# Boards & Commissions Restructure Working Group

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** May 5, 2022 1:28 PM EDT (2022-05-05T13:28:28-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4992/boards-commissions-restructure-working-group-may-5-2022
**Outcome:** The working group discussed the boards and commissions restructuring process and agreed to provide a one-page rationale to the City Council.

## Summary

No formal votes were taken, and no motions were made or seconded during this meeting. Consequently, no decisions were recorded regarding the restructuring of city boards and commissions. A staff member clarified that the City Council has not voted on any restructuring plans or pilot programs. The staff member noted that an upcoming May 10 City Council meeting will include an update on the boards and commissions process and a review of council committees, but explicitly stated that no decisions are on the agenda for that future meeting.

## Discussion Highlights
The meeting focused on the "Boards & Commissions Restructure Working Group," though significant confusion arose regarding the scope of the group. A staff member serving as chair expressed the need for a "one pager and rationale justification" to explain the goals of the change and its impact on boards and commissions, stating that this information was necessary to pull more information from participants before moving forward. Another staff member emphasized the importance of hearing from people on boards and commissions, as well as from the general public, noting that "we need all voices."

Significant debate occurred regarding the approach to the restructuring. Commenters raised concerns that the City Council had not formally approved the plan, leading to questions about whether the process was moving forward without proper authorization. There was also discussion about the impact of the pandemic, with notes that many boards, such as the Transit Committee, lost members during that period, making the current baseline for restructuring difficult. The debate extended to whether the city’s proposed structure was designed in a "closed room" without sufficient consultation from long-serving board members and the general public.

## Community Input
Public commenters expressed frustration that previous city initiatives lacked clear timelines, budgets, or accountability, leading to years of stalled progress. One public commenter stated, "I have, like many people, have wasted years of my life sitting in various city meetings... and here I am, you know, 21 years later with the same issue." They requested clear organizational structures, timelines, and budget information for working groups. In response, a staff member replied, "I think that's the point of this working group... that's the work that we're going to do together in this working group is make those kind of recommendations."

Another public commenter stated, "I don't think that there was a vote by council to move forward with the boards and commissions restructuring yet." This commenter also noted that the Transit Committee is "not at its strongest" due to pandemic-related member loss and argued it was not the right time for existing members to dictate the committee's future. No specific member or staff member directly quoted a reply to this specific comment in the immediate following lines, though a staff member later addressed the general concern about council approval.

A third public commenter stated, "city council has not publicly discussed or approved a plan to restructure boards and commissions... I would suggest for this working group is that we focus... on making recommendations to produce a process that allows for more feedback... and also really importantly, slowing down this process." This commenter urged the group to "take a step back" and avoid "predetermined outcomes about four boards or five boards." No direct quote from a member or staff member responding specifically to this suggestion to slow down the process is recorded in the immediate lines following the comment, before the chair moved to the next speaker.

A fourth public commenter stated, "I am going to concur that we need to put a big fat pause On any direct recommendations to counsel until we have the time to take this down to the grassroots." This commenter argued that the current design was based on a "lousy baseline" due to the pandemic and that those who have served for years were not consulted. The chair responded, "All right, this has been very enlightening for me... I appreciate all of the work that you do." The chair then outlined next steps.

## Follow-ups
A staff member agreed to provide a "one pager and rationale justification" explaining the goals of the change and the impact of working groups on boards and commissions. This staff member also stated she would "go back and talk to them [the community] about the process" and would "go back and ask" the City Council if the process was voted on. Additionally, the staff member agreed to change the name of the working group to "work group function" to clarify the scope and avoid confusion with "restructuring." The staff member invited interested parties to join the next meeting to provide "deep recommendations."

Another staff member clarified that the May 10 City Council meeting will include an update on the boards and commissions process and a review of council committees, but explicitly stated, "No decisions are on the agenda for council." This staff member also agreed to a separate debrief call with the chair after the public meeting ended.

## Impact
This meeting highlights the current state of the city’s efforts to restructure its boards and commissions, which remains in a preliminary phase without formal council approval. The discussions underscored significant community concerns regarding accountability, timelines, and the inclusivity of the planning process. The clarification that the City Council has not voted on these plans indicates that the restructuring is not yet an authorized city action, but rather a working group initiative that requires further validation and public input before proceeding.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrAl2feG9yE
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2796/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrAl2feG9yE)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
