# Urban Forestry Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Urban Forestry Commission
**Date:** December 6, 2022 1:00 PM EST (2022-12-06T13:00:17-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4892/urban-forestry-commission-dec-6-2022
**Outcome:** The Urban Forestry Commission unanimously adopted a recommendation for an independent arborist review of the golf course tree removal plan and a resolution to protect heritage trees.

## Summary

On December 6, 2022, the City of Asheville Urban Forestry Commission convened to address several key governance and policy matters, most notably the renovation of the Municipal Golf Course and the associated tree removal plan. The meeting also covered updates from various working groups, the adoption of a heritage trees resolution, and the election of commission officers.

## Key Decisions
The Commission took several formal votes during the session. First, the body unanimously approved the minutes from the previous November meeting. Second, the Commission unanimously adopted a formal recommendation regarding the Municipal Golf Course tree removal plan. This recommendation, moved by the Chair and seconded by Patrick Gilbert, directs that an independent certified arborist review all trees slated for removal using ANSI A300 Part 9 standards, that a detailed replanting plan focusing on native species be provided, that soil testing and chemical usage data be shared, and that alternatives to removal, such as pruning, be explored.

Additionally, the Commission unanimously adopted a resolution urging the City of Asheville to protect and steward "heritage trees," defined as trees 30 inches or greater in diameter or those with historical significance. The resolution calls for amending the tree canopy ordinance to include double credits for preserving these trees and double penalties for removing them. This resolution is to be sent to City Council for discussion. Finally, the Commission unanimously re-elected Amy Smith as Chair and Dawn Chavez as Vice Chair.

## Discussion Highlights
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to a presentation by Chris Corral, Director of the Community and Regional Entertainment Facilities Department, regarding the $3.5 million renovation of the Municipal Golf Course. Corral detailed the course’s physical condition, noting challenges with stormwater, drainage, and fairways, and stated that the replanting plan meets city ordinances for overall canopy. However, the discussion focused heavily on the methodology for removing approximately 150–200 trees. Patrick Gilbert expressed skepticism about the risk assessments, stating he did not see typical risk assessment language and requested a more technical assessment. Ed Macy similarly struggled with the risk assessments, noting they did not appear to follow A300 Part 9 standards. Mark Matheny, Interim Director of Development Services, explained that his decision to remove certain trees was based on experience and training after a field trip, rather than formal track forms. Karen McNeil raised concerns about soil health, suggesting that soil deterioration might be affecting grass health and causing issues like oak wilt.

Other discussions included updates from working groups. The Policy Working Group reported that one-third of proposed amendments to the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance were agreed upon, one-third opposed, and one-third required further inquiry. The Budget Working Group suggested an initial request of $275,000 for forest assessment and plan creation. The Commission also discussed the "Missing Middle Housing" initiative, with the Chair agreeing to ensure the Commission is included in stakeholder discussions. Regarding the Ravenscroft Reserve, the Commission noted that land ownership has transferred and the price has increased to approximately $2.5 million, making purchase unlikely at this time.

## Community Input
Three members of the public provided comments regarding the Municipal Golf Course tree removal plan, echoing concerns raised by approximately 80 written comments. One public commenter expressed concern that the designation of trees as dead or diseased was based on "sketchy" plans by the new operator and argued the plan violated the zero-net-loss tree protection ordinance. Another public commenter questioned why the course was not adopting sustainable, organic landscaping practices to reduce aquifer pollution and asked if soil testing had been conducted to determine if chemical fertilizers were causing oak wilt. A third public commenter expressed support for restoring the golf course but urged the city to prioritize tree trimming over cutting, arguing that the new operator needed to earn trust by working with arborists to save mature trees. No specific member or staff member verbally addressed the individual concerns during the public comment period; these concerns were subsequently addressed during the Q&A session with the staff presenter.

## Follow-ups
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Chris Corral agreed to provide answers to questions regarding soil tests and the use of chemicals or herbicides. Amy Smith, Chair, agreed to reach out to planning staff to request that the Urban Forestry Commission be included as a stakeholder in the missing middle housing study. Ed Macy agreed to circle back with staff to ask for a timeline on the rollout of landscaping amendments and silva cells criteria. Cecil Bothwell volunteered to review the Recommended Species List to identify species readily available in local nurseries. Karen McNeil agreed to communicate with Mark Matheny regarding making the Recommended Species List more user-friendly. Staff agreed to review the status of ordinance revisions regarding commission membership limits during the upcoming retreat and to send a copy of the Heritage Trees resolution to a staff member for linking to the action minutes. Additionally, GreenWorks is holding late pickup dates for the tree adoption event on the upcoming Saturday and Tuesday, with remaining trees to be donated to the City of Black Mountain.

## Impact
This meeting highlights the Commission’s role in balancing urban development with environmental stewardship. The formal recommendation on the golf course renovation sets a precedent for requiring independent arborist reviews and detailed replanting plans for major city projects. The adoption of the heritage trees resolution aims to provide stronger protections for significant trees through potential ordinance amendments, which will now be considered by City Council. Furthermore, the updates on the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance and the Recommended Species List indicate ongoing efforts to refine city policies to better support a healthy urban forest and provide clearer guidance to residents and developers.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eETiS5y8Ww8
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2720/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eETiS5y8Ww8)
