# Urban Forestry Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Urban Forestry Commission
**Date:** July 5, 2022 12:59 PM EDT (2022-07-05T12:59:49-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4961/urban-forestry-commission-jul-5-2022

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Urban Forestry Commission convened on July 5, 2022, to address administrative matters, project updates, and strategic planning for the city’s urban canopy. The meeting began with the approval of the minutes from the previous session, which passed with 5 ayes, 1 abstention, and 1 aye from a member who was absent at the prior meeting. The commission also voted unanimously, with 7 ayes, to cancel the scheduled meeting for August 2022. The session concluded with a unanimous vote of 6 ayes to adjourn, following a correction to the roll call to include a previously skipped member.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the proposed relocation of an aging Duke Energy substation from near the Harris Cherokee Center to a parking lot on Rankin Avenue. Jason Walls of Duke Energy explained that the substation must be rebuilt as it is nearing the end of its useful life, noting that the utility intends to enter the city’s informal design review process within two to three weeks and will hold a public information meeting on August 11. Chris Corral, Director of Community and Regional Entertainment Facilities, noted that the relocation would facilitate a more feasible renovation of the Thomas Wolfe Auditorium. In response to stakeholder input, commission members emphasized the need for a planting plan for the original substation site to ensure a net benefit to the urban canopy. The Chair expressed support for reviewing plans to ensure the new site does not infringe on the steep slope, while another member stated a preference to avoid tree loss or, if loss occurs, to offset it with equivalent canopy elsewhere. A third member requested specific proposals for feedback to assess the overall impact on the urban canopy.

The commission also reviewed the Carter and Patton Stormwater Improvement Project (CAPS) along Patton Avenue, which involves reworking sidewalks and managing diseased or overgrown trees. In response to member recommendations, Public Works agreed to use little leaf lindens instead of ginkgos or zelkovas, citing better survival rates in constrained areas. Additionally, a member raised concerns regarding unauthorized tree removal on a steep slope property on Elk Mountain Ridge. The commission also discussed the city’s plan to phase back into in-person meetings, with a potential test phase in September. Members discussed health safety measures, including the possibility of mandatory masking for in-person attendees, with one member expressing comfort with mandatory masking and another questioning the environmental logic of driving to in-person meetings when virtual options are available.

Other business included status updates for the Policy, Budget Request, Fee and Lieu, and Urban Forest Master Plan working groups. The Chair proposed that Cecil Bothwell return to the Budget Request Working Group while the Chair steps away from that specific group. The commission also discussed the importance of separating personal opinions from official statements on social media and explored potential partnerships with Buncombe County and other municipalities to promote urban forestry education and canopy growth. An update on the Boards and Commissions Realignment noted that the Urban Forestry Commission was well-regarded for its functionality, with a member noting that the common theme in the review was that the commission is a "working commission that works."

Several staff members agreed to specific follow-up actions during the meeting. Russ Davis of Public Works will carry forward the recommendation to use little leaf lindens for the CAPS project. Ricky Hurley, the Planning Supervisor, will verify with plan reviewers that steep slope conditions are clearly stamped on plan sets for the Elk Mountain Ridge property. Ben Woody, the Assistant City Manager, will connect with staff to determine next steps for updating the Davey Resource Group canopy study. Additionally, Haley Mahoney, a Staff Assistant, will check with the city clerk’s office regarding mandatory masking policies for in-person meetings and will follow up the following week to confirm if any alternative compliance applications were received prior to the August meeting cancellation.

These discussions and decisions are significant for residents as they directly impact the health and expansion of Asheville’s urban tree canopy, which provides critical services such as sound buffering, temperature regulation, and slope stabilization. The decision to cancel the August meeting and the shift toward in-person meetings with potential masking requirements will affect how residents engage with the commission in the near future. Furthermore, the focus on the Duke Energy substation relocation and the CAPS project highlights the ongoing balance between infrastructure needs and environmental preservation in the city.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d0DzI014VRA
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3177/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d0DzI014VRA)
