff support for the waste hauler task force recommendation. Mark Matheny agreed to send his contact information to the board member to facilitate this conversation.

In relation to the decibel working group, a board member agreed to send an email to complainants to share the property waiver and gauge their willingness to participate in measurements. Another board member agreed to compile a calendar of sound source activity times to plan measurement dates. The working group agreed to convene another meeting once the waiver responses and calendar were ready, including the Noise Administrator or his representative.

**Impact**
These decisions ensure the board maintains a consistent schedule to support the accelerating pace of the decibel working group, which is critical for gathering accurate data on low-frequency noise. By targeting the June 27 Environment and Safety Committee meeting, the board allows time to refine its annual report recommendations and coordinate with city staff. The commitment to engage with sound producers before proposing ordinance changes reflects a cautious approach to regulatory updates, aiming to ensure that any future recommendations are grounded in direct dialogue with affected parties.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I1pEgTgz7M0
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2624/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I1pEgTgz7M0)
