# Urban Forestry Commission – February 7, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Urban Forestry Commission
**Date:** February 7, 2023 1:05 PM EST (2023-02-07T13:05:29-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4859/urban-forestry-commission-february-7-2023

## Summary

The Urban Forestry Commission of the City of Asheville convened on February 7, 2023, to review alternative compliance requests for landscape standards, receive updates on municipal facilities, and discuss ongoing working group initiatives. The meeting focused primarily on four development projects seeking waivers from standard street tree requirements due to site constraints such as underground utilities, narrow sidewalks, and existing infrastructure.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The Commission voted unanimously (5-0) to approve the minutes from the previous meeting. Regarding the alternative compliance requests, the Commission voted 5-0 to approve the waiver for one street tree at 717 Haywood Road, 5-0 to approve the waiver for seven street trees at 680 Haywood Road, and 6-0 to approve the waiver for two street trees at 197 Hilliard Avenue. The most contentious item was the request for 23 & 25 Elizabeth Place and 183 Broadway Street. After an amendment was proposed to condition approval on the receipt of a tree removal inventory, the Commission voted 4-2 to approve the alternative compliance request. The affirmative votes were cast by Zoe Hoyle, Patrick Gilbert, Karen Macneil, and Chair Amy Smith, while Chardin Detrich and Cecil voted against. The Chair clarified that the Commission is making a recommendation to the Planning Director, who holds the final decision authority. Additionally, the Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to recommend funding for a comprehensive urban forestry program, including an urban forest inventory and master plan, to be presented to City Council.

**Discussion Highlights**
During the review of the 183 Broadway Street project, significant debate arose regarding the preservation of existing mature trees. Cecil expressed strong opposition, stating, "I am... once again disturbed that over and over again, it seems to me that we are pressed to not enforce the idea of preservation, but instead offer the exceptional level of we'll put a few sticks in the ground and that will compensate. I'm sorry, I can't support this." Chardin Detrich echoed these sentiments, noting that the process seemed to be "business as usual, not prioritizing the trees that are already there in the planning process." In response, Mark Foster, the City Arborist, provided context on the specific species on site, noting, "My familiarity with the site is that there's a lot of Ailanthus and Polonia, a lot of locusts, some silver maple, a busted up pine tree. It's not the sort of stand of trees that, you know, at the hill you want to die on when you're familiar with the actual trees on site." Patrick Gilbert indicated that seeing an actual tree inventory list of what would be lost would help him move forward with the approval.

Updates were also provided on the Municipal Golf Course, where Chris Corral, Director of Community and Regional Entertainment Facilities, reported that the number of trees to be removed was reduced from 157 to 111, with 83 trees scheduled for pruning. A third-party arborist is overseeing the work, and a $30,000 grant from the Donald Ross Society Foundation was awarded for a master plan. Mark Foster also reported on routine operations, including storm cleanup and the upcoming planting of 35 trees in March.

**Community Input**
A public commenter from the Tree Protection Task Force expressed concern that the 183 Broadway Street project represents a loss of climate resilience through the removal of mature trees, arguing that trees are often treated as an afterthought in the planning process. In response to this comment, Cecil and Chardin Detrich voiced their opposition to the waiver, while Mark Foster provided the technical assessment of the tree species mentioned above. Nancy, the Stormwater Supervisor, clarified that the Commission is making a recommendation to the Planning Director rather than approving or denying the project outright. Another public commenter attempted to discuss non-native plants in the 183 Broadway plan but was unable to connect initially; Sam Starbaum, a Planner, provided his direct contact information to the commenter to discuss the item offline, as that agenda item had already passed. A third public commenter asked an advance question regarding revisions to Section 711 of the code concerning exemptions for small infill developments, but members did not respond directly to this specific question during the meeting.

**Follow-ups**
The Commission approved the 183 Broadway alternative compliance conditional upon the applicant providing a tree removal inventory. Sam Starbaum and the applicant agreed to provide this material to staff for distribution. Regarding the Policy Working Group, Mark Foster and Ed Macy, a consultant, agreed to meet on Thursday to resolve confusion regarding which version of the Chapter 20 document was being reviewed by Public Works and Legal. Mark Foster stated he would check the document on his personal email to verify the version. Zoe Hoyle proposed that the Fee & Loo Funds working group meet again this month to finalize prioritization questions, with the goal of sharing something with the full Commission at the next meeting. Additionally, Dawn Chavez stated that a request for a proclamation for National Invasive Species Awareness Week will be presented to City Council the following week.

**Impact**
These decisions reflect the Commission's ongoing effort to balance development needs with urban canopy preservation. The approval of the 183 Broadway alternative compliance, contingent on a tree inventory, highlights the tension between new construction and the retention of existing vegetation. The unanimous recommendation to fund a comprehensive urban forestry program, including an inventory and master plan, signals a strategic shift toward data-driven management of the city's trees. This plan will be taken to City Council by Councilwoman Kim Roney for further consideration and potential funding approval.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZFwukRMP_EI
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3164/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZFwukRMP_EI)
