# Downtown Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Downtown Commission
**Date:** August 12, 2022 9:30 AM EDT (2022-08-12T09:30:22-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4946/downtown-commission-aug-12-2022
**Outcome:** Downtown Commission opposed the Biltmore Avenue bike lane proposal and supported lowering the speed limit, while noting the Duke Energy substation design is being reworked.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Downtown Commission convened on August 12, 2022, to review several key initiatives affecting the downtown area. The agenda centered on a proposal for restriping Biltmore Avenue, updates on the Duke Energy substation relocation, and the development of new design guidelines. The meeting also included brief updates on public restroom facilities, homelessness studies, and walkability assessments.

The primary decision of the meeting was the approval of the minutes from the July 8, 2022 session. A motion was made to approve these minutes, followed by a roll call vote. The minutes were approved unanimously by those present, with ayes recorded from Kimberly Hunter, Steven Lee Johnson, Megan Rogers, Guillermo Rodriguez, Ricardo Seijo, Ruth Summers, and Sage Turner. Andrew Fletcher and Tal Frankfurt were recorded as absent for this vote.

The most significant discussion concerned the Transportation Department’s proposal to add two 6-foot bike lanes to Biltmore Avenue between Patton and Hilliard streets. This plan, tied to a larger NCDOT repaving project scheduled for the fall, would require removing one southbound vehicle lane and narrowing the northbound lane, alongside new loading zones. The Commission expressed a consensus that it was not in support of the bike lanes and loading zones as currently presented, citing concerns about the rushed process and a lack of alternatives. Chair Bryan Moffitt summarized the group’s preference for the city to restripe the road as it currently exists and to undertake a longer, more formal process to build community consensus. While opposing the lane changes, the Commission expressed full support for lowering the speed limit between Aston and Hilliard streets. Assistant Director of Transportation Jessica Morris accepted responsibility for the insufficient public outreach, stating, "I fully take the blame for not being able to do the level of effort that we should have done." She also clarified that road diets are primarily safety measures intended to slow traffic and reduce injuries.

Regarding the Duke Energy substation relocation, the City Council Liaison provided an update that the previous proposal to move the substation from Rankin Street to the 57 Rankin parking lot has been effectively removed. A new design is currently being developed. The Liaison requested that this new design be brought back to the Downtown Commission for feedback and a vote before proceeding to Planning/Economic Development and City Council.

Three members of the public provided comments via phone or email, all opposing the Duke Energy substation project. One commenter representing "Friends of Lexington Avenue" argued that the existing Memorandum of Understanding requires mitigation of visual impacts and consistency with neighborhood character. Another commenter cited aesthetic, safety, and economic concerns, referencing a petition with over 5,000 signatures. A third commenter questioned the logistical feasibility of the move due to the steep grade and argued the current location has ample room for expansion. No specific member responded directly to these comments during the public comment period; however, the City Council Liaison later confirmed that community meetings for the project were canceled and the plan is being reworked. Additionally, the Chair summarized three written comments regarding the Biltmore Avenue project, noting that two were opposed to the lane reduction and one was not.

Several follow-up actions were identified during the meeting. Jessica Morris agreed to share all public comments and the memo with the City Manager and Assistant City Manager, noting she has a meeting scheduled for Monday to discuss the Biltmore Avenue decision. She also stated that the city is working with NCDOT to assess the speed limit south of Aston, with a high likelihood of it being reduced from 35 mph to 25 mph. The City Council Liaison stated that the new substation design is expected in September or October. Megan Rogers, representing the Asheville Downtown Association, noted that the walkability study data collection is open for two weeks and that the "Building Our City" Speaker Series is returning in October.

These discussions highlight ongoing tensions between traffic safety, infrastructure development, and community character in Asheville’s downtown core. The Commission’s rejection of the current Biltmore Avenue plan signals a demand for more thorough public engagement before permanent road changes are made. Meanwhile, the rework of the Duke Energy substation plan indicates that the city is responding to significant community opposition by revisiting the design before further approvals.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eCIT4j4v-54
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2760/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eCIT4j4v-54)
