# Noise Advisory Board

**Body:** City of Asheville — Noise Advisory Board
**Date:** September 12, 2022 1:00 PM EDT (2022-09-12T13:00:07-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4931/noise-advisory-board-sep-12-2022
**Outcome:** The Noise Advisory Board approved the decibel survey questions and sound mitigation tips document, removed a non-attending member, and deferred the decision on meeting frequency to a future retreat.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Noise Advisory Board held a virtual meeting on September 12, 2022, to address board administration, working group updates, and community noise concerns. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, the removal of a non-attending member, and discussions regarding meeting logistics for the coming year. The board also reviewed progress from its Decibel Levels and Sound Mitigation working groups and received public comment on vehicle noise and a new music venue.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The board unanimously approved the minutes from the June 13, 2022 meeting, with the motion made by Rick Freeman and seconded by Carmelo Papalonio. The board also unanimously approved survey questions developed by the Decibel Level working group, a motion made by Rick Freeman. Additionally, the board unanimously approved the "Good Neighbor and Sound Mitigation Tips" document for publication on the City website, with the motion made by Carmelo Papalonio and seconded by Liliana Woody.

In a significant administrative change, the board unanimously voted to remove Anup Krishnan from the Noise Advisory Board due to attendance issues, noting he had only attended the first meeting. The motion was made by Chair Jessica Tomasin. While the board did not formally vote to change bylaws regarding meeting frequency, they agreed to hold an annual retreat in October and a regular meeting in December. The specific date for the October retreat will be determined by a staff poll, and the decision on whether to meet monthly or every other month was deferred to the October retreat or December meeting.

**Discussion Highlights**
The board discussed the upcoming City Council briefing, with Assistant City Manager Ben Woody clarifying that the slide deck is "not intended... to be adversarial" and is "going to be data heavy." Regarding the format of future meetings, the board did not vote on remote versus in-person attendance but discussed their preferences. Chair Jessica Tomasin stated, "I would rather do remote for the same reasons. Cause I already have dates and places that I have to be in outside of Asheville in February... I just wouldn't be able to do that if it was in person." Staff noted that a two-thirds majority is required to continue remote meetings under proposed City Council policy, and the board agreed to make a formal decision on the format at a future meeting, likely in October.

On the topic of waste hauler noise, Rick Freeman stated, "It is, in my opinion, beyond the responsibility of the Noise Advisory Board to go work that, but it seems like we could make a recommendation to City Council... to ask them to form a business leader, community leader, waste hauler working group." Regarding vehicle noise, Compliance Coordinator Todd Justice explained that the current ordinance does not provide much guidance for DSD staff, as "The only people that are authorized to stop motor vehicles are law enforcement officers." He added that a "no revving" ordinance would be easy to enforce, whereas loud mufflers on moving vehicles are harder to regulate.

**Community Input**
A public commenter, identified as a retired attorney, expressed strong concern about intentional vehicle noise, particularly motorcycles and cars revving engines in downtown areas. He argued that this is a legislative issue requiring strong enforcement, such as making it a traffic offense enforceable by police, similar to practices in Greenville, SC. He also mentioned concerns about loud amplifiers at the bandshell. Chair Jessica Tomasin thanked the commenter and stated that the board would likely reach out to him regarding participation in the new Vehicle Noise working group.

Another public commenter, a resident of Montford Hills, expressed concern about a music venue coming to their neighborhood. He referenced a letter submitted to the board and requested the board’s attention to the issue, noting that the decibel limits and sound migration documents reviewed in the meeting were relevant. He stated that residents were committed to working with the venue and the board to resolve the issue. Chair Jessica Tomasin acknowledged receipt of the letter and informed the commenter that she had been copied on emails regarding the venue (Salvage Station) working with outside engineers to mitigate sound traveling to the Montford area. She stated she would ask the venue to reach out to citizens to share progress on mitigation efforts.

**Follow-ups**
Rick Freeman will work with compliance staff to determine the best method to distribute the approved decibel survey to complainants who previously reported noise from commercial properties where readings were below the limit. He will also draft a recommendation to City Council suggesting the formation of a working group involving downtown business leaders, residents, and waste haulers to coordinate pickup routes and times, and he plans to bring a rough draft of this proposal to the October retreat. Additionally, Rick Freeman will reach out to the Downtown Asheville Residents Network (DARN) to gauge interest in this proposal.

Reb Haizlip agreed to take the lead on the Vehicle Noise working group and requested a further conversation with Todd Justice to narrow the scope of the study, focusing on enforceable actions like engine revving. Rick Freeman will share contact information for a downtown resident interested in participating in this group. Staff member Haley Mahoney will send a Doodle poll this week to determine a date and time for the annual retreat in October. Staff members Todd Justice and Ben Woody will finalize the slides for the City Council briefing by September 20. Staff members Haley Mahoney and Ben Woody will follow up with the City Clerk and City Attorney to clarify if a "hybrid" meeting is permissible under the proposed remote meeting policy. Finally, staff will notify the City Clerk of the removal of Anup Krishnan so a replacement can be posted, likely by the end of the month or beginning of next month.

**Impact**
These decisions establish the board's operational framework for the remainder of the year, including the removal of a non-attending member and the scheduling of an annual retreat to finalize meeting frequency. The approval of the "Good Neighbor and Sound Mitigation Tips" document and the decibel survey questions provides the board with tools to engage with the public and gather data on noise complaints. The formation of a Vehicle Noise working group and the recommendation regarding waste haulers indicate a shift toward collaborative, multi-stakeholder approaches for complex noise issues that may exceed the board's direct enforcement authority.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zoFgnsUPDwo
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2751/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zoFgnsUPDwo)
