# Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee
**Date:** November 30, 2022 9:01 AM EST (2022-11-30T09:01:11-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4894/homeless-initiative-advisory-committee-nov-30-2022

## Summary

On November 30, 2022, the City of Asheville’s Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee (HIAC) convened to review winter sheltering efforts, housing data, and upcoming funding decisions. The joint City/County committee focused on the status of the Emergency Solutions Grant, the implementation of new winter shelters, and the operational logistics of Code Purple.

## Key Decisions
The committee took several formal votes during the session. A motion to approve the consent agenda was made and seconded, but no vote is recorded in the summary. Regarding winter shelter funding, the committee voted 9-1-1 to approve continued funding for the Asheville Ecumenical Winter Shelter as originally awarded; the vote included one "No" and one abstention. A separate motion to reopen the proposal process for the $9,940 previously awarded to the Salvation Army, which could not provide shelter, passed unanimously. The committee also unanimously voted to delegate the final decision on supplemental winter shelter funding to the Finance Workgroup.

In terms of meeting operations, a motion to meet 100% remotely for the next year failed, as it did not receive the required two-thirds majority. Consequently, the committee will continue to meet in person for the next 12 months. The committee unanimously agreed to meet on the second Thursday of the month at 9:00 AM and unanimously voted to skip the December meeting, with the next session scheduled for January.

## Discussion Highlights
The meeting included reports on the Emergency Solutions Grant (ESG) and local eviction trends. It was confirmed that the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services approved the ESG application for $128,187 to support shelter, homelessness prevention, and rapid rehousing programs in 2023, with contracts expected to be finalized in the coming month. David Bartholomew, Program Director for the Homeless Prevention Program at Pisgah Legal Services, presented data showing that over 50% of households in Western North Carolina are cost-burdened. He noted that eviction filings in Buncombe County reached 249 summary ejectments in October 2022, the highest number since 2018, and stated, "We're seeing a lot more holdover evictions in western North Carolina because of the rent increases... We're seeing just some landlords deciding not to renew a lease."

Winter sheltering operations were a central topic. A public commenter from ABCCM reported that the Veterans Restoration Quarters (VRQ) and Transformation Village (TRV) are not at capacity, with VRQ averaging 40–42 people per night and TRV averaging 8. A pastor from Trinity United Methodist Church provided a status update on the new ecumenical winter shelter, confirming it will begin January 1, 2023, at Trinity United Methodist Church in West Asheville. The shelter will provide 10 beds for intact families on a referral basis and will rotate to other churches in February and March. The group has raised approximately $50,000 and needs to raise an additional $13,000–$20,000. The pastor stated, "My personal goal as a faith leader in this is that we will continue to push the model forward to moving from Code Purple to winter shelter, and then from winter shelter to year-round shelter."

A representative from the National Alliance on Homelessness (NAH) presented on frameworks for an effective homeless response system, emphasizing Coordinated Entry, Housing First, Rapid Rehousing, and Permanent Supportive Housing. The representative explained, "Coordinated entry... creates a process that is more equitable and efficient for the overall community and homeless system... It really ensures also that the resources go to the folks in the most need." The NAH is finalizing its report and plans to present it to the City, County, and HIAC in January 2023.

## Community Input
During public comment, a resident with lived experience noted that while the committee reported capacity, the community perception is that shelters are full, citing seeing standing-room-only buses on a Code Purple night. In response, a public commenter from ABCCM stated, "I'm not sure why that narrative is out there, but you know, hopefully people will see our meeting today and hear that there is capacity and there's plenty of capacity so you know we we certainly want people to come in and take advantage even if it's for one... of what's being offered by our community right now." David Nash, Chair, added, "As people who work in that space let's all take responsibility for spreading that word."

Another public commenter asked about warming shelter options for nights that are cold but not cold enough for Code Purple, such as 34°F with rain. A public commenter explained that ABCCM holds people until temperatures rise above 32°F and noted that First Presbyterian Church offers a warming shelter on Saturdays from 11:00 AM to 2:00 PM. A member noted that Haywood Street Congregation is open for daytime sheltering from 9:00 AM to 2:00 PM, Sunday through Thursday.

A public commenter who had stayed at the previous "Room in the Inn" shelter asked if meals would be provided at the new ecumenical shelter. The pastor from Trinity United Methodist Church replied, "Definitely food will be provided... I think there will be a lot of flexibility in terms of... entry times... But definitely food will be provided."

Finally, a public commenter expressed concern that moving to remote meetings would limit public participation, as they could not interact live via chat or phone if the meeting was not streamed through a platform that allowed it. David Nash, Chair, clarified that the city currently streams directly to YouTube, which does not support live public input, and stated, "I'm opposed to this motion. I think we have lost a lot of this committee... for that purpose, I think in-person meetings are important." Another member voted No, stating, "For the sake of accessibility... for folks who we are making decisions on behalf of, to be in person... is of utmost importance."

## Follow-ups
David Bartholomew agreed to pull and share data on the demographics of individuals facing evictions, specifically looking at age (over 60) and race/ethnicity. The committee asked city staff to explore options for enabling live public comment (e.g., via chat or phone) for in-person meetings and to respond by the next meeting. The Finance Workgroup (David Bartholomew, Lance Crawford, Jamie Benshoff) is responsible for making the final decision on the supplemental winter shelter funding once proposals are received. The National Alliance on Homelessness team is finalizing their report and will present it to the City, County, and HIAC in January 2023.

## Impact
These decisions and discussions highlight the ongoing efforts to address the housing crisis in Asheville. The approval of continued funding for the ecumenical winter shelter and the delegation of supplemental funding decisions to the Finance Workgroup ensure that resources are directed toward immediate winter needs. The committee’s decision to continue meeting in person reflects a prioritization of direct community engagement and accessibility for those affected by homelessness. The data presented on rising evictions and cost burdens underscores the urgency of the housing challenges facing Western North Carolina, while the upcoming NAH presentation in January will provide a framework for long-term systemic solutions.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7LjHSw73fjs
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2719/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7LjHSw73fjs)
