# Transit Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Transit Committee
**Date:** May 31, 2022 5:00 PM EDT (2022-05-31T17:00:05-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4980/transit-committee-may-31-2022
**Outcome:** Transit Committee approved the meeting minutes and heard updates on a $1 million budget shortfall, driver shortages, and the need for a joint city-county transit master plan.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Transit Committee held a virtual meeting on May 31, 2022, from 5:00 PM to 7:00 PM. The agenda focused on operational challenges, including driver shortages, budget shortfalls, and facility needs, as well as updates on federal grant applications and bus acquisitions. The committee also discussed the strategic role of the board in transit planning.

**Key Decisions**
The only formal votes taken during the meeting were for the approval of meeting minutes. A motion was made and seconded to approve the minutes for the current meeting (May 31, 2022), and the minutes were approved. Additionally, a motion was made and seconded to approve the minutes from April 19, 2022, and those minutes were also approved. No other formal votes or motions were recorded.

**Discussion Highlights**
Staff provided updates on reduced service frequency on the N3 and W6 routes, attributing the cuts to a current driver shortage. Staff member Barry noted that the system currently has 51 operators compared to a desired complement of 63, with five drivers currently in the hiring pipeline. Barry also highlighted recent wage increases, stating that driver pay had risen from $15 an hour eight months prior to a new wage package of $18.78.

Regarding the FY 2022-23 operating budget, staff member Jessica explained that the department is facing a $1 million shortfall at the close of the current fiscal year. Consequently, the $1 million originally earmarked for service expansion will be used to fill this budget gap. Jessica stated that the system cannot expand until additional drivers, staff, and revenue are secured. She emphasized that the most critical need is for the city and county to conduct a joint transit master plan, with the goal of pursuing a ballot measure for a quarter-cent sales tax in 2024. Jessica noted that such a measure would double the budget, providing a more sustainable funding source for investments like facilities.

The committee also discussed facility and fleet updates. Jessica indicated that a new maintenance facility is needed, with costs estimated between $50 million and $75 million, and suggested that major federal grants are likely the only way to fund such a project. On the fleet, Jessica confirmed that four new Vicinity buses are expected by the end of July, with diesel Gillig buses to be delivered in the fall. Staff member Haley confirmed that the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) grant application for six hybrid buses and three battery packs was submitted at 5:30 PM on the day of the meeting.

Committee members raised concerns about their ability to fulfill their roles, noting that they have primarily received reports rather than opportunities for strategic input. Member Bill Loftus expressed a desire for the committee to be part of the analysis for bus specifications and strategic planning. Member John Bassoon suggested revisiting the master plan to assess the system's direction over the next decade. Member Colin Kenton asked about potential benefits from the new federal transportation bill; Jessica responded that the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act provides a 20 to 30% increase in federal formula funds over five years, which she noted is not enough to buy a new bus or pay for another route. Additionally, member Sandy Aldrich reported complaints from riders regarding driver conduct, specifically instances of being yelled at. Staff member Barry responded that it is critical to report incidents as soon as possible so the department can deal with driver misconduct directly.

**Community Input**
No public comment period was held during this meeting. The Chair stated, "We have no public comment on this meeting. So, I'll forego the public comment input for the meetings."

**Follow-ups**
Staff member Jessica agreed to prepare a memo outlining recommendations for a joint city-county transit study and a potential sales tax ballot measure to provide to the City Manager. Jessica also agreed to create a document explaining the variables and decision-making process behind bus specifications, such as size, fuel type, and cost, to help the committee understand the choices. Member Bill Loftus agreed to ask Dennis, a member of the Multimodal Commission, to include the transit funding and study topic as an agenda item at a Multimodal meeting in the next couple of months.

**Impact**
This meeting highlighted significant financial and operational pressures on the transit system, including a $1 million budget shortfall and a driver shortage that has already led to reduced service on specific routes. The discussion underscored the long-term need for new infrastructure and stable funding, with staff identifying a joint city-county master plan and a potential 2024 ballot measure as key strategic steps. The committee’s expressed desire for greater engagement in strategic planning and bus specification analysis suggests a shift toward more collaborative decision-making in the coming months.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qlZXLpwQ-eI
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2790/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qlZXLpwQ-eI)
