# Urban Forestry Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Urban Forestry Commission
**Date:** May 3, 2022 1:00 PM EDT (2022-05-03T13:00:31-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4995/urban-forestry-commission-may-3-2022
**Outcome:** The Urban Forestry Commission approved two alternative compliance requests for street tree standards and tabled the Rules and Procedures Manual until the next meeting.

## Summary

The Urban Forestry Commission of the City of Asheville held a meeting on May 3, 2022. The session focused on reviewing alternative compliance requests for street tree standards, receiving updates on bond-funded sidewalk projects, and discussing ongoing work from several internal working groups. The commission also addressed procedural matters, including the approval of previous minutes and the review of its Rules and Procedures Manual.

## Key Decisions
The commission took several votes during the session, all of which were unanimous with five ayes. The body approved the minutes from the previous meeting. It also approved two alternative compliance requests: one for 39 Patton Avenue, which included a suggestion to expand the tree pit area for an existing mature tree, and another for 980 Brevard Road, which allowed for the required trees to be distributed more evenly across the parking lot. Regarding the Rules and Procedures Manual, the commission did not vote to approve the document at this time. Instead, the body unanimously voted to table the discussion until the next meeting to allow members time to review the section on selecting new members. The meeting concluded with a unanimous vote to adjourn.

## Discussion Highlights
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to updates from the commission’s working groups. The Policy Working Group discussed revisions to Ordinance 719 and Chapter 20, noting that they are close to finalizing soil volume requirements and are exploring suspended pavement systems as an alternative to traditional tree pits. Ed Macy, a commission member, stated that the group’s position has always been that "more is better with respect to soil buying," citing concerns about the unknown.

The commission also debated the Recommended Species List, specifically discussing the addition of a column to identify trees not appropriate for parking lots. Ed Macy noted that the group is moving toward using the term "appropriate species list" instead of "recommended species list" to ensure that non-native invasive species are not used for zoning credits or canopy requirements. The Budget Request Working Group reported on efforts to secure funding for an Urban Forester position and an Urban Forest Master Plan, while the Fee-in-Lieu Working Group discussed the framework for spending fee-in-lieu funds in light of the city’s support for the Ravenscroft Reserve Initiative.

Jade Dundas, Director of Capital Projects, provided an update on ongoing bond-funded sidewalk projects, specifically highlighting the challenges and tree canopy impacts associated with the Vermont Street and New Hawk Creek sidewalk projects. Dundas stated that she wanted to introduce herself to the group, express appreciation for their work, and open up an opportunity for feedback on how the departments can collaborate in the future. Kim Roney, a guest/staff member, emphasized that restoring and maintaining the tree canopy is an important step in restoring neighborhoods that have been divested from. Additionally, Dawn Chavez, a commission member, stressed the importance of commission members reading through documents regarding quorum and public discourse, noting that communications between now and the next meeting should follow codes of ethics into quorum.

## Follow-ups
Staff member Nancy Watford agreed to send a follow-up email to commission members with links to documents regarding quorum and public discourse, including points raised about avoiding quorum in communications. Ben Woody, the Assistant City Manager, was noted to be out of town at a conference; upon his return, he will touch base with the Chair regarding outreach to Duke Energy for a presentation on tree pruning. Commission members were asked to review the Rules and Procedures manual and add comments to a Google document regarding the selection process for new members before the next meeting. Finally, the Budget Working Group agreed to be prepared with a plan of action, including public comment strategies, in case the Urban Forester or Master Plan funding is not included in the City Manager’s draft budget.

## Impact
These decisions and discussions impact residents by shaping how the city manages its urban forest and public infrastructure. The approval of alternative compliance requests ensures that specific development projects on Patton Avenue and Brevard Road can proceed while maintaining necessary tree coverage. The ongoing work on the Rules and Procedures Manual aims to formalize the process for selecting new commission members, which will influence future governance of the urban forest. Furthermore, the focus on funding for an Urban Forester and a Master Plan, as well as the collaboration on sidewalk projects, addresses the long-term health of the city’s tree canopy and the integration of green infrastructure with public works.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IkYqln_IqBA
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2801/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IkYqln_IqBA)
