# Sustainability Advisory Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Sustainability Advisory Committee
**Date:** May 18, 2022 3:31 PM EDT (2022-05-18T15:31:32-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4986/sustainability-advisory-committee-may-18-2022
**Outcome:** The Sustainability Advisory Committee approved the March minutes unanimously and referred the proposed plastic reduction ordinance to the Waste Reduction Working Group for finalization.

## Summary

On May 18, 2022, the City of Asheville’s Sustainability Advisory Committee (SACI) convened to review ongoing sustainability initiatives and evaluate a proposed plastic reduction ordinance. The meeting focused on updates from the committee’s working groups, a staff briefing on municipal restructuring, and a detailed presentation regarding a draft ordinance to ban single-use plastic bags and polystyrene food service ware.

The committee’s primary decision was the approval of the minutes from the previous meeting. A motion to approve the March minutes was made by Tim Ormond and seconded by Ann Keller, passing unanimously by roll call. No vote was taken on the proposed plastic reduction ordinance. Instead, the committee agreed to refer the draft to the Waste Reduction Working Group for finalization. Chair Anna Priest established a deadline for the finalized ordinance to be ready by July 15, ensuring it would be included in the meeting materials for the July 20 SACI meeting.

Working groups provided updates on their respective projects. The Climate Resilience Group reported meeting with subcontractor AECOM to discuss prioritization factors for the Municipal Climate Action Plan (MCAP). Chair Anna Priest noted that the group provided significant feedback to AECOM and plans to reconvene soon to align on the MCAP’s direction. The Waste Reduction Group highlighted the success of the Food Waste Reduction Month campaign, which included an Instagram campaign engaging over 3,000 accounts and a "Taste It, Don’t Waste It" event. They noted that over 30 tons of food scraps have been collected at the Stevens Lee drop-off site. Additionally, the Energy Working Group discussed proposed net metering rules by Duke Energy, noting that stakeholders are advocating against the rules and considering legal action if they pass, as they negatively impact the local solar market.

A major portion of the meeting was dedicated to a presentation on the proposed plastic reduction ordinance by representatives from Mountain True, Sierra Club, the Southern Environmental Law Center, and Plastic Free WNC. The proposal bans plastic bags at the point of sale, requiring retailers to offer paper bags with 40% recycled content for a 10-cent fee, which is exempt for customers using EBT/SNAP benefits. The ordinance also bans polystyrene takeout containers and requires straws to be provided only upon request. Presenters outlined a 6–12 month phase-in period and a budget of approximately $50,000 for outreach and reusable bag distribution. Susanna Knox of the Southern Environmental Law Center confirmed the city has strong legal authority under North Carolina’s Solid Waste Management Act, while a survey of over 500 local businesses showed 87–93% support for the ban.

Staff provided an update on the City Council’s restructuring of boards and commissions. Bridget Herring, the new Sustainability Director, noted that the timeline is currently "in a state of flux" and encouraged the public to provide input via the city’s public input page. During public comments, a written comment was read on behalf of an absent individual, noting that City Council had awarded ARPA grants, including $500,000 for cleanliness projects, and expressing hope that Asheville might become the first North Carolina city to pass a plastic bag ban. Bridget Herring clarified that the city did approve ARPA funds for the Green Builds Alliance to perform energy efficiency and renewable energy work in low-income communities.

Several follow-up actions were established to move the plastic reduction ordinance forward. The full committee directed the Waste Reduction Working Group to take the draft ordinance, incorporate feedback and edits discussed during the meeting, and finalize it. Staff members Jess Foster, Sanitation Division Manager, and Brad Brantham, City Attorney, were invited to attend the June 8 Waste Reduction Working Group meeting to assist with legal and operational language. Presenters from Mountain True and the Southern Environmental Law Center also agreed to attend or provide input. Additionally, Hartwell Carson agreed to send the cost analysis document to staff if it had not already been distributed, ensuring all members had access to the materials.

This meeting marks a significant step in the city’s efforts to address waste management and climate resilience. By referring the plastic reduction ordinance to the working group for finalization, the committee is moving toward a potential vote on a policy that aims to reduce single-use plastics, which presenters identified as both a climate and human health issue. The engagement of legal and operational staff in the upcoming working group session ensures that the final ordinance will be legally sound and practically enforceable.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UVGutqOz5Dk
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2793/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UVGutqOz5Dk)
