# Transit Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Transit Committee
**Date:** April 19, 2022 3:30 PM EDT (2022-04-19T15:30:22-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5003/transit-committee-apr-19-2022
**Outcome:** The Transit Committee elected Harvey Harrow as Chair and Sandy Aldridge as Vice Chair unanimously and sent a new member application to the Multimodal Transportation Commission.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Transit Committee held a hybrid virtual and in-person meeting on April 19, 2022. The agenda focused on establishing new leadership, reviewing the committee’s operational schedule, and addressing critical challenges in transit service, including driver shortages, budget constraints, and ridership data discrepancies. The committee also received a presentation on data-driven decision-making frameworks and reviewed the status of the 2018 Transit Master Plan.

**Key Decisions**
The committee approved the minutes from previous meetings, including those from August 17, 2021, December 15, 2021, and February 15, 2022. The August and December minutes passed with split votes, while the February minutes passed unanimously. Councilwoman Kim Roman, serving as a liaison, clarified that under North Carolina regulations, an abstention is counted as a "yes" if the motion is approved by a majority. The committee unanimously elected Harvey Harrow as the new Chair and Sandy Aldridge as the new Vice Chair. Regarding the application of Mr. Colon Kenton to join the committee, the Chair recommended forwarding the application to the Multimodal Transportation Commission for further review and approval; staff confirmed the application would be placed on the Multimodal Commission’s agenda for their next meeting. The committee discussed changing the regular meeting time from 3:30–5:30 PM to 5:00–7:00 PM to accommodate member availability. No formal motion or vote was recorded for this change; staff indicated that an official motion was not required to proceed, provided the public is notified in advance.

**Discussion Highlights**
Staff presented an update on the reduction of service frequency on the W1 route due to driver shortages. Jessica, a transit staff member, noted that the department is supposed to have approximately 65 drivers for current service but is currently closer to 51 or 52, which provides a four-driver buffer. Barry, another transit staff member, explained that in the last 10 hires, no candidates held a Commercial Driver’s License (CDL); instead, the department hired individuals new to the industry, such as those with customer service experience, because it is easier to train them. Barry emphasized the lack of secure state funding for transit in North Carolina compared to other states. The committee also discussed the 2018 Transit Master Plan, noting constraints regarding vehicle size and facility capacity. Jessica explained that the fleet is predominantly 30-foot buses to maximize capacity per driver, and that electric buses are currently larger (35+ feet) and do not fit well on existing narrow routes.

**Community Input**
A public commenter asked if the Transit Committee had undergone the Results-Based Accountability (RBA) process presented by the Office of Data and Performance (ODAP). Staff member Jessica responded that while she had received training, the committee had not formally gone through it together, noting that transit already collects significant data due to federal funding requirements. Another public commenter asked if contract workers or Uber subsidies were options to address the driver shortage. Jessica explained that the driver shortage is a national crisis, particularly for CDL holders, and that while the city is looking at budget options for wage increases, they cannot afford them immediately. She clarified the W1 cut was chosen because parallel routes exist to mitigate the impact. A public commenter requested bus utilization reports (passengers per stop) in the monthly packet, noting a discrepancy between his observation of empty buses and staff claims of "full" buses. Jessica explained that generating per-stop data for 600+ stops is resource-intensive, but they could potentially provide general data on peak times and capacity per route. A public commenter suggested exploring funding from tourism dollars (TDA) to support transit infrastructure and route expansion, noting that tourists currently do not use the system.

**Follow-ups**
Staff member Jessica agreed to check with the new applicant, Mr. Kenton, regarding the proposed meeting time change before sending out public notifications. Jessica also agreed to look into providing more general bus utilization and capacity data, specifically peak times per route, for the committee, acknowledging that per-stop data is too granular for current reporting. Staff agreed to analyze the time of day for peak ridership on each route and the number of people on the buses to better understand the demand profile. Committee member Sandy Aldridge stated she would speak with other riders to gather specific issues and forward them to RATP Dev and the City.

**Impact**
These discussions highlight the ongoing operational challenges facing the Asheville transit system, particularly the national driver shortage and the resulting service adjustments. The election of new leadership and the potential shift in meeting times aim to improve committee accessibility and engagement. The focus on ridership data discrepancies and vehicle sizing reflects a broader effort to align service levels with actual demand and infrastructure constraints, which will influence future route planning and resource allocation.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ujDJrz8E-BI
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2812/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ujDJrz8E-BI)
