# Environment & Safety Committee – March 28, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Environment and Safety Committee
**Date:** March 28, 2023 11:00 AM EDT (2023-03-28T11:00:33-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4809/environment-safety-committee-march-28-2023
**Outcome:** The Environment and Safety Committee unanimously adopted the Municipal Climate Action Plan and recommended a contract for the parks master plan consultant.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Environment and Safety Committee held a remote virtual meeting on March 28, 2023, chaired by Councilwoman Maggie Ullman. The agenda addressed public safety, sustainability, and parks planning, including the approval of previous minutes, the adoption of a municipal climate action plan, and updates on police recruitment and fire department initiatives.

**Key Decisions**
The committee took three formal votes during the session. First, the committee unanimously approved the minutes from the February 28, 2023 meeting, with the motion seconded by Vice Mayor Sandra Kilgore. Second, the committee unanimously adopted the Municipal Climate Action Plan, a motion made by Councilwoman Shanique Smith. This item is scheduled to move to the full City Council for consideration on the same evening. Third, the committee unanimously voted to move forward with a recommendation to the full City Council to approve a contract with Design Workshop, a consultant hired to develop a 10-year Comprehensive Parks and Recreation Master Plan.

**Discussion Highlights**
A significant portion of the meeting focused on public safety and crime. Police Chief David Zack presented 2022 crime statistics, noting that while violent crime increased by 17.4% overall, targeted operations in specific areas, such as the downtown "Charlie District," led to a significant drop in aggravated assaults in those zones. Chief Zack highlighted that despite a loss of over 55% in investigative staff, the department maintained a 63% homicide clearance rate, which exceeds the national average of 50%. He emphasized the need for "violence interrupters" and community partners to assist in solving gang-related homicides.

On sustainability, Sustainability Director Bridget Herring presented the updated Municipal Climate Action Plan, which incorporates goals adopted since 2009. Chair Ullman expressed appreciation for the strategic thinking behind the plan, noting it provides a long-term path for the city despite state-level limitations on climate change strategies. Regarding parks, Parks and Recreation Director D. Tyrell McGirt discussed the hiring of a consultant for the master plan. Vice Mayor Kilgore thanked the department for the progress made in correcting service gaps in certain communities.

The Fire Department presented a Community Responder Pilot Program designed to proactively assist individuals experiencing homelessness, addiction, or behavioral health issues. Assistant Fire Chief Patrick Grittup explained that the pilot will initially focus on the Central Business District but will address needs wherever they arise, working in coordination with Buncombe County’s community outreach team. Councilwoman Smith suggested using opioid settlement money to fund new initiatives, including the Community Responder program and violence interruption efforts. Finally, City Manager Deborah Campbell discussed synthesizing goals from a recent council retreat into a 12-month organizational work program.

**Community Input**
During opening public comment, multiple residents called in to express strong support for the Asheville Police Department (APD). Commenters requested dramatic salary increases and improved health benefits to address staffing shortages and crime. One commenter cited a "culture war" against the department and flagrant crime on major corridors, while another shared a personal story of positive interactions with APD during a family emergency. A third commenter argued that without a safe city, other issues like sustainability do not matter, urging the city to provide competitive salaries and full retirement benefits to attract officers. A fourth commenter highlighted an instance where APD responded to a pregnant woman under a bridge when other outreach services did not. Chair Ullman thanked the callers for sharing their comments, but no specific member responded to the substance of the requests for budget increases during this segment. No public comments were received during the closing comment period.

**Follow-ups**
Staff will present the Municipal Climate Action Plan to the full City Council for a vote on the evening of March 28. If the full Council approves the Parks and Recreation Master Plan consultant contract, the work will begin in April with a kickoff meeting scheduled for the following month; staff will provide updates to the committee throughout the year. The Police Department is processing eight additional applications for the July 2023 Basic Law Enforcement Training class and will attend additional job fairs in April. The Fire Department plans to implement the Community Responder Pilot on May 1, 2023, and will report data after a two-month pilot period ending June 30, 2023. City Manager Deborah Campbell committed to providing information to the committee in late to mid-April outlining all departmental initiatives, deliverables, and resource connections for the next 12 months.

**Impact**
These decisions and updates reflect the city's ongoing efforts to balance public safety with sustainability and community development. The adoption of the Climate Action Plan establishes a strategic framework for municipal sustainability goals, while the recommendation for the Parks and Recreation Master Plan aims to create a long-term strategy for equitable park services. The detailed crime data and recruitment updates provide transparency into the challenges facing the police department, including staffing shortages and the impact of targeted enforcement. The upcoming Community Responder Pilot represents a shift toward proactive, non-emergency assistance for vulnerable populations, potentially reducing the burden on emergency services.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vf76IQx3kj4
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2650/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vf76IQx3kj4)
