# Noise Advisory Board

**Body:** City of Asheville — Noise Advisory Board
**Date:** May 9, 2022 1:00 PM EDT (2022-05-09T13:00:29-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4990/noise-advisory-board-may-9-2022

## Summary

The City of Asheville Noise Advisory Board held a meeting on May 9, 2022. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a review of monthly noise complaint data, discussions on residential noise enforcement, updates on citywide board restructuring, and presentations on specific sections of the noise ordinance.

## Key Decisions
The board’s only formal decision was the approval of the minutes from the previous meeting. A motion was made by Rick Freeman and seconded by a staff member. The chair called for a vote, and the present members—Rick Freeman, Jeff Santiago, and Carmelo Papalonio—voted in favor. The chair declared the motion approved.

## Discussion Highlights
A significant portion of the meeting focused on the high volume of noise complaints originating from multifamily apartment complexes. Staff reported that while complaints related to business operations and outdoor venues increased during the spring and summer, decibel readings at monitored events remained within legal limits, resulting in no violations. The debate centered on the difficulty of measuring the effectiveness of current enforcement strategies in dense housing.

Rick Freeman expressed concern that residential noise remains the highest category of complaints, asking if the team felt they were spending their time effectively and how they measured whether their actions were reducing noise. He emphasized, "you can't manage what you can't measure." In response, staff member Daniel Oropesa defended the department's approach, noting that relationships with property managers had led to a decrease in calls for police assistance, as issues were being resolved directly. Jeff Santiago supported the staff's efforts but stressed the need for accountability with property owners, asking if the board was requesting the creation of a dedicated team. Chair Jessica Tomasin advocated for realistic expectations, noting the difficulty of setting specific complaint targets without understanding the total number of apartments in Asheville.

The board also discussed the city’s initiative to restructure boards and commissions. Rick Freeman reported that a coalition of neighborhood groups has taken an opposition stance, arguing the city is not consulting existing board members. He stated that the group demanded the city halt its current work until it conducts in-depth interviews with every board and commission.

Additionally, staff presented an overview of the construction noise section of the ordinance, including time restrictions and permit processes, as well as an explanation of the three types of sound exceedance permits.

## Follow-ups
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting:
*   A staff member, referred to as "Charlie" in the transcript, agreed to send information about an acoustical sound absorption wall system to Chair Jessica Tomasin for consideration as a noise abatement technique.
*   Rick Freeman agreed to share the letter his group sent to City Council regarding the boards and commissions restructuring with the rest of the board. The chair suggested the board review the letter and table the topic for the next meeting.
*   Staff member Granye Miser indicated that a detailed presentation on the residential section of the noise ordinance is expected in November, after a full year of data is available.
*   The Sound Mitigation Working Group, consisting of Granye Miser, Carmelo Papalonio, Jeff Santiago, and Jessica Tomasin, committed to having information on good neighbor practices and business sound mitigation ready for the next meeting.

## Impact
This meeting highlights the ongoing challenge of balancing noise enforcement with the realities of dense urban living. The discussion underscores the complexity of measuring success in residential noise reduction, as staff must prioritize limited resources while working with property managers. The upcoming presentation on residential noise in November will provide a data-driven look at trends after a full year of monitoring. Additionally, the board’s engagement with the citywide restructuring process reflects the importance of maintaining effective advisory bodies that can address local quality-of-life issues.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBLuoTqHEFM
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2798/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBLuoTqHEFM)
