# Planning and Zoning Commission – May 3, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Planning and Zoning Commission
**Date:** May 3, 2023 5:00 PM EDT (2023-05-03T17:00:29-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4780/planning-and-zoning-commission-may-3-2023

## Summary

The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission met on May 3, 2023, to review several development proposals and zoning code updates. The Commission approved the minutes from the April 5, 2023 meeting unanimously. The agenda included a mix of site plan reviews, rezoning requests, and technical updates to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO), with several items deferred to the June 7, 2023 meeting for further review.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The Commission voted 5-0 to recommend approval of the Level 2 ministerial site plan for 72 Broadway Street, a nine-story mixed-use building in the Central Business District (CBD). This recommendation is subject to the applicant addressing outstanding technical and design review conditions. For the conditional rezoning request for 319 Biltmore Avenue, the Commission voted unanimously to continue the item to the June 7, 2023 meeting. Additionally, the Commission voted 4-0 to continue the UDO Table of Uses Consolidation to June 7, 2023. Two other items—a Level 2 site plan for 68 Carter Street and a conditional rezoning for 99999 Grandview Place—were continued to the June 7 meeting by unanimous motion. No formal vote was taken on the proposed Pre-Development Application Community Meeting Requirements, as Chair Geoffrey Barton clarified the item was for informational presentation and informal review rather than formal approval.

**Discussion Highlights**
Discussion on 72 Broadway Street focused on updated plans, valet parking logistics, and access for a tower crane. Staff recommended approval, noting that all technical standards could be satisfied. Regarding 319 Biltmore Avenue, a request to rezone City-owned property for 221 residential units with 30% affordable housing, significant debate arose regarding the project's alignment with the South Slope Vision Plan. Chair Geoffrey Barton expressed strong opposition, stating, "I just... I don't know if I can be for this... I hate it... but I don't know that I can." Another Commissioner noted the project seemed like "suburban development stuck right on the edge of downtown" due to the abandonment of commercial space. Staff clarified that the affordability breakdown is 20% of units at 60% Area Median Income (AMI) or lower, and 10% at 80% AMI.

On the UDO Table of Uses Consolidation, staff presented a draft to merge four inconsistent "Table of Uses" sections into a single global table. Development Liaison Clay Mitchell described the goal as "one table to rule them all," aiming to reduce permitting confusion. Deputy City Attorney Jannice Ashley emphasized that defining uses is legally critical to avoid litigation. Assistant Director Chris Collins noted that current inconsistencies cause administrative issues, citing food trucks in the Haywood Road District as an example of confusion.

Regarding the Pre-Development Application amendments, which would expand notification radii and require city-provided templates, Chris Collins recommended against changing notification requirements for quasi-judicial or legislative hearings, citing existing "communication fatigue." During the discussion, a Commissioner stated they were "unconvinced" the proposed pre-development amendment was a significant barrier, noting it was a "very modest" burden.

**Community Input**
During the review of 72 Broadway Street, a public commenter, an attorney representing the owners of a neighboring building, raised concerns about the applicant’s use of a privately owned rear alley for a tower crane and service access, noting potential infringement on deeded access rights. The commenter stated that if the applicant cannot secure access, the project may need to be redesigned and re-reviewed. Chair Geoffrey Barton responded by explaining that for a Level 2 ministerial review, the Commission must approve the project if it meets UDO requirements. He noted that if the alley cannot be used, the applicant could potentially use construction access off Broadway or a crane through the building, though these are less ideal. He stated that if the access issue forces a redesign, the project would likely need to come back for a new review. No public comments were received for the 319 Biltmore Avenue item or the UDO amendments.

**Follow-ups**
Staff agreed to forward comments regarding potential traffic calming measures on Broadway to transportation staff for review during the permitting process for 72 Broadway Street. For 319 Biltmore Avenue, the applicant agreed to work with staff to incorporate feedback on pedestrian access, street activation, and design details before the June 7 meeting. Staff also agreed to present the formal UDO Table of Uses amendment with highlighted changes at the June 7 meeting. Additionally, staff noted that the IT department confirmed the ability to implement a "subscribe" button for development notifications, which they intend to commit to as part of system updates.

**Impact**
These decisions impact the development landscape in Asheville’s downtown and South Slope areas. The recommendation to approve 72 Broadway Street moves a major mixed-use project closer to construction, contingent on resolving access and design conditions. The deferral of 319 Biltmore Avenue allows for further refinement of a large residential project to better align with city planning goals for street activation and pedestrian safety. The technical consolidation of the UDO Tables of Uses aims to streamline the permitting process and ensure fair administration of zoning codes for all residents and businesses.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKtkMCygGrU
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3027/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKtkMCygGrU)
