# Reparations Commission – March 20, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Reparations Commission
**Date:** March 20, 2023 5:55 PM EDT (2023-03-20T17:55:28-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4819/reparations-commission-march-20-2023
**Outcome:** The Reparations Commission heard updates on education and health proposals, a finalized performance audit scope, and new data on the legacy of urban renewal in the South Side.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Reparations Commission convened on March 20, 2023, to review updates from its working groups and hear presentations on historical data. The meeting focused on progress in the Education and Health and Wellness Impact Focus Areas (IFAs), the finalized scope for a performance audit, and new findings regarding the legacy of urban renewal in the city’s South Side.

## Key Decisions
The commission took two formal votes during the session. First, the chair called for a vote on the minutes, which were approved unanimously. Second, a motion was made to adjourn the meeting, which was also approved unanimously. No other binding decisions or policy adoptions were recorded at this meeting.

## Discussion Highlights
The meeting began with a review of a survey from the previous month, which received positive feedback on engagement but suggested improvements in time management and clearer explanations regarding conflict of interest and funding.

The Education IFA presented proposals aimed at recruiting and retaining Black teachers, addressing disparities in student suspensions, and expanding community programming. The group highlighted significant data disparities, noting that 89% of students in gifted and talented programs are white, while only 11% of Black youth meet third-grade literacy standards. Dr. Mary Falkner, the Education IFA Facilitator, stated, "We know that not 89% of gifted students are white. There are stark disparities in the outcomes of black youth as well as the opportunities afforded to them and that is what this group is working on to both remedy the harm, to course correct them, and to propose community based solutions..."

The Health and Wellness IFA presented eight categories of recommendations prioritized by timeline. Immediate priorities included free access to health insurance for African Americans, non-punitive substance abuse treatment, and suicide prevention resources. A commission member noted, "I know I can speak for black people. I've never seen it this bad here before. So these programs, even though they are well-intended, are not working." Another member emphasized the need to separate personal relationships from professional performance metrics to ensure vulnerable populations are not harmed.

The Audit Scope Working Group presented the finalized scope of work for a performance audit. This audit will examine the tangible outcomes, policies, and programs of municipal governments, sub-recipients, and NGOs that have received taxpayer funds to serve the African-American community. The group emphasized that while programs have been well-intended, data indicates that harm has perpetuated, necessitating a rigorous review of accountability.

Finally, Priscilla Medea Robinson, Dr. Lee, and Dr. Messinia presented data findings regarding the legacy of urban renewal on Asheville’s South Side, introducing a new website (urbanrenewalimpact.org). Key findings included:
*   The city paid a median of just over $5,000 for acquisition parcels, with 85% of acquisitions below $10,000.
*   Current city-owned and Housing Authority properties overlap with 316 original acquisition parcels, representing over one-third of the original pool.
*   Property values in the affected area have increased by approximately 400% since urban renewal, after inflation adjustment.
*   Repackaged parcels were resold at a discount, with 83% sold below acquisition cost.
*   Only 14 individuals who lost their property were able to repurchase in the first round, while the top 10 repurchasers (all businesses) bought nearly a third of the repackaged parcels.

Priscilla Medea Robinson stated, "This indicates that urban renewal really deprived Southside homeowners of a significant source of intergenerational wealth. And for the first time, we have data in numbers that can be audited and looked at and examined..." A commission member responded, "I just want to say, Ms. Robinson... the work that you're doing lets us know that this work can be done. These numbers can come out. It's not hard to find... I'm just so happy that people like you are out there doing this when people aren't watching you, people aren't asking you to do it. And I just really appreciate it because it made my job a lot easier."

## Community Input
Two members of the public provided comments, and no member or staff member responded to either.

A resident of 25 years who has researched Black involvement in city government noted that Asheville did not have a Black councilperson until 1969 and that African American participation on the City Council since 1931 has averaged only 8.6%. The commenter highlighted that the formation of the current City Council in 1931 was surrounded by efforts to disenfranchise Black people, including repealing absentee voting provisions.

A second public commenter criticized the commission for "paralysis of analysis" and asked when the body would "get down to business." The commenter questioned why the "State of Black Asheville" project was discontinued due to lack of financial support, noting that the data presented by Ms. Robinson proved the work was possible. The commenter also challenged the concept of "affordable housing" without a median living wage, arguing that infrastructure costs and economic realities make the current narrative "false and racist."

## Follow-ups
Several working groups and staff members outlined next steps:
*   **Education IFA:** The group stated they will look into federal funding and the North Carolina Education Lottery for potential resources. They also plan to collaborate with other IFAs and hold community engagement events to refine proposals and definitions.
*   **Health and Wellness IFA:** The group stated they are making additional data requests to the Department of Health and Human Services regarding uninsured African Americans and current funding levels. They plan to hold two more community events before the end of the year.
*   **Audit Scope:** The Project Manager stated that the scope of work will be put into a Request for Proposal (RFP) document, to be published in early spring 2023. The subgroup will serve on the evaluation committee for the vendor selection.
*   **Urban Renewal Data:** Dr. Messinia and the team stated they will release an executive report with more detailed graphics and a companion paper. Priscilla Robinson stated she is willing to collaborate with other communities (e.g., East End) if invited.
*   **Community Engagement:** The Project Manager stated she will send a link to commission members to sign up for upcoming community events to represent the commission.

## Impact
This meeting marked significant progress in the commission's mandate to document historical harms and propose remedies. The presentation of specific, auditable data regarding urban renewal provides a concrete foundation for understanding how municipal actions contributed to the loss of intergenerational wealth in the South Side. The finalized scope for the performance audit signals a shift toward rigorous accountability for taxpayer-funded programs serving the African-American community. Furthermore, the detailed proposals from the Education and Health and Wellness IFAs outline specific, actionable steps to address current disparities in student outcomes and healthcare access, moving the commission from research toward concrete policy recommendations.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BLrpQLU_buE
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2659/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BLrpQLU_buE)
