# Human Relations Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Human Relations Commission of Asheville
**Date:** September 15, 2022 5:31 PM EDT (2022-09-15T17:31:24-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4924/human-relations-commission-sep-15-2022

## Summary

The Human Relations Commission of Asheville held a virtual meeting on September 15, 2022. The session began with significant technical difficulties on the virtual platform, as the meeting owner was absent due to a personal injury. Staff and members spent the first 20 minutes troubleshooting access issues to establish a quorum. Once quorum was reached, the Commission addressed the approval of previous minutes, updates on ordinance changes, a recommendation regarding housing discrimination, and a vote on the Commission’s meeting format for the coming year.

## Key Decisions
The Commission voted to approve the minutes from the August 18, 2022 meeting. The motion passed unanimously with 6 ayes and 0 nays; only six members were present for this vote due to the earlier technical difficulties.

The Commission also approved a recommendation to add "source of income" and "city-funded housing" protections to the city’s non-discrimination ordinance. This recommendation was developed by a committee addressing housing issues. During the vote, an amendment was made to change the language from "stand in solidarity with the residents of Asheville" to "hereby offer a formal recommendation to the Asheville City Council." The amendment passed unanimously (6 ayes, 0 nays). Staff clarified that this vote also served as the approval of the recommendation itself, so no separate vote on the base recommendation was recorded.

Finally, the Commission voted on its meeting format for the next year, a decision mandated by recent City Council policy changes. Staff explained that the options were strictly "in-person" or "virtual," as hybrid was not an option for this specific vote due to staff capacity constraints. The motion to continue meeting virtually passed with a vote of 6-1.

## Discussion Highlights
During the discussion on the housing recommendation, Commissioner Susie Chandler explained that discrimination based on source of income refers to renters who are denied property when a landlord sends different application terms or refuses to show a property to tenants who pay with vouchers, child support, or alimony. Commissioner Dolores Venable expressed support for the protections but requested the language change to avoid the phrase "stand in solidarity," suggesting instead that the Commission represent a faction of working taxpaying citizens. Commissioner Harvey Dean Harrell countered that the original language was fine, stating that discrimination in any form should not be tolerated and that the group should stand together in solidarity.

The debate on meeting format highlighted differing preferences among members. Commissioner Dolores Venable voted for in-person meetings, stating that the board accomplishes more work and camaraderie in person and that members should have accounted for the possibility of non-virtual meetings when signing up. Commissioner Susie Chandler agreed that she loves meeting in person but noted that the timing of the meetings is prohibitive for her due to her children, making virtual meetings preferable. Commissioner Nwena Smith also voted for virtual meetings, explaining that she works until 5:00 PM and has two small children, making the virtual format the most practical. Vice Chair Brandon Oliver stated he prefers in-person meetings for the energy and productivity but indicated he had no problem with the virtual option.

The meeting concluded with Commissioner Susie Chandler announcing her resignation from the Commission, effective September 16, 2022. She stated that she had learned a lot from the group and that her intention was to resign regardless of the vote outcome on the housing recommendation. Commissioner Dolores Venable expressed regret at the resignation, noting that it set a tone of people walking away once something is done. Commissioner Chandler responded that she was stunned the recommendation passed unanimously, as she had been fully prepared for it to fail, and that she felt it was a win for the group.

## Follow-ups
Staff member Brenda Mills agreed to send the approved recommendation regarding source of income and housing to all City Council members and the City Manager via the liaison report. Councilwoman Kim Roney, acting as the liaison, stated she would send a liaison report to all council members and Human Relations Commission members regarding the passed recommendation. She also suggested that the Commission might follow up with the Governance Committee, as the non-discrimination ordinance previously went through that committee. Additionally, staff noted that bus passes were issued at the start of the year for board members who needed transportation assistance and directed new members to contact staff if they needed them.

## Impact
This meeting resulted in a formal recommendation from the Human Relations Commission to the Asheville City Council to expand the city’s non-discrimination ordinance to include protections for source of income and city-funded housing. The Commission also determined that it will continue to meet virtually for the next year, a decision that affects how residents can participate in or observe future Commission meetings.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ok9vIqO_XFg
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2748/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ok9vIqO_XFg)
