# Community Reparations Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Reparations Commission
**Date:** June 6, 2022 5:58 PM EDT (2022-06-06T17:58:16-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4979/community-reparations-commission-jun-6-2022
**Outcome:** The Commission confirmed its request for a reparations budget line item and deferred the decision on youth participation to the next meeting.

## Summary

On June 6, 2022, the City of Asheville Community Reparations Commission convened to review its official charge and proposed operating procedures. The Commission’s mandate includes issuing reports on minority home and business ownership, equity, generational wealth, and gaps in health care, education, employment, and criminal justice. The meeting focused heavily on establishing the rules of order for future sessions and clarifying the legal scope of the Commission’s upcoming recommendations to city and county governing bodies.

## Key Decisions
The Commission approved the minutes from the previous meeting by unanimous vote. Regarding the proposed meeting procedures, the Commission did not vote on adoption; instead, the Chair instructed members to review the documents and return with questions, approvals, or amendments at the next meeting. The Commission confirmed that it would proceed with a previously passed motion to request a budgetary line item for reparations, as no motion to withdraw the proposal was offered. Additionally, the Commission voted to add the topic of youth participation to the current agenda for immediate discussion. After debate, the Commission agreed to place the substantive question of youth participation on the agenda for the next meeting on June 27 for further discussion and a potential vote; no final decision on the specific role of youth was made at this session. The "Discussion Topics" agenda item was tabled for the next meeting, and the meeting was subsequently adjourned.

## Discussion Highlights
City and County attorneys presented a simplified set of rules based on Robert’s Rules of Order, noting that motions require a second and cannot be voted on in the same meeting they are introduced. The attorneys clarified that current governing bodies are not legally permitted to bind future iterations of the board regarding budgetary policy, though they can make legislative decisions. A Commission Member distinguished between "seed money" for administrative work and funds for actual reparations, stating, "My motion was saying put aside some money for what the people gonna give, not for what we gonna work to figure out how they gonna give it. It's two separate pots."

The Commission also debated the role of youth in the reparations process. One Commission Member argued that teenagers are the only generation not currently represented and stated, "They are the only people that can speak today. We can't speak for these kids and they have a voice." Another Commission Member expressed concern about granting voting power to youth, noting, "If you're going to have them to have voting power, then you would have to do the same with the alternates... I just didn't think it was [appropriate]... I don't think they're ready." The Chair encouraged participation, stating, "I have never heard a stupid question. Never. And so if there's something to say and you're not sure if there's clarity that needs to be made... maybe you should let us hear it."

## Community Input
The Chair opened the floor for verbal public comments after a member suggested it was important to hear the community’s voice directly. A public commenter, identified as a Pastor, argued that if young people are old enough to serve in the military and vote, they are old enough to serve on the Commission with voting rights. The commenter criticized Robert’s Rules of Order as an "albatross" that slows down necessary work, urging the Commission to be "bold" and "bodacious." They also advised the Commission to submit recommendations to the City and County even if rejection is feared, stating, "Don't say no to ourselves," and urged the Commission to move meetings into the community to increase involvement. In response, the Chair stated, "I completely agree" with the suggestion to allow verbal comments and expressed a desire to respond to public points in real-time to avoid "talking into a vacuum."

A second public commenter from West Asheville, speaking on behalf of the Racial Justice Coalition, voiced support for reparations and mentioned their involvement in a weekly solidarity circle for over a year. They expressed hope to contribute to racial healing and resource transfer. A member responded, "Yes sir." A third public commenter addressed the Commission members directly, stating that if members do not have the voice or comfort to speak out on their own and rely on the Chair or Vice Chair to speak for them, they should "step aside" and "get out of my way" so others can have a seat on the board. The Chair responded, "Okay. Thank you."

## Follow-ups
The Chair and Vice Chair agreed to ensure the letter of recommendation regarding the budgetary line item is completed so it can be submitted to the City Council and County Commissioners. The facilitator stated that they will contact members to schedule the start of the impact focus area meetings in July. Members were instructed to read the proposed meeting procedures and bring questions or amendments to the next meeting. Additionally, members were reminded to submit their W-9 forms and signed statements of commitment to the staff as soon as possible.

## Impact
This meeting established the procedural framework for the Commission’s work, including the decision to proceed with a budgetary request for reparations while acknowledging legal limitations on binding future governing bodies. The decision to defer the final vote on youth participation to June 27 highlights the ongoing debate regarding the inclusion of younger residents in decision-making roles. The Commission’s commitment to completing the budgetary letter and scheduling impact focus area meetings in July indicates a transition from procedural setup to substantive research and recommendation development.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8-Tsd4n5d4
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2789/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8-Tsd4n5d4)
