# City Council Budget Work Session – April 11, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** April 11, 2023 2:53 PM EDT (2023-04-11T14:53:17-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4797/city-council-budget-work-session-april-11-2023
**Outcome:** Council discussed the proposed budget, including employee compensation increases and water service fee changes, without taking any formal votes.

## Summary

On April 11, 2023, the Asheville City Council held its final planned budget work session for the current fiscal year. The session focused on reviewing updates to the General Fund, compensation recommendations, new investments, and water service fees. Staff from the Finance and Management Services Department presented data on balancing rising service costs with available revenues and addressed feedback from previous meetings. No formal votes or motions were taken during this work session, as the items discussed are part of the City Manager’s proposed budget.

**General Fund and Fund Balance**
Staff reported that General Fund revenues are estimated at just over $158 million, with expenses at $156.6 million, resulting in a projected addition of $1.7 million to the fund balance. The current estimated fund balance is approximately $36.3 million, or 23% of expenses, which is significantly higher than the city’s internal policy target of 15% and the Local Government Commission minimum of 8%. Staff recommended using approximately $6 million of this fund balance for next year’s budget, including $2 million for McCormick Field preparation and $4.2 million for operating expenses. While some Council members expressed a preference for using more of the available balance to fund one-time projects, staff advised caution due to economic uncertainty and the need to maintain a strong credit rating. No decision was made on the final amount.

**Compensation and Benefits**
The Council discussed recommendations for increasing employee compensation, with total changes estimated at $7.2 million. Staff proposed increasing the night/weekend shift differential from $0.75/hour to $2.00/hour, an estimated annual cost of $250,000. This figure is higher than their original $1.50 proposal but lower than the $3.00 requested by Council. Additionally, staff recommended increasing on-call pay from $20/day to $30/day, with an estimated annual cost of $150,000. Staff explained that the $2.00 differential is competitive with peer benchmarks and avoids disincentivizing day-shift work, while the $30 on-call rate focuses on retaining current employees. City Manager Deborah Campbell emphasized the necessity of these changes, stating, "I’m proud of you for looking at this type of compensation and benefits package for our employees... This is the market that we’re in, and I don’t think it’s going to be over in the next year or two. I think this is the base. This is the floor."

**Water Services Fund and Fees**
The Water Services Fund budget includes a 3% increase to maintain current operations, totaling approximately $41.6 million, plus approximately $1 million for service enhancements such as additional maintenance crews, night coverage at treatment plants, and customer service staff. Including compensation changes of just under $700,000, the total Water Fund budget is approximately $43.5 million. Staff reiterated recommended fee increases that would impact a typical household by $10.89 per bi-monthly bill, or approximately $65 annually. Council members debated the timing of these increases, with one member stating, "I still would like to see an option for some sort of phasing that’s in between the we do nothing and we do everything... I would like to be able to review it." Another member raised equity concerns, noting, "If you raise it [the base rate], it’s actually regressive... It would be less equitable for people living here than folks who have second homes." Staff explained that a consultant is conducting a rate model study expected to be completed in September or October 2023, and no vote was taken on the fee increases at this time.

**New Investments**
Staff presented several new staffing and operating requests for the General Fund, including a Solid Waste Driver offset by a previously approved sanitation fee increase, a Purchasing Coordinator to support the water department, Janitorial Staff for the upcoming Broadway Public Safety Center Station, Animal Care Naturalists for the Nature Center, and City Attorney Administrative Support. Additionally, staff proposed expanding a current part-time ARPA-funded position to a permanent General Fund position for a Constituent Services Coordinator to handle resident inquiries and homelessness/affordable housing information.

**Follow-ups and Next Steps**
City Manager Deborah Campbell agreed to provide Council with specific information on how much the fund balance would be above the 15% policy target if the recommended $6 million is used. David Melton, Director of Water Resources, confirmed that the consultant’s rate study is expected to be completed in September or October 2023, and that if fee increases are approved, they would typically take effect in September to allow for a full billing cycle. Taylor Floyd agreed to provide data on employee vacation time usage to address concerns about staff burnout. Staff also confirmed that the city’s reparations allocation will continue to compound at 2% annually. The next scheduled steps include the City Manager’s proposed budget presentation on May 9, 2023, a statutory budget public hearing on May 23, 2023, and a tentative budget adoption date of June 13, 2023.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SgYnXgYdCaA
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3062/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SgYnXgYdCaA)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
