# Design Review Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Design Review Committee
**Date:** September 15, 2022 12:15 PM EDT (2022-09-15T12:15:07-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4927/design-review-committee-sep-15-2022
**Outcome:** The Design Review Committee approved the August minutes unanimously and discussed the legal status of virtual meetings and design guidelines for the Biltmore Pavilion project.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Design Review Committee held a virtual meeting on September 15, 2022. The agenda focused on the committee’s operational status, the review criteria for hotel projects, and an informal design review of a specific development proposal.

**Key Decisions**
The committee’s only formal vote was to approve the minutes from the August 18, 2022 meeting, as written. A motion was made and seconded, and a roll call vote resulted in a unanimous approval. No formal vote was taken on the committee’s meeting format or on the Biltmore Pavilion project, as the latter was reviewed informally.

**Discussion Highlights**
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to determining whether the committee is legally classified as "advisory" or "quasi-judicial" under the Open Meetings Law, a distinction that dictates whether they can continue to meet virtually. Chair Robin Raines noted that staff and legal are still determining this status, stating, "I’m checking to see I haven’t gotten a definitive answer yet whether we are considered advisory or not... We’re kind of gray area." Member Bryan Moffitt advocated for a hybrid approach, stating, "I would just press for, even if we, the members, need to be in person, I would press for some kind of hybrid to allow public remote access and public participation."

The committee also reviewed the roles and processes for design reviews, specifically how projects are categorized as major or minor works and the guidelines applied to hotels in overlay districts. During the informal review of the Biltmore Pavilion project at 137 Biltmore Avenue, Member Bryan Moffitt expressed concerns about the architectural style, commenting, "I just don’t find it as congruous with the houses... It looks farmhouse style to me in terms of the massing, the roof slopes, the gables... I think you either need to go one way or the other... let’s do it just a really fun, you know, modern contemporary design here, or let’s get more congruous."

Additionally, the committee discussed potential updates to downtown and riverfront design guidelines. Member Kimberly Hunter suggested an incremental approach, stating, "I would recommend... if we take that approach, I think we get a lot done really consistently." Staff and the City’s Historic Preservation Planner discussed the potential incorporation of Secretary of the Interior Standards for rehabilitation into these guidelines. Member Bryan Moffitt expressed caution regarding this inclusion, noting, "I want to be real careful when you start pulling those into our downtown design... a lot of designers see anything to do with Secretary of Interior standards... and they immediately think we’re trying to spray the craggle on it... I just know how designers react and I want to be careful that we don’t communicate something to them we’re not wanting to do."

**Community Input**
A public commenter spoke during the public comment period, stating that keeping meetings virtual is "so much better for everyone involved," citing environmental benefits and efficiency, and noting that clients do not want to pay for travel time to City Hall. Members did not respond to this specific comment, and the Chair immediately closed the meeting.

**Follow-ups**
Chair Robin Raines agreed to email members prior to the next meeting to clarify if the committee can legally vote to remain virtual; if not, the committee may need to meet in person in November. Staff member Will (Assistant City Manager) agreed to create a summary document or rubric using past hotel projects to illustrate how the UDO and hotel overlay definitions have been applied. Staff indicated that updating the downtown and riverfront design guidelines is a priority for early-to-mid 2023, contingent on staffing levels.

**Impact**
These discussions establish the legal framework for how the committee will operate in the near future, specifically regarding virtual participation. The review of the Biltmore Pavilion and the debate over design guidelines highlight the committee's role in shaping the aesthetic character of the downtown area. The creation of a reference document for hotel reviews aims to provide clearer guidance to developers and members on how specific zoning and overlay district rules are applied.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=01n12DnuPt8
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2754/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=01n12DnuPt8)
