# Boards & Commissions - Restructuring Working Group

**Body:** City of Asheville — Boards and Commissions Committee
**Date:** May 5, 2022 12:00 PM EDT (2022-05-05T12:00:17-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4993/boards-commissions-restructuring-working-group-may-5-2022
**Outcome:** The working group recommended completing a comprehensive assessment of advisory boards and adopting a bottom-up communication strategy before finalizing restructuring decisions.

## Summary

On May 5, 2022, the City of Asheville’s Boards and Commissions Committee convened for the kickoff meeting of the Boards & Commissions Restructuring Working Group. The session focused on reviewing the City’s proposal to restructure its advisory boards and commissions, with the primary objective of defining the scope of work and gathering initial community input on the process.

## Key Decisions
The working group made two formal recommendations during the session. First, the group unanimously agreed, with no objections recorded, to recommend that a comprehensive assessment and rationale for the restructuring work must be completed. This includes a clear report on the current state of boards, their effectiveness, and the justification for any proposed changes. Second, the group agreed to recommend a clear communication strategy and a bottom-up approach to the restructuring process, ensuring that current board and commission members are interviewed and their concerns are heard before final decisions are made. No formal votes were taken on the restructuring proposal itself, as the meeting focused on defining the scope of work.

## Discussion Highlights
Staff presented an overview of the local government structure and the current state of the 20+ advisory boards, noting that while these boards provide valuable expertise, the system has become siloed with inconsistent communication pathways. Sarah Gross, Deputy City Clerk, emphasized that the work being done by boards and commissions is not going away, but rather the City hopes to align the work to better harness community expertise and prioritize solutions to real community issues.

Participants engaged in a "time capsule" exercise to reflect on Asheville’s identity and future. Gwynn Whistler, a City Council member, suggested putting a picture of the broken stones of the dance monument in the capsule to represent the community's current state. Dawa Hitch, Director of Communications & Public Engagement, suggested an arrowhead to represent the long history of people living in the area. Lucy Crown from the Transportation Department suggested the draft of the gap plan, and Kim Roney, a City Council member, suggested a list of Asheville High and SILSA graduates to honor their resilience through the pandemic.

## Community Input
Several public commenters raised significant concerns regarding the proposal. One commenter, identified as a former city council member, criticized the proposal as an effort to eliminate citizen input, stating, "I think that this proposal is total crap." Another commenter questioned the driving force behind the initiative, noting that a full assessment of how the 20+ boards are functioning has never been conducted. A third commenter suggested aligning boards with functional city departments to ensure better outcomes, while another proposed implementing sunset clauses for boards to allow for regular reevaluation of their charges.

In response to these comments, Sarah Gross clarified that the City has conducted internal assessments, including reviewing agendas, vacancies, and informal conversations, but agreed to formalize this into a report. Aisha Adams, the Facilitator, addressed concerns about the working group’s authority by explaining that while the group makes recommendations to staff and City Council, participants have the power to influence the process by lifting their voices. Adams also translated the "bottom-up" comments into a recommendation for a better communication plan.

## Follow-ups
Sarah Gross agreed to work on converting the internal assessment of boards and commissions into a formal report. She also confirmed that the working group’s recommendations and raw notes will be provided to City Council. Additionally, Gross noted that a City Council work session is scheduled for May 10, 2022, which will include an update on the boards and commissions restructuring goals and community feedback.

## Impact
This meeting marks the beginning of a formal process to restructure the City’s advisory boards and commissions. The decisions made to prioritize a comprehensive assessment and a bottom-up communication strategy aim to ensure that any changes are based on data and include input from those currently serving on these bodies. For residents, this process is significant as it will determine the future structure of citizen participation in local government, with the stated goal of improving efficiency and inclusion while preserving the value of volunteer labor.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rkr3Ebj_2GU
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3184/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rkr3Ebj_2GU)
