# Mountain Community Capital Fund - Operating Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Mountain Community Capital Fund
**Date:** September 2, 2022 9:30 AM EDT (2022-09-02T09:30:21-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4934/mountain-community-capital-fund-operating-committee-sep-2-2022

## Summary

**Meeting Overview**
The Mountain Community Capital Fund (MCCF) Operating Committee met on September 2, 2022. The session began without a quorum, leading the group to discuss agenda items without voting until later in the meeting when quorum was established. The primary focus of the meeting was a detailed review of the committee’s Rules of Procedure and updates regarding the Carolina Small Business Development Fund.

**Key Decisions**
Once quorum was established, the committee took two formal votes. First, a motion to remove the "Future Meeting Preferences" item from the agenda passed with five votes in favor and no nays. This item was removed because the City Council’s remote meeting policy was still pending. Second, the committee approved the minutes from the August 18, 2022, special meeting, which also passed with five votes in favor and no nays. No other votes were taken during the session.

**Discussion Highlights**
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to reviewing the Rules of Procedure, presented by Karen Omansky of Self-Help. The committee debated the timing and duration of officer elections, with Carl Allgaier, a City of Asheville appointee, expressing a preference for terms longer than one or two years to ensure institutional knowledge. Chair Maui Vang countered that a one-year minimum is helpful for those stepping into the chair role. The group also discussed adding a Vice Chair position to support the Chair and ensure continuity.

Regarding meeting logistics, Frank McGowan, a City of Asheville appointee, noted that the City Council is considering a remote meeting policy. Consequently, the committee agreed to hold changes to the "Place of Meetings" section until that policy is finalized. The group also reviewed the "Services and Duties Agreement," specifically the moratorium trigger points defined as 20% portfolio-wide delinquencies and 5% annual average credit loss defaults. Karen Omansky suggested that the operating committee might want to add earlier "speed bump" trigger points for deeper review before a full moratorium is required. Frank McGowan stated he was fine with the current clause (11.02) as it stands. Additionally, the committee reviewed termination clauses, with Karen Omansky clarifying that the language allows lenders to exit their own participation, not the entire fund, though the group agreed to seek attorney opinions for clarity.

Reginald Jones, Business Solutions Director for the Carolina Small Business Development Fund, reported that the organization had previously struggled to maintain a local presence in Buncombe County. He announced that Vinaya Ramos would be joining the team within the next month to provide technical assistance and support for local small businesses. Maui Vang commented that having more variety of lending partners and loans would provide more data points to help run a more efficient and impactful fund.

**Follow-ups**
Karen Omansky agreed to incorporate the feedback from the discussion into a draft of the Rules of Procedure for review at the next meeting. She also stated she would seek attorney opinions regarding the termination clauses in the Services and Duties Agreement. Tara Brown of Self-Help agreed to track changes in the Rules of Procedure document during the discussion, and Tim Love of Buncombe County agreed to take minutes. Frank McGowan noted that the committee will need to take action on remote meeting policies at the next meeting once the City Council’s policy is finalized. Committee members agreed to pay particular attention to Section 5.1 (Credit Underwriting Committee) and its dollar thresholds before the next meeting to finalize thoughts prior to a vote on the Rules of Procedure.

**Impact**
These discussions are relevant to residents as they shape the operational framework of the Mountain Community Capital Fund, which supports local economic development. The addition of a dedicated staff member from the Carolina Small Business Development Fund to Buncombe County aims to improve access to technical assistance for local small businesses. Furthermore, the refinement of the Rules of Procedure, including officer terms and meeting locations, will determine how the committee governs itself and makes decisions regarding capital fund operations in the coming year.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rLejwLQJj4g
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2752/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rLejwLQJj4g)
