# Historic Resources Commission – March 8, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Historic Resources Commission
**Date:** March 8, 2023 4:01 PM EST (2023-03-08T16:01:11-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4833/historic-resources-commission-march-8-2023
**Outcome:** The Commission approved the Kingsland Alley and Walton Street Park applications and continued the Houston Street application to April.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission met on March 8, 2023, to review applications for Certificates of Appropriateness (COA) and address administrative matters. The Commission began by approving the minutes from the February 2023 meeting unanimously. The primary agenda items involved four COA applications: alterations at Biltmore Village, new construction in the Montford Historic District, and improvements to Walton Street Park.

**Key Decisions**
The Commission made the following decisions on the COA applications:
*   **Biltmore Village at Brookside and Hendersonville Road:** The application for alterations and demolition was continued to the April meeting unanimously.
*   **Montford Historic District at 109 Kingsland Alley:** The COA application was approved unanimously. The certificate was issued with the condition that the applicant verify the texture of the garage doors to confirm they are smooth metal rather than wood-embossed.
*   **Walton Street Park:** The COA application was approved unanimously. The certificate was issued with conditions requiring the submission of playground equipment specifications and a site lighting plan.
*   **Montford Historic District at 8 Houston Street:** The application for a new primary structure was continued to the April meeting unanimously. The Commission determined that the lack of a stucco sample and unresolved site plan details regarding the retaining wall and railing made it difficult to approve the application at that time.

**Discussion Highlights**
The most extensive discussion centered on the 8 Houston Street application, which involves a new structure on a small, steeply sloped lot. Chair Emily Kite expressed comfort with the changes to the building itself but requested a sample of the proposed synthetic stucco finish. She also suggested shifting the building footprint to allow for a fence in front of the retaining wall rather than on top of it. Commissioner Annie McDonald noted that the building design respectfully recalls historic features of Montford while appearing as new construction. She suggested that future design guidelines consider prohibiting fences above retaining walls in front yards, though she cautioned that such a rule might not anticipate specific new construction where such a feature could be congruous with the district’s character.

Staff member Alex Smith noted that no one had previously proposed synthetic stucco to the Commission and emphasized the need for a physical sample. He also clarified that the proposed feature on the wall should be classified as a railing rather than a fence. Commissioner Alexander Ellenbogen suggested that if zoning regulations allowed, stairs leading down to the backyard could be used to prevent the railing from being visible from the front of the house. Property owner Aaron Zellner stated he was open to making necessary changes, including replacing crepe myrtles with more indigenous species, and explained that the building’s footprint was minimized to 1,100 square feet to avoid overwhelming the lot.

Regarding the Historic Resources Champion Award, staff provided context on the award’s history, explaining it was formerly the Sodley Award but was renamed in 2021 to address historical exclusionary stipulations. Staff requested nominations from members. Additionally, the Commission discussed the appointment of a nominating committee for the new slate of officers.

**Community Input**
A public commenter, identifying himself as a member of the development community and a former commission member, spoke regarding the 8 Houston Street application. He noted that the application’s floor area ratio was approximately 0.73 and suggested the Commission consider floor area ratios and precedent-setting materials as difficult infill projects become more common. He stated he had no specific objections to the application but wanted to highlight these considerations for the future. In response, a commission member asked if there is a maximum ratio of floor area to site square footage. Chair Emily Kite replied, "There was some advocating for that. So it's not been incorporated into the guidelines."

During the discussion of the Historic Resources Champion Award, a public commenter requested that the Commission consider Jack Thompson for the award. The commenter detailed Thompson’s 19-year career in preservation, including his role as Executive Director of the Preservation Society of Asheville and Buncombe County (2010–2021) and his current role as Western Regional Director for Preservation North Carolina. The Chair thanked the commenter, and no other members responded to the specific nomination.

**Follow-ups**
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting:
*   For the 109 Kingsland Alley application, the applicant’s representative agreed to follow up with staff to verify the texture of the garage doors.
*   For the Walton Street Park application, the applicant (Parks Department) agreed to submit playground equipment specifications and a finalized site lighting plan to staff for review.
*   For the 8 Houston Street application, the property owner/architect agreed to provide a sample of the proposed synthetic stucco finish, revise the site plan to clarify the relationship between the retaining wall and the railing/fence, provide detailed window and mechanical unit specifications, and revise the landscaping plan to replace crepe myrtles with more native species. The applicant requested a continuance to the April meeting to address these items and stated they would confer with staff to codify the discussion points.
*   Staff asked members to send nominations for the Historic Resources Champion Award, along with a summary of why the candidate is suitable, between now and the next meeting. Staff will bring this information to the Commission for a vote so the award can be presented at the Griffin Awards.
*   Regarding the nominating committee, the Chair stated the Commission would like to appoint Shannon Watkins, Annie McDonald, and Maria Delsasi as members. Staff agreed to circle back with these three members between now and the next meeting to discuss next steps.

**Impact**
These decisions impact the preservation and development of historic properties in Asheville. The approvals for 109 Kingsland Alley and Walton Street Park allow for new construction and park improvements that are compatible with the historic character of their respective districts, subject to the specified conditions. The continuance of the 8 Houston Street application ensures that the Commission can review additional details regarding materials and site layout before making a final decision on a new structure in a sensitive historic district. The review of the Historic Resources Champion Award and the formation of a nominating committee will help the Commission recognize preservation efforts and prepare for upcoming leadership changes.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AlbxESjAZog
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3130/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AlbxESjAZog)
