# Human Relations Commission – March 16, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Human Relations Commission of Asheville
**Date:** March 16, 2023 6:00 PM EDT (2023-03-16T18:00:06-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4821/human-relations-commission-march-16-2023
**Outcome:** The Human Relations Commission unanimously recommended that City Council adopt a local ordinance protecting residents from hair-based discrimination and tabled the proposal to move to virtual meetings.

## Summary

The Human Relations Commission of Asheville held a regular meeting on March 16, 2023. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, staff updates, discussions on unfinished business regarding the Crown Act and non-discrimination complaints, new business concerning meeting formats, and updates from various working groups.

## Key Decisions
The Commission unanimously approved the minutes from the January 19, 2023 meeting. Additionally, the Commission voted unanimously to recommend that the City Council adopt a local ordinance based on the North Carolina Crown Act (HB 170), which would protect residents against hair-based discrimination. Regarding the proposal to move from in-person to virtual meetings, the Commission did not take a vote; instead, the discussion was tabled for a future meeting to allow for further deliberation on accessibility and quorum requirements.

## Discussion Highlights
During the discussion on the Crown Act, the Chair expressed enthusiasm for the local ordinance, stating, "I'm looking forward to seeing it go far here in Asheville and set a precedent for protecting the black community here in Asheville from discrimination." The City Attorney noted that the state-level bill had a "very, very low chance of becoming law with the current makeup of the legislature," suggesting it might not even receive a vote.

Staff presented information on how residents can file complaints with the City, including through the Asheville app, customer service lines, and the Non-Discrimination Ordinance. The discussion covered the investigation process, retaliation protections, and data sharing with Buncombe County. In a related discussion on housing, a Commissioner highlighted concerns about the 5,000-person housing waiting list, stating, "I used to run a housing program in the city and when I would call these places, those units weren't available or weren't affordable... I called for a watchdog to knock on these doors and find out if these people are still there."

The Commission also debated the logistics of meeting locations. A Commissioner advocated for holding meetings in various neighborhoods, stating, "I think that's part of what the HRCA should be looking at, is meeting people where they are. And that means you go into their neighborhoods... The meetings that we've had the most attendance at were when we went outside of this." Updates were also provided on the Community Engagement, Housing, and Intergovernmental Relations working groups.

## Follow-ups
Staff member Elena Schmidt, identified as the Equity and Inclusion Analyst, agreed to several actions: to check records regarding the commission’s meeting history during the pandemic to clarify attendance data for in-person versus virtual meetings; to look into specific requirements for holding un-streamed meetings in community centers; to provide a link to the General Boards and Commissions Manual and HRCA procedures via email; to obtain the housing report mentioned by a Commissioner and the presentation materials from the Affordable Housing Commission to share with HRCA members; and to coordinate with the Development Department to get specific numbers on affordable housing units coming online. The City Attorney stated that staff would work to bring resources to a future agenda to answer questions about the 5,000-person housing waiting list and the transition from HUD to RAD data.

## Impact
The unanimous recommendation to adopt the local Crown Act is significant for residents, as it seeks to establish local protections against hair-based discrimination, particularly for the Black community, independent of the state legislature's actions. The ongoing discussion regarding meeting formats and locations reflects the Commission's intent to improve accessibility and community engagement by meeting residents in their neighborhoods. Furthermore, the staff's commitment to gathering specific data on affordable housing and clarifying complaint procedures aims to provide the Commission with better tools to address housing inequities and ensure residents understand how to utilize city resources for non-discrimination complaints.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sNXzuWe5hVA
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2662/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sNXzuWe5hVA)
