# Design Review Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Design Review Committee
**Date:** June 16, 2022 12:30 PM EDT (2022-06-16T12:30:06-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4970/design-review-committee-jun-16-2022

## Summary

**Meeting Overview**
On June 16, 2022, the City of Asheville Design Review Committee (DRC) held a virtual meeting to review one formal design project: Create 72 Broadway. The committee also approved the minutes from its May 19, 2022 meeting.

**Key Decisions**
The committee voted unanimously (7 ayes) to accept the minutes from the May 19, 2022 meeting as written. Member Kathryn Ancaya recused herself from the Create 72 Broadway project due to a relationship with the project, a motion that passed unanimously (7 ayes). Regarding the Create 72 Broadway project, the committee voted 5-1 to recommend approval subject to seven specific conditions. The vote was cast by Chair Christina Roush, Kimberly Hunter, Steven Lee Johnson, Bryan Moffitt, and Robin Raines in favor, with Ricardo Seijo voting against. Kathryn Ancaya was recused.

**Discussion Highlights**
The project involves a nine-story mixed-use building at 72 Broadway Street, featuring 22 hotel rooms, condominium units, ground-floor retail, and 43 structured parking spaces. Staff presented the project’s compliance with Downtown Design Guidelines, noting it was largely compliant with siting, height, massing, and pedestrian entrance requirements. Staff identified one area of partial non-compliance regarding the use of synthetic wall systems (stucco/EFIS) and metal panels, though they found the overall appearance compatible with nearby buildings.

During the discussion, several design elements were addressed. Members expressed concern that the proposed public art piece was merely a placeholder and created a cramped pedestrian experience; the applicant offered to remove it from the current scope. Bryan Moffitt and Ricardo Seijo criticized the main tower element for appearing "tacked on" or lacking depth, leading the applicant to propose extending the tower back over the roof. Members also discussed the high-contrast brick banding, with Chair Christina Roush noting it looked like a "literal" copy of the nearby Center for Craft building. The applicant agreed to revise the banding to be lower contrast or monochromatic with 3D articulation. Additionally, the applicant clarified that the metal panel grid would align with window mullions and be flat rather than corrugated.

**Community Input**
A public commenter, identified by staff as a property owner or representative on Market Street, asked if the project was encroaching on the alleyway. A staff member responded that the project is proposed on its current parcel outline and would not be encroaching onto access to adjacent properties.

**Follow-Ups**
The project team explicitly agreed to remove the public art placeholder and return to the Design Review Committee with a formal presentation once an artist is commissioned. They also agreed to revise the tower element to extend back over the roof, revise the brick banding to be lower contrast or monochromatic with 3D articulation, clarify the metal panel grid alignment with windows, move bike racks, and adjust street tree placement. The applicant further agreed to provide a courtesy meeting with the committee during early design development to review metal panel detailing. Staff stated they will monitor the applicant's revisions to ensure they meet the conditions set by the committee.

**Impact**
This decision allows the Create 72 Broadway project to proceed to the Planning and Zoning Commission. Staff noted that if the project had not received a favorable recommendation from the Design Review Committee, it would likely have been pushed to the August Planning and Zoning meeting. The approval is contingent upon the applicant implementing the seven conditions specified by the committee, which include specific architectural revisions to the tower, brickwork, and site improvements.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b0TNvyX8o_E
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2787/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b0TNvyX8o_E)
