# Design Review Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Design Review Committee
**Date:** July 21, 2022 12:16 PM EDT (2022-07-21T12:16:36-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4955/design-review-committee-jul-21-2022
**Outcome:** The Design Review Committee unanimously recommended approval for the exterior rehabilitation of the building at 58 North Lexington Avenue and sent the Duke Energy substation proposal back for another informal review.

## Summary

On July 21, 2022, the City of Asheville Design Review Committee convened to review several development proposals, including a formal design review for a building rehabilitation and two informal reviews for new construction projects. The meeting began with a pre-meeting discussion clarifying the committee’s scope of authority, with the Chair confirming that the body’s role is strictly to review designs against the Downtown Design Guidelines rather than debate the political or policy merits of projects. Staff also noted that a public meeting for a substation project originally scheduled for August 8 had been canceled, and the item was pulled from the August 23 Council hearing to allow for additional review time.

## Key Decisions
The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the June 16, 2022 meeting. The body also voted unanimously to recommend approval for the exterior rehabilitation of the existing two-story building at 58 North Lexington Avenue. Staff presented the proposal, which involves restoring the original storefront location, replacing windows with tempered glass panels in aluminum grids, and re-stuccoing the front facade. The architect noted that the design was modified to be more historically accurate, and staff recommended approval because the project aligns with the Downtown Design Guidelines regarding zero front setbacks, traditional facade components, and material preservation.

No votes were taken on the other two agenda items. For the Duke Energy substation proposal at 57 Rankin Street, the committee discussed the design extensively but did not make a motion to approve or deny. The Chair suggested that the applicant return for another informal review to address the committee’s concerns. Similarly, no motion was made regarding the micro-housing proposal at 46 Aston Street; the committee provided feedback on the preliminary design, and the applicant indicated they would develop the design further.

## Discussion Highlights
During the informal review of the Duke Energy substation at 57 Rankin Street, presenters explained that while the project is a Level 1 review, it is being treated with Level 2 rigor due to its impact. They presented two primary design options for the screening wall—one using metal panels and one using stone veneer—and noted that variances are being sought for street trees, tree canopy preservation, property line buffers, and sidewalk width. Committee members expressed significant concern about the aesthetic quality of the proposed walls. Committee Member Steven Lee Johnson stated, "These walls look like what we'd see as sound barriers on the side of the interstate. There's no design... I think Duke may be missing a really interesting opportunity to do something that could be incredibly artistic and playful." Committee Member Bryan Moffitt added, "I'm not going to receive a favorable review by this committee based on what you're seeing... I'm looking for an entire design... think about how people relate to it, what are they looking at, what is it communicating, and go from there."

For the micro-housing proposal at 46 Aston Street, applicants presented a plan to subdivide the lot into three parcels, maintaining the existing one-story building for potential commercial use and constructing two new seven-story micro-housing buildings. The design features dark gray brick, light gray fiber cement siding, and reddish-orange metal cladding. Committee Member Kathryn Ancaya suggested exploring a green roof for stormwater management, noting, "I would also point to another project CDC worked on on 145 Biltmore that used the green roof for their stormwater... This is a great opportunity to improve the streetscape and the quality of the pedestrian environment on Aston." Committee Member Ricardo Seijo also suggested providing elevations, stating, "I was actually going to suggest elevations as well, because I think your design is doing a lot of things that the perspectives aren't really showing very well... I think a line drawing that shows that in more detail would definitely be good."

## Community Input
Public comment was received for the 57 Rankin Street substation item. One public commenter from Friends of Lexington Avenue requested the square footage of the slab and argued that the total construction should trigger a Level 2 review. They requested better renderings showing the impact on the streetscapes of Rankin and North Lexington, noting that the current close-ups were disorienting. In response, a committee member stated that the committee’s comments matter because the City owns the property, while another member emphasized that the current design lacks artistic merit.

A second public commenter expressed concern about the removal of tree canopy, which provides cooling, and argued the project is out of scale for Lower Lexington. They urged the committee to recommend the substation remain in its current location or move elsewhere. A committee member agreed with the concerns about scale and visibility, suggesting that the design needs to be viewed from eye-level street views rather than aerials to properly assess the impact.

A third public commenter noted that the project appears to be a feasibility study rather than a fully designed project. They asked about the viability of the sidewalk on the east side of Rankin, the location of trees on the slope, and why a gas-insulated solution was not explored. In reply, a committee member asked the Duke team to confirm if they had looked at the GIS system for tree data, and another member encouraged the applicant to reach out to City Councilors early due to the significant community pushback.

No public comments were received for the 58 North Lexington Avenue or 46 Aston Street items.

## Follow-ups
Staff member Will Pryor agreed to email links regarding substation design precedents to a committee member who could not open them during the live meeting. Staff also confirmed that they and the Director of Planning are working on a presentation to clarify the roles and responsibilities of the Design Review Committee and the Downtown Commission, to be shared with both bodies in the coming month. Regarding the Aston Street project, the applicant from MPS agreed to follow up with the client regarding the feasibility of a green roof for stormwater management.

## Impact
This meeting resulted in the approval of a historic building rehabilitation on North Lexington Avenue, which will restore the building's original storefront and facade elements in accordance with city design guidelines. The substation and micro-housing projects remain in the preliminary design phase. The substation project, which involves a land swap with the City, will return for another informal review to address aesthetic and scale concerns raised by the committee and the public. The micro-housing project will be further developed by the applicant, potentially incorporating a green roof for stormwater management as suggested by the committee.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ftiFeqPDlxQ
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2770/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ftiFeqPDlxQ)
