# African American Heritage Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — African American Heritage Commission
**Date:** September 8, 2022 4:30 PM EDT (2022-09-08T16:30:19-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4932/african-american-heritage-commission-sep-8-2022
**Outcome:** The African American Heritage Commission unanimously recommended the local landmark designation for the Walton Street Park pool and pool house, sending the proposal to the Historic Resources Commission.

## Summary

On September 8, 2022, the City of Asheville’s African American Heritage Commission held a virtual meeting to review recent minutes, receive staff updates, and deliberate on the historic designation of the Walton Street Park pool. The commission also discussed the format of future meetings and addressed current vacancies on the board.

## Key Decisions
The commission unanimously approved the minutes from the August 11, 2022 meeting. A motion to approve was made by Ashley Wilberding and seconded by Aaron Griffin, with all voting members casting ayes.

The commission also voted unanimously to recommend moving forward with the local landmark designation application for the Walton Street Park pool and pool house. All six members present voted in favor of the recommendation. This action sends the proposal to the Historic Resources Commission for a public hearing scheduled for October 12, followed by a final City Council vote on October 25.

No formal vote was taken on the commission’s meeting format. While the majority of speaking members expressed a preference for continuing with virtual meetings, the Director of Equity and Inclusion noted that a supermajority of the six current members is required to make a final decision. The final determination is pending an upcoming City Council vote on the matter.

## Discussion Highlights
Staff provided several updates, including reports on recent City Council actions such as the sale of 319 Biltmore Avenue to a Black-owned developer for housing and an $850,000 loan to Mountain Housing for affordable units on Tunnel Road. Additionally, a Community Engagement Specialist for Buncombe County announced a free workshop on September 23 at Pack Memorial Library to preserve local stories and reminded the public that the North Carolina Black Architects and Builders exhibit is running until October 10.

The primary discussion centered on the Walton Street Pool landmark designation. An Urban Planner presented a staff report noting that approximately 300 community survey responses were received, with roughly 70% supporting historic designation. The planner clarified that historic designation does not freeze the site in time but requires review of proposed changes to preserve historic character, while still allowing for adaptive reuse such as restoring the pool.

Commission members shared their perspectives on the designation. Catherine Mitchell emphasized the personal and historical significance of the site, stating, "That's the only place my grandparents could go swim... Preservation is preservation to me. It is art, it is history, it is like a museum to me... We cannot afford to drop the ball with this one." Michael Hayes asked whether the designation would prevent refurbishing the pool house if funding arose, to which the Urban Planner responded, "I envision preservation as a living, breathing, dynamic tool... I would be remiss in recommending a designation if we couldn't breathe a new life... into those features with the community's input." Sandra Kilgore, the City Council Liaison, added, "Preservation means with use and for use, we don't want to use it for anything other than, you know, a pool... I think the community would love to see that too."

## Follow-ups
An Urban Planner agreed to share a list of grant funding organizations—including the National Trust, National Park Service, NEH/NEA, and Covington Foundation—with the Director of Equity and Inclusion, who would then forward it to commission members. The planner also agreed to share updated survey data with the Director once available from Parks staff.

Josie Ward, President of the Preservation Society Board, offered to share her research and writing on the pool to assist the commission with grant applications. The Director of Equity and Inclusion stated she will check with the clerk’s office after the City Council meeting regarding the meeting format decision. Michael Hayes stated he would create a "doodle poll" to schedule an informal in-person gathering for commission members to build relationships.

## Impact
This meeting marks a significant step in the preservation of a key site in Asheville’s African American history. By recommending the landmark designation for the Walton Street Pool, the commission has initiated the process to protect the site’s historic character while keeping the door open for its restoration and continued use as a swimming facility. The unanimous vote reflects a strong consensus among commission members on the importance of preserving this community landmark.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bI6hhhL7bY
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2753/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bI6hhhL7bY)
