# Reparations Commission – January 9, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Reparations Commission
**Date:** January 9, 2023 5:57 PM EST (2023-01-09T17:57:52-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4878/reparations-commission-january-9-2023
**Outcome:** The Reparations Commission approved the previous minutes unanimously and discussed a proposed 2023 timeline, a draft audit resolution, and a Code of Ethics, deferring votes on those items to the next meeting.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Reparations Commission held a meeting on January 9, 2023. The session focused on reviewing survey data, discussing the definition of reparations, and receiving presentations on the city and county’s response to previous recommendations. The commission also reviewed a proposed Code of Ethics and a new project timeline.

## Key Decisions
The only formal vote taken at this meeting was the unanimous approval of the minutes from the previous meeting. No other items were voted on. The proposed Code of Ethics, the draft resolution for an audit, and the 2023 project timeline were all presented for review and feedback but were not approved or finalized. Staff indicated that the timeline and template would be voted on at the next meeting after incorporating member feedback.

## Discussion Highlights
Staff presented data from a survey conducted after the December 5th meeting, noting that feedback was largely positive regarding communication, though respondents requested improved meeting structure and clearer definitions of reparations. During the discussion on the definition of reparations, a commissioner expressed concern that local governments may lack the economic bandwidth for full reparations, potentially leading to legal challenges, and suggested informal conversations to clarify scope.

Assistant City Manager Rachel Wood and Assistant County Manager DK Wesley presented a draft resolution to the City Council and Buncombe County Commission. This resolution authorizes staff to develop a scope of work for an audit to ensure compliance with federal and state laws and to cease further harm. Wood stated the intent is to ensure the scope of work meets the spirit of the immediate recommendation.

Marsha Davis, Executive Director of the Zedek Social Justice Fund, and Lydie Kyle, Director of Community-Led Grant Making, presented the Reparations Stakeholder Authority of Asheville (RSAA), a private organization for Black residents to direct private reparations funds. They reported raising $241,615 from 43 donors since January 2022. Davis emphasized that the RSAA operates in solidarity with, not opposition to, the commission.

New Project Manager Christine Edwards presented a proposed 2023 project timeline that proposes a closeout in late 2023. This timeline drew concern from members regarding the shortened deliberation period. Edwards clarified that the timeline had not been approved and would be voted on at the next meeting. Spokespersons for the Economic Development and Education Impact Focus Areas (IFAs) provided updates, including capacity building grants for legacy neighborhoods and recommendations for Black teacher recruitment and student suspension policies.

## Follow-ups
Several staff members and commission members agreed to specific follow-up actions:
*   **Rachel Wood (Assistant City Manager):** Agreed to email an updated draft resolution for final feedback and provide regular updates on city/county projects impacting the community.
*   **DK Wesley (Assistant County Manager):** Agreed to work with the Chair and Vice Chair to plan future agendas and identify projects for discussion.
*   **Christine Edwards (Project Manager):** Agreed to send emails regarding onboarding agreements for stipends, incorporate feedback on the timeline and template, and present updated items for a vote at the next meeting.
*   **Brad Bradley (Vice City Attorney):** Agreed to be available with Michael Sprua to answer questions about the Code of Ethics outside of meetings.
*   **Chair (Dr. Mullen):** Agreed to host virtual or in-person meetings with commissioners or the public to discuss the definition of reparations if requested via survey.
*   **Commissioner Dee Williams:** Requested an updated project team and commission member list; staff agreed to provide this.
*   **Commissioner Dwayne Richardson:** Requested that the commission connect with DOT and city/county departments to be aware of future plans; staff agreed to mention known projects in future agenda planning.

## Impact
This meeting marked a transition in the commission’s operational phase, introducing a new project manager and a proposed timeline for 2023 that aims to close out the project by the end of the year. The presentation of the draft audit resolution signals the city and county’s intent to move forward with compliance checks and harm cessation measures, with votes scheduled for January 24 (City) and February 7 (County). Additionally, the introduction of the RSAA provides a parallel channel for private reparations funds, while the discussion on the Code of Ethics aims to establish ethical standards and trustworthiness for the commission’s ongoing work.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZUaPMkLz_FY
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2712/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZUaPMkLz_FY)
