# Housing and Community Development – April 4, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Housing and Community Development Committee
**Date:** April 4, 2023 10:01 AM EDT (2023-04-04T10:01:43-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4805/housing-and-community-development-april-4-2023
**Outcome:** The Housing and Community Development Committee reviewed five housing trust fund applications totaling $5.255 million and deferred funding decisions to its April 18 meeting.

## Summary

On April 4, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Housing and Community Development Committee held a special meeting to review applications for the Housing Trust Fund (HTF). The session was dedicated to hearing presentations from developers regarding six received applications, with the committee noting that five were eligible for consideration and one was deemed ineligible. The total funding requested for the five eligible projects is $5.255 million. No votes were taken, and no public comment was accepted during this special session.

## Key Discussions and Presentations
Staff presented an overview of the five eligible projects, each of which was discussed by its respective developer or representative:
*   **Redwood Commons:** A 70-unit, 9% Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) project for seniors in East Asheville, developed by Buckeye Community Hope Foundation, requesting $1.8 million.
*   **Reimagining Deaverview:** A rental apartment project in West Asheville, developed by Asheville Housing Authority, requesting $1.135 million as a modification to a previous grant award.
*   **Fair Haven Summit:** A 77-unit, 9% LIHTC project in South Asheville, developed by Commonwealth Development Corporation, requesting $500,000.
*   **Stewart Street Cottages:** A 10-unit homeownership project in West Asheville, developed by Reasonable Development LLC, requesting $1,052,000.
*   **Oak Hill Cottages:** A 42-unit mixed-use project on city-owned land in West Asheville, developed by Reasonable Development LLC, requesting $868,000 in HTF financing and a discounted land sale.

During the discussions, Chair Sage Turner noted that the committee is managing a high volume of housing-related work, stating, "By the time I had typed out that email, I was like, oh my goodness, there is so much going on in housing... kudos to everybody for staying above water." Regarding the Fair Haven Summit project, Affordable Housing Officer Sasha Brzezinski explained that Buncombe County has a policy prohibiting tax-exempt status for projects receiving county affordable housing funds, noting that the county’s Affordable Housing Committee recommended changing this policy but the full commission rejected the change.

For the Reimagining Deaverview project, Asheville Housing Authority COO Tara Irby emphasized the importance of resident input, stating, "We consider this to be a best practice... We believe the resident is the primary stakeholder... We certainly stand by the fact that the success of the work will be in large part due to the input and the thoughtfulness of the residents." Commonwealth Development Corporation VP Sean Brady proposed a cash flow repayment structure rather than deferring all payments, aiming to repay loans within the 20-year term to avoid a massive repayment at the end. Reasonable Development LLC’s Barry Bialik, presenting the Stewart Street Cottages project, remarked, "Affordable housing takes all of us giving in a little bit to make this work... I'm basically using almost, I'd say, everything I've learned from my time on the committee for how to provide the elusive affordable housing."

A council member raised concerns regarding the Oak Hill Cottages project, specifically the disposition of city-owned land. The member stated, "If it were decided to not follow our... sale disposition policy... you can't just give city land away... You have to, if you're going to do it for affordable housing to a private developer, 20% of the units are... have to be affordable to those at 60% of AMI for at least 15 years." In response, Assistant City Manager Rachel Wood explained that she is working with the community and economic development team on a more comprehensive strategy for the disposition of city-owned land, noting, "those are considerations that we're going to be bringing back fall, winter, leading into calendar year 2024."

## Decisions and Votes
No votes were taken at this meeting. Chair Sage Turner explicitly stated at the beginning of the session that committee members would have the chance to ask questions, but there would be no public comment and no funding decisions made. The Chair clarified, "We will have our regular Housing and Community Development Committee meeting on April 18th... and that is when we will consider the funding recommendations and allocations."

## Follow-ups
Staff member Sasha Brzezinski agreed to bring more complete summaries, analyses, and staff recommendations for each of the five projects to the next meeting on April 18. Additionally, staff noted that the Affordable Housing Plan, which includes a review of the HTF policy, and a comprehensive strategy for the disposition of city-owned land are scheduled for the committee’s work plan in the fall and winter leading into calendar year 2024. Staff also clarified that a micro-units item, previously expected in April, is now scheduled for May due to scheduling constraints.

## Impact
This meeting served as a preliminary review of significant affordable housing developments in Asheville, including projects in East, West, and South Asheville. While no funding was allocated or approved on April 4, the committee gathered necessary information to make recommendations. The discussions highlighted ongoing policy considerations regarding city-owned land sales and the interaction between local and county affordable housing incentives. The committee will formally consider funding recommendations and allocations at its regular meeting on April 18, 2023, with items subsequently moving to City Council for consideration on April 25, 2023.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2wb0fXwpODw
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2646/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2wb0fXwpODw)
