# City Council Work Session – May 10 2022

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** May 10, 2022 2:26 PM EDT (2022-05-10T14:26:17-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4988/city-council-work-session-may-10-2022
**Outcome:** Council discussed staff proposals to restructure advisory boards and realign committees, with no votes taken or formal decisions made.

## Summary

**City Council Work Session Recap: May 10, 2022**

On May 10, 2022, the Asheville City Council held a work session to discuss a holistic review of the city’s advisory boards, commissions, and council committees. This is the first comprehensive review of these bodies since 2006. The session focused on staff proposals to restructure the current 20 advisory boards into a tiered system and to realign council subcommittees with the city’s Comprehensive Plan and 2036 Vision.

No votes were taken and no formal decisions were made during this work session. Staff explicitly stated that they were not asking for a council decision on that day, but rather sought feedback to determine if the proposed direction was appropriate. While council members discussed the proposals at length, no formal action was taken to adopt, reject, or modify the structures.

The discussion centered on three main areas: the realignment of council committees, the restructuring of boards and commissions, and community input. Staff proposed creating two new council committees, "Healthy Environment and Safe Community" and "Connected and Equitable Community," merging the Finance and Governance committees, and absorbing Public Safety into the new "Healthy Environment and Safe Community" committee. Regarding the advisory bodies, staff presented a draft proposal to restructure the 20 boards into a tiered system involving Council Committees, Advisory Boards, and Working Groups, aiming to improve accountability and address operational inefficiencies.

Staff shared feedback from two focus groups and four workshops involving 81 participants. Major themes included concerns that the proposal limits voices, lacks clarity on how specific boards like the Downtown Commission and African American Heritage Commission will fit into the new structure, and questions about the support provided to working groups. In response to concerns that downgrading boards to "working groups" might cause their work to "evaporate" due to a lack of staff support, minutes, or public notice, staff explained that the goal is to add more people to the discussion by having advisory boards proactively reach out to interested community members. Staff Member Deborah stated, "A resounding, no, this cannot continue... Under the current structure, it is not working. It is not sustainable and it's not effective."

Council members also shared feedback they had received from the community, noting that some board members feel the proposal is a "personal attack" and that residents often feel their time is "in vain" when recommendations are not acted upon. One council member asked where the Downtown Commission would land in the new structure, noting it is the economic hub for five counties. Staff suggested the work would likely fall under Planning and Economic Development, emphasizing the need to think about "where the work lands" rather than just "where the board lands."

Staff agreed to several follow-up actions during the session. They committed to defining the scopes of the proposed council committees and identifying which departments align with them. In response to a request from a council member, Staff Member Deborah stated, "Ms. Ronnie, we will try to... add that [staff liaisons/department alignment] to the proposal." Staff also agreed to create talking points to explain to the public how the restructure expands rather than limits voices. Additionally, staff will continue meeting with the "Restructure Working Group" to troubleshoot details and develop guidelines for working groups.

Mayor Esther Manheimer closed the meeting by emphasizing the cautious approach being taken. She stated, "I'm very glad we're doing a pilot, we're doing a go slow approach, we're experimenting, we're getting feedback from the community and the participants. And so I think that's hopefully reassuring to anyone who has any concerns or doubts about it that we're not jumping into the deep end, we're wading in very slowly." Staff indicated they would take the feedback heard that day and come back with a final recommendation related to council committees, though no specific timeline was provided.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XuCrZ5GYv3Q
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2799/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XuCrZ5GYv3Q)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
