# City Council Work Session, McCormick Field Project – February 14, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** February 14, 2023 3:17 PM EST (2023-02-14T15:17:41-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4850/city-council-work-session-mccormick-field-project-february-14-2023

## Summary

The Asheville City Council held a work session on February 14, 2023, to discuss the future of McCormick Field, the city-owned minor league baseball stadium. No votes were taken on the McCormick Field project during this session, as the Chair clarified that the meeting was for informational purposes only. The Council agreed to return to a formal meeting on March 14, 2023, to vote on whether to proceed with the project.

In addition to the McCormick Field discussion, the Council recorded several other votes on routine and specific agenda items. Councilwoman Turner moved for the adoption of the Consent Agenda, which was seconded by Councilwoman Ullman and carried unanimously. Councilwoman Turner also moved to adopt a resolution to permanently close an unopened right-of-way connecting to the east side of Buncombe Street between Commerce Street and another street; this motion passed. Furthermore, Councilwoman Turner moved to approve the Land Use Incentive Grant application for Cohen-Esrey Development Group at 157 New Leicester Highway, which passed. Councilwoman Mosley moved to approve the conditional zoning request for the property located at 157 and 99999 New Leicester Highway from Residential Multi-Family High Density to another zoning classification, and this motion passed.

The Council also voted to continue a public hearing until May 23, 2023, a motion moved by Councilwoman Turner and seconded by Councilwoman Ullman that carried unanimously. Following a brief discussion, Councilwoman Turner moved to authorize the adoption of a resolution allowing the City Manager to sign a funding letter of commitment, which passed. In a non-unanimous vote, Councilwoman Roney moved to instruct City staff to prepare a letter to the N.C. Dept. of Transportation acknowledging Council's support of the I-26 aesthetic redesign; this motion passed with a 5-1 tally, with Councilwoman Ullman voting no.

Vice-Mayor Kilgore moved to appoint Joe Balcken to serve as a member of the AARRC for a three-year term, which passed. Vice-Mayor Kilgore also moved to appoint Michael McDonough as an at-large member of the Design Review Committee to serve the unexpired term of Kimberly Hunter, which passed. Finally, Vice-Mayor Kilgore moved to appoint Michael Fulbright to fill the unexpired term of Karl Knight, with the term to expire July 1, 2024, or until a successor is appointed, and this motion passed.

## Discussion Highlights

Staff presented a detailed analysis of McCormick Field’s condition, noting that the facility is currently in the bottom 10% of minor league facilities in the U.S. due to a "reverse health score" of 177 points. Major League Baseball requires the facility to be under 30 points by April 1, 2023, to retain its affiliation. Chris Corral, Director of Community and Regional Entertainment Facilities, stated, "We're currently at 177 points, which is obviously way high compared to what Major League Baseball would like. And that puts us in the bottom 10% of all minor league facilities." Staff outlined two renovation options: a Minimum Project costing $19.6 million to meet MLB standards and a Full Project costing $37.5 million that includes additional pro-sport and fan amenities to support multi-use events.

Staff noted that the team generates approximately $9.8 million in annual economic impact for Buncombe County. Tony McDowell, Director of Finance, explained the financial implications, stating, "This funding is not currently included in our multiyear capital improvement debt model... We will either have to look at reducing or delaying some planned spending in the five-year CIP, or additional resources will have to be put into the CIP." He added that the city’s share of the debt service would be approximately $950,000 to $1 million annually. Staff recommended the Full Project due to its greater long-term flexibility and revenue potential, contingent on commitments from partners including the team, Buncombe County, and the Tourism Development Authority.

Council members raised concerns regarding the impact of increased stadium activity on surrounding neighborhoods, particularly in the East End and Oakhurst areas. One Council member expressed concern that neighbors in East End Valley Street were not broadly supportive of more concerts and fireworks, stating, "I would be really surprised if there was a broad support for more concerts and fireworks and noise... I really would love to hear from neighborhood that this is a benefit." Another Council member spoke on behalf of the East End community, noting concerns that increased activity could lead to further gentrification, and stated, "The ideal goal would be... coming up with benefits that benefit the larger community, but with an emphasis on the black and brown communities."

Another Council member asked if the lease could include provisions for free or discounted tickets for low-income community members. Staff responded that the team already provides free and discounted tickets and that they could explore a contractual tie-in with Parks and Rec programming to ensure broader community access. A Council member also asked how to ensure more local, minority-owned businesses are represented in the stadium’s concessions and retail spaces. Staff confirmed that less than 25% of local products are beer and that there is an effort to include more diverse local goods. The Chair stated, "I think some of that will have to come from us in terms of the direction... I think we need to have a conversation with the neighborhood about... what is a way we could... do with those revenues? What could we do that would benefit more directly the neighborhoods so that that would make sense?"

## Follow-ups

Staff agreed to provide a breakdown of the cost difference between the minimum and full projects, specifically regarding multi-use capabilities. Chris Corral stated, "we have the breakdown of that difference certainly bring that back to this group." Staff also acknowledged that no direct community meetings had been held regarding non-baseball uses. Chris Corral stated, "I suppose there can be [community meetings] before we vote." Council members emphasized the need for focused outreach to neighborhoods to determine acceptable levels of event activity and to identify direct benefits for the community.

Staff agreed to clarify the financial impact of the $4 million capital improvement requests in years 7 and 14 of the lease. Chris Corral confirmed these are not currently in the debt service calculation but would need to be programmed into the Capital Improvement Plan. Staff is in the process of finalizing lease terms with the team ownership group, DeWine Seed Silver Dollar Baseball Inc., including provisions for naming rights, sponsorship, and community benefits. Staff confirmed they would submit a letter of commitment to MLB by the end of March.

## Impact

This discussion matters to residents because it addresses the future of a significant local and regional asset. Staff presented that McCormick Field is a "pretty important regional asset" and that investment could turn a potential liability into a bigger asset for the community. The decision on whether to proceed with the $19.6 million or $37.5 million project will affect the city's budget, potentially requiring reprogramming of existing capital improvement funds or adding new resources to cover debt service. The outcome will also determine the level of non-baseball events, such as concerts and festivals, that may take place at the stadium, which has raised concerns about noise, traffic, and gentrification in nearby neighborhoods. The Council will vote on the project at a formal meeting on March 14, 2023.

## Votes

- Councilwoman Turner moved for the adoption of the Consent Agenda.  This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Ullman and carried unanimously. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4850/city-council-work-session-mccormick-field-project-february-14-2023#vote-18462))
- Councilwoman Turner moved to adopt a resolution to permanently close an unopened right-of-way connecting to the east side of Buncombe Street between Commerce Street and Aston Street, associated with the Central United Methodist Church.  This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Mosley and carried unanimously. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4850/city-council-work-session-mccormick-field-project-february-14-2023#vote-18465))
- Councilwoman Turner moved to approve the Land Use Incentive Grant application for for Cohen-Esrey Development Group at 157 New Leicester Highway.  This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Mosley and carried unanimously. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4850/city-council-work-session-mccormick-field-project-february-14-2023#vote-18468))
- Councilwoman Mosley moved to approve the conditional zoning request for the property located at 157 and 99999 New Leicester Hwy from Residential Multi-Family High Density (RM-16) and Highway Business (HB) to Residential Expansion - Conditional Zone (RES EXP-CZ) and find that the request is reasonable, is in the public interest, is consistent with the city's comprehensive plan and meets the development needs of the community in that the request: 1) provides infill development in targeted growth areas; 2) increases the supply of affordable housing in proximity to schools, transit and parks; and, 3) promotes the development and availability of affordable and workforce housing. This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Turner and carried unanimously. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4850/city-council-work-session-mccormick-field-project-february-14-2023#vote-18472))
- Councilwoman Turner moved to continue this public hearing until May 23, 2023.  This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Ullman and carried unanimously. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4850/city-council-work-session-mccormick-field-project-february-14-2023#vote-18473))
- After a brief discussion, Councilwoman Turner moved to authorize adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to sign a funding letter of commitment to the N.C. Dept. of Transportation regarding the City betterments and aesthetics treatments for Project I-2513B and I-2514D in the amount of $7,301,924.  This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Ullman and carried unanimously. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4850/city-council-work-session-mccormick-field-project-february-14-2023#vote-18474))
- Councilwoman Roney moved to instruct City staff to prepare a letter to the N.C. Dept. of Transportation acknowledging Council's support of the I-26 aesthetic recommendations by impacted neighborhoods of Burton Street, Montford and Hillcrest.  This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Turner and carried on a 5-1 vote, with Councilwoman Ullman voting "no." Councilwoman Ullman wanted to support Councilwoman Roney's request, but without seeing what the impacted neighborhood recommendations were, she would not be able to support the motion. — Passed, 5-1 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4850/city-council-work-session-mccormick-field-project-february-14-2023#vote-18476))
- Vice-Mayor Kilgore moved to appoint Joe Balcken (district business or property owner seat) to serve as a member of the AARRC, to serve a three-year term, term to expire January 1, 2026, or until Joe Balcken's success has been appointed; and readvertise for the other district business or property owner seat. This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Turner and carried unanimously. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4850/city-council-work-session-mccormick-field-project-february-14-2023#vote-18481))
- Vice-Mayor Kilgore moved to appoint Michael McDonough as an at-large member of the Design Review Committee, to serve the unexpired term of Kimberly Hunter, term to expire December 31, 2023, or until Michael McDonough's successor has been appointed.   This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Roney and carried unanimously. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4850/city-council-work-session-mccormick-field-project-february-14-2023#vote-18482))
- Vice-Mayor Kilgore moved to (1) appoint Michael Fulbright (28801 representative) to fill the unexpired term of Karl Knight, term to expire July 1, 2024, or until Michael Fulbright's successor has been appointed; and (2) appoint Jaik Smith (at-large representative) to fill the unexpired term of Mike Wasmer, term to expire July 1 2024, or until Jaik Smith's successor has been appointed. This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Turner and carried unanimously. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4850/city-council-work-session-mccormick-field-project-february-14-2023#vote-18484))

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6bE7zO013QY
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2686/segments

## Documents

- [minutes_2023-02-14_from_packet_26332.md](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4850/documents/30122/minutes-2023-02-14-from-packet-26332md)

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6bE7zO013QY)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
