# Boards & Commissions

**Body:** City of Asheville — Boards and Commissions Committee
**Date:** August 23, 2022 1:01 PM EDT (2022-08-23T13:01:37-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4938/boards-commissions-aug-23-2022
**Outcome:** The committee adopted changes to the Human Relations Commission ordinance and approved several board appointments, all by unanimous vote.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Boards and Commissions Committee met remotely on August 23, 2022, chaired by Vice Mayor Shanika Smith. The agenda focused on the approval of previous minutes, a review of proposed amendments to the Human Relations Commission (HRCA) ordinance, a discussion on a new remote meeting policy for advisory boards, and the review of numerous appointments for various city boards and commissions.

## Key Decisions
The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the June 14 meeting (3-0). The committee also voted unanimously (3-0) to adopt proposed changes to the HRCA ordinance, which remove specific membership quotas and expand the list of recommended diverse groups to include Native Americans and Asian Americans, with an additional motion to include indigenous peoples.

The committee approved several board and commission appointments, all by unanimous vote (3-0):
*   **Affordable Housing Advisory Committee:** Tara Irby (Housing Authority seat), Nguyenna Smith, and the reappointment of Andy Barrett, Margie Bukowski, Paul Heathman, Barbara Ann Phillip, and David Bartholomew.
*   **Board of Adjustments:** Elliot Smith, who resides outside city limits.
*   **Buncombe County TDA:** Reappointment of Larry Crosby.
*   **Historic Resources Commission:** Thomas McLaughlin (Design Review seat) and Maria Diasi (Historic Resources Commission seat).
*   **Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee:** Rick Freeman.
*   **Noise Advisory Board:** Liliana Woody (Restaurant Industry seat, owner of Isis Restaurant, resides outside city limits) and Reb Haslip (Resident seat).

No vote was taken on the proposed remote meeting policy, which was discussed for informational purposes only.

## Discussion Highlights
An analyst from the Office of Equity and Inclusion presented the HRCA ordinance amendments, noting that the changes were recommended by the HRCA to address legal concerns regarding existing membership requirements. Councilwoman Kim Roney moved to adopt the changes with the addition of indigenous peoples to the list of recommended membership groups.

The committee discussed a proposed policy allowing advisory boards to meet remotely. The proposal suggests that in-person meetings remain the default, but boards may opt for remote meetings if a supermajority votes in favor and commits to that format for at least one year. Councilwoman Kim Roney noted that archived meetings have been beneficial for reviewing proceedings and asked what it would take to include recording (video or audio) as part of the policy. Deputy City Clerk Sarah Gross responded that she would connect with the communications department to determine the capacity for recording meetings to bring back for the September meeting.

Staff also provided updates on House Bill 1057, which changes the membership composition of the Tourism Development Authority effective July 1, 2022, adding a seat for a restaurant owner, brewery/distillery/winery owner open for tours or tastings, or an executive director of a ticketed arts organization. Additionally, staff reported that the realignment team is meeting to focus on a survey for current and past board and commission members to drive the next phase of the assessment.

## Community Input
A public commenter from East West Asheville, who served on the Blue Ribbon Committee that originally recommended the HRCA structure, expressed concern that removing specific membership requirements might lead to a less diverse commission over time. They asked staff to clarify why legal concerns regarding the existing requirements were raised only now, several years after adoption. No member or staff member directly responded to this specific concern in the transcript.

Another public commenter expressed concern that the proposed remote meeting policy does not address public participation in virtual meetings, urging Council to ensure live call-in options are available. They questioned the requirement for a supermajority vote to hold remote meetings, arguing that remote meetings increase accessibility and transparency, and suggested that live-streaming in-person meetings would be a better solution. No member or staff member directly responded to the supermajority or live-streaming concerns in the transcript.

## Follow-ups
Deputy City Clerk Sarah Gross agreed to connect with the communications department to determine the capacity for recording meetings (video or audio) to include in the policy for the September meeting. Councilwoman Kim Roney agreed to provide the list of HUD-required sectors currently unrepresented to Assistant Clerk Jerry Goldberg to help with re-advertising the second vacancy on the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee.

## Impact
These decisions ensure that city advisory boards and commissions have the necessary membership to continue their work, with specific attention to diversity and representation in the Human Relations Commission. The review of the remote meeting policy addresses the evolving needs of advisory boards regarding accessibility and public participation, with a commitment to explore recording options to maintain transparency. The appointments and ordinance changes will move forward to City Council for final action where applicable, while the remote meeting policy will be revisited in September.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yms_DKLLCdY
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3174/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yms_DKLLCdY)
