# Human Relations Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Human Relations Commission of Asheville
**Date:** April 21, 2022 5:44 PM EDT (2022-04-21T17:44:57-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5002/human-relations-commission-apr-21-2022
**Outcome:** The Human Relations Commission removed two commissioners for non-attendance and postponed the vote on procedural rule changes until the following month.

## Summary

The Human Relations Commission of Asheville held a virtual meeting on April 21, 2022, to address administrative updates, procedural changes, and the status of various working groups. The session began with the approval of the minutes from the March 17, 2022 meeting, which passed unanimously via roll call vote. Staff from the Office of Equity and Inclusion provided updates on the formation of a Policy Equity Analysis Group, the launch of a monthly newsletter, the introduction of a new resident complaint and inquiry form, and a $10,000 grant from the Children and Nature Network for youth programming.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the removal of two commissioners who had failed to attend 75% of meetings in the preceding 12 months. Motions to remove Commissioner Alfred Green and Commissioner Emma Nicole Worthy were both seconded by Commissioner Harvey Dean Harrell. Both motions passed unanimously, with all present commissioners voting in favor. Chair Tonya Rodriguez noted that these individuals had not attended any meetings for two years, stating it was time to "make space for people who would like to join the HRCA." Councilwoman Kim Rooney supported the removals, explaining that non-participation makes it difficult for the group to maintain a quorum and work effectively.

The commission also discussed proposed changes to the Human Relations Commission Rules of Procedure, specifically regarding membership composition. However, the vote on these changes was postponed rather than taken. Chair Tonya Rodriguez suggested pausing the vote until the following month to correct a typo in the Latinx/Latino/Latina section and to ensure the document is complete before it is sent to City Council. During the discussion, Commissioner Suzy Chandler expressed support for the new language, noting that it was effective because it was not specific about the numbers of minorities and underrepresented populations.

Updates from various working groups were presented, covering topics such as Intergovernmental Relations, Community Engagement, Addressing Housing Issues, Examining Systems, and Improving HRCA. In the "Examining Systems" working group, Commissioner Daniel Young raised concerns about the lack of diversity in school staff, stating, "I went to the Martha store and they had a whole staff full of white teachers, no black teachers... How is anybody going to teach our kids about history that don't look like us? ... Our kids voices are not being heard." Additionally, Vice Chair Brandon Oliver promoted an upcoming Children’s Day event, which will feature music, free food, door prizes, pinatas, games, and resources for the underserved community.

Several follow-up actions were identified during the meeting. Staff member Elena Schmidt agreed to bring the question of public input to the first meeting of the Policy Equity Analysis Group. Councilwoman Kim Rooney stated she could collect reports on the intentions of the original Blue Ribbon Committee to help clarify the commission’s history. Chair Tonya Rodriguez directed Commissioner Daniel Young to bring more information on equity stipends for volunteer board members to the "Improving HRCA" working group. Staff member Sarah Gross noted that a working group on the restructuring of boards and commissions will hold its first meeting on May 5. Furthermore, Commissioner Tiffany Flourney-Devolo suggested creating a one-sheet document for distribution at community events, which staff member Elena Schmidt noted she was writing down. Commissioner Melanie Noyes-Espinoza stated she would email the committee if the housing recommendation is ready before a specific meeting so members can review it in advance.

There were no public comments recorded during this meeting, as staff confirmed there were no callers in the queue for live public comment. The meeting concluded with announcements for local events, including the Peace Garden/Market and a "Dining Out for Life" fundraiser, as well as a preview of future agenda items such as equity training, complaint processes, and mentorship programs.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=261p_PaHiVg
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2805/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=261p_PaHiVg)
