# Affordable Housing Advisory Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Affordable Housing Advisory Committee
**Date:** May 5, 2022 9:30 AM EDT (2022-05-05T09:30:15-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4994/affordable-housing-advisory-committee-may-5-2022
**Outcome:** The Affordable Housing Advisory Committee voted unanimously to pursue further discussion on using CDBG repair funds for manufactured homes and to support exploring shorter funding commitments for smaller projects.

## Summary

On May 5, 2022, the City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) held a virtual meeting to address housing inventory, regulatory barriers, and inter-agency coordination. The committee reviewed current housing market conditions, discussed the use of federal funds for manufactured homes, and received updates from various task forces.

## Key Decisions
The committee took three formal votes during the session, all of which passed unanimously via roll call:
*   **Approval of Minutes:** The committee approved the minutes from the previous meeting.
*   **CDBG Repair Funds for Manufactured Homes:** The committee voted to pursue further discussion on allowing Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) repair funds for manufactured homes.
*   **HCD Pass-Along Motion:** The committee voted to support exploring shorter-length funding commitments for smaller projects, a priority to be formally communicated to the Housing and Community Development (HCD) committee.

## Discussion Highlights
**Housing Inventory and Market Conditions**
Staff presented an Available Homes Report indicating a "bleak picture" with no new inventory and average house prices rising to approximately $449,000. Chair Paul Heathman described the situation as "really sad," noting that the committee has seen this same lack of inventory for several months.

**CDBG Funds and Manufactured Homes**
A significant portion of the meeting focused on regulatory barriers preventing the use of CDBG funds to repair manufactured homes not on permanent foundations. Staff member Jonathan Jones explained that under state and federal definitions, mobile homes not on permanent foundations are classified as motor vehicles rather than real property, making them ineligible for these repair funds. Member Andy Barnett challenged the committee to continue pushing on this issue, stating that the means someone uses to finance their home "shouldn't determine their access to health and safety and a dignified place to live."

**Task Force Updates**
The Connect Task Force reported on difficulties recruiting members with lived experience and expressed intent to review its 2008 charter to better align with its original purpose of providing public input and policy advice. The Build Task Force reported on ongoing meetings with stakeholders, including the Fire Department and builders, and the creation of a summary document to identify "low-hanging fruit" for housing production.

**Inter-Agency Coordination and Zoning**
The committee discussed its relationship with the HCD committee, noting a perceived lack of priority for affordable housing policy at that level. Chair Paul Heathman remarked, "Honestly, the gist I got out of it [the HCD meeting] was really most of HCD isn't very interested in affordable housing... I'm probably going to continue some of that [pushing back] and putting my foot in the door." Consequently, the committee decided to use a monthly "pass-along" agenda item to formally communicate priorities to HCD.

Additionally, the committee received a report on the Planning and Zoning Commission’s recent 5-1 vote in favor of open space text amendments, which will go to City Council. The Commission did not approve the rezoning of two city-owned parcels (Grant Center and a fire station) due to concerns about the pause on urban renewal property sales. Staff also clarified the impact of a recent North Carolina Court of Appeals ruling on short-term rentals (STRs), confirming that Asheville’s zoning-based restrictions remain valid, though annual permits for non-conforming units in commercial districts may be affected.

## Follow-ups
Several members and staff members agreed to specific follow-up actions:
*   **David Bartholomew** agreed to investigate how other municipalities have navigated CDBG regulations for manufactured home repairs. He stated he would reach out to the City of Concord and speak with colleagues at the Community Economic Development Conference in Wilmington, and agreed to present findings to the committee, potentially with the help of an intern.
*   **Jonathan Jones (Staff)** agreed to forward CDBG research documents to the local HUD field office to seek guidance.
*   **Scott Adams** agreed to share a reorganized summary document of the Build Task Force’s notes with the full committee and staff.
*   **Connect Task Force** agreed to take up the task of updating the affordable housing calculator with new interest rates, in collaboration with staff member Christina.
*   **Paul Heathman (Chair)** stated he would ask staff at every meeting for updates on Housing Trust Fund applications to ensure the committee is informed.

## Impact
This meeting highlighted the ongoing tension between regulatory definitions and housing needs, particularly regarding manufactured homes. By voting to pursue further discussion on CDBG funds and establishing a formal channel to communicate priorities to the HCD committee, the AHAC is actively working to remove bureaucratic barriers and ensure affordable housing remains a priority in city planning. The committee also began the process of updating its 2008 Affordable Housing Action Plan to better reflect current conditions.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yESdvnlP7Cs
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3264/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yESdvnlP7Cs)
