# Noise Advisory Board

**Body:** City of Asheville — Noise Advisory Board
**Date:** December 12, 2022 1:00 PM EST (2022-12-12T13:00:09-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4886/noise-advisory-board-dec-12-2022
**Outcome:** The Noise Advisory Board changed its meeting frequency to monthly and discussed draft recommendations on vehicle noise and a downtown waste hauling task force.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Noise Advisory Board held its meeting on December 12, 2022. The agenda included the introduction of a new member, review of staff reports, discussion of noise measurement complexities, and deliberations on vehicle noise and waste hauling issues.

## Key Decisions
The board took three formal votes during the meeting, all of which were approved unanimously. First, the board approved the minutes from the previous meeting. Second, the board voted to hold a meeting in January. Third, the board voted to change its meeting frequency from quarterly to monthly, starting in January, until the board determines there is insufficient work to continue at that cadence. No votes were taken on the draft vehicle noise recommendation or the downtown waste hauling proposal; both items were discussed but not formally adopted.

## Discussion Highlights
The board reviewed staff reports for November and December, noting that staff are working on 2023 noise log templates to allow for month-to-month and year-to-year comparisons. A significant portion of the discussion focused on the complexity of measuring low-frequency sound and the distinction between objective decibel levels and subjective nuisance. Rick Freeman expressed hope for obtaining objective data through baseline and active noise measurements at properties where complainants have agreed to measurements. Todd Justice, the Noise Administrator, identified the major issues as the subjective standard in residential communities compared to the objective standard in commercial properties, as well as vehicle noise. Regarding vehicle noise, Reb Haizlip described the issue as "fairly straightforward" and suggested a recommendation for the board to ask City Council to direct changes in the noise ordinance to reduce or prohibit intentional vehicular noise. The board also discussed a proposal to form a task force to address early morning waste hauling noise in the downtown area, with Rick Freeman explaining the logistical challenges of multiple waste haulers accessing narrow alleys.

## Community Input
The board reviewed written public comments submitted via email prior to the meeting; no verbal public comments were made during the session. One written comment discussed the subjectivity of noise, noting that sounds like unamplified buskers are perceived as noise while others are not, and mentioned the difficulty of enforcing vehicle noise regulations. Another comment described low-frequency sound from venues shaking windows and doors, preventing sleep even when standard decibel levels did not appear high. In response to these comments, a board member questioned how well the subjective nuisance clause is working in practice, asking about the experience of the compliance team. Another board member acknowledged the confusion in distinguishing between personal decisions, noise, and quality of life issues, stating, "I don't know if there's a good way of doing that." A third board member expressed appreciation for the enforcement team's efforts to navigate these complicated issues.

## Follow-ups
Several members and staff agreed to specific follow-up actions. Staff member Haley stated that staff are working on 2023 noise log templates. A staff member agreed to look into including population growth data in future reports to contextualize complaint numbers, with Jessica Tomasin offering to help find this information. Rick Freeman stated he would work with Noise Administrator Todd Justice to plan baseline and active noise measurements. Reb Haizlip stated she would send the draft vehicle noise recommendation and a copy of the World Health Organization guidelines for community noise to the board for review. Board members agreed to read the vehicle noise draft and provide feedback at least five days before the next meeting. Rick Freeman stated he would draft resolution language for a downtown waste hauling task force to be reviewed at the next meeting.

## Impact
This meeting established a more frequent meeting schedule to address ongoing noise concerns, shifting from quarterly to monthly sessions. The board’s focus on obtaining objective data through specific measurements aims to provide a clearer basis for future recommendations regarding noise limits. The discussions on vehicle noise and waste hauling highlight the board's intent to address specific sources of community disturbance, with the vehicle noise recommendation moving toward a formal request for ordinance changes and the waste hauling issue moving toward the formation of a task force.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5s5st5Zcxo
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3153/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5s5st5Zcxo)
