# Public Safety Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Public Safety Committee
**Date:** August 23, 2022 11:00 AM EDT (2022-08-23T11:00:06-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4939/public-safety-committee-aug-23-2022

## Summary

The City of Asheville Public Safety Committee met on August 23, 2022, to review budget amendments, grant renewals, and updates on emergency management and climate resilience initiatives. The committee addressed five primary agenda items, including the approval of previous minutes, the allocation of asset forfeiture funds, and recommendations for two specific grants. The meeting also featured updates from city staff on the Emergency Operations Plan and the Climate Justice Initiative.

**Key Decisions**
The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the previous June meeting. Regarding the asset forfeiture budget amendment, which would allocate $419,214.47 in state and federal funds for a new DNA analyzer, a replacement bomb robot, and forensic training, the committee voted 2-1 to recommend the amendment to the full Council. Councilwoman Sandra Kilgore and Vice Mayor Shanika Smith voted in favor, while Councilwoman Kim Roney voted against. Similarly, the committee voted 2-1 to recommend the renewal of the High Intensity Drug Trafficking Area (HIDTA) grant, valued at $204,638, to the full Council, with the same voting split. The committee unanimously recommended the renewal of the Bike Safe NC program, a $5,000 grant, to the full Council.

**Discussion Highlights**
Staff proposed using the asset forfeiture funds specifically for law enforcement equipment and training. Police Chief David Zak emphasized that the department is down 50% or more of its detectives and described the proposed equipment and training as "force multipliers" that would help solve crimes quicker and more fairly. City Manager Deborah Campbell urged the committee not to return these resources, stating that the DNA analyzer and forensic training are "desperately needed" to ensure the right person is charged. City Attorney Brad Branham cautioned the committee against passing any policy directing the police department to spend the money on specific items, noting that the Department of Justice (DOJ) has explicitly cited such directives as a reason to cancel an agency’s participation in the sharing program.

Councilwoman Kim Roney explained that her vote against the forfeiture amendment was not due to a lack of need for training, but because she did not believe the committee had sufficient information on the demographics impacted by asset seizures. Councilwoman Sandra Kilgore voted in favor, calling the DNA analyzer and training a "no-brainer," and suggested looking for other budget flexibility to fund community investment programs rather than circumventing DOJ restrictions. Vice Mayor Shanika Smith supported the equipment but advocated for a "different vision" for spending that addresses immediate threats like gun violence and benefits the most harmed communities.

**Community Input**
During public comment at the beginning of the meeting, a representative from East West Asheville raised concerns about the asset forfeiture program, citing national arguments that civil forfeiture allows property seizure without conviction. The commenter requested transparency on the demographics of those affected and urged the Council to consider redirecting funds to address root-cause public safety issues rather than "profiting off the war on drugs." Members did not respond to this comment.

At the end of the meeting, a public commenter stated that the Climate Justice Initiative appears to exclude citizens with disabilities from emergency management planning and expressed concern about synthetic narcotics and gun violence. Another public commenter argued that the "war on drugs" is punitive rather than proactive, criticizing the city for adding money to the police budget via forfeiture and HIDTA grants while asking for community resources. The commenter suggested removing these grant amounts from the police budget and redirecting them to violence interruption programs. Members did not respond to these comments.

**Follow-ups**
Councilwoman Kim Roney requested that the asset forfeiture item return to the Public Safety Committee in one month with additional answers regarding the demographics of asset seizures and the source of funds before a final recommendation is made to the full Council. She also suggested that a future Public Safety Committee meeting review the outcomes of the HIDTA grant over the last few years to inform the decision on continuing to fund it. Deputy Fire Chief Chris Bozinski stated that the Request for Proposal (RFP) for the Emergency Operations Plan and Continuity of Operations Plan is ready to post within the next week, with responses expected in September and October.

**Impact**
These decisions determine how the city utilizes over $419,000 in federal and state asset forfeiture funds and whether it continues to receive over $204,000 in HIDTA grant funding. The committee’s recommendation to the full Council prioritizes law enforcement equipment and training, a decision that drew debate over the balance between investigative capabilities and community-based public safety resources. Additionally, the updates on the Emergency Operations Plan and Climate Justice Initiative provide residents with a timeline for improved emergency response planning and the integration of climate equity into city operations.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g4tMF3GYe-s
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3180/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g4tMF3GYe-s)
