# Downtown Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Downtown Commission
**Date:** April 8, 2022 9:30 AM EDT (2022-04-08T09:30:09-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5010/downtown-commission-apr-8-2022
**Outcome:** The Downtown Commission approved the draft action minutes and discussed a presentation on migratory bird safety and lighting.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Downtown Commission convened on April 8, 2022, to review recent minutes and discuss several key initiatives affecting the downtown area. The agenda included presentations on migratory bird safety and lighting, updates on homelessness services, results from the recent downtown business survey, and the status of the Public Space Management Task Force. The meeting concluded with staff updates on ongoing projects, including Pack Square Plaza, the Southside Vision Plan, and proposed bike lanes.

**Key Decisions**
The commission’s only formal vote was to approve the draft action minutes from the March 11 meeting. A motion was made and seconded, and the chair called for a roll call vote, which passed. The meeting was subsequently adjourned by a motion that was seconded and passed.

**Discussion Highlights**
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to a presentation by Danielle DiBella of the Lights Out Initiative, who highlighted that Asheville is listed in the top 125 cities for migration-disrupting light pollution. DiBella requested that the commission connect with the design review committee to promote bird-safe development. In response, Commissioner Andrew Fletcher offered to provide a contact for a building owner or manager to help the initiative connect with stakeholders.

The commission also received an update from Emily Ball of the City of Asheville’s Community and Economic Development department regarding homelessness. Ball reported that the homeless population has remained stable between 500 and 600 people over the last 12 years and noted that the Ramada shelter closure wound down effectively, with most individuals who returned to being unsheltered having housing plans or already moving into new housing. Sage Turner, the City Council Liaison, informed the commission that the Home Consortium received an additional $4.7 million in Rescue Plan funding for homelessness and invited the commission to make recommendations on how to use these funds, which she would take to the consortium.

Regarding the downtown business survey, Megan Rogers of the Downtown Association presented results indicating that homelessness, safety, and cleanliness were the top three issues facing businesses, while parking had slipped to fourth place. Rogers noted that safety perceptions dropped significantly from roughly 3.5 out of 5 during the day to just below 2 at night. On the Public Space Management Task Force, staff member Dana explained that the task force will be asked to narrow an initial list of 15 priorities down to a top three for the year ahead. Additionally, Dana stated that interviews with top firms for the Pack Square Plaza project are scheduled for the following week, with the community engagement process anticipated to begin in May.

**Community Input**
No formal public comments were received during the designated comment period. The chair noted that while a number was attempting to connect, no resident or member of the public provided remarks.

**Follow-ups**
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting:
*   **Danielle DiBella** (Lights Out Initiative) stated she would follow up with information regarding the percentage of other cities with similar terrain and data on how natural landscapes, such as green roofs, impact bird safety.
*   **Emily Ball** (City of Asheville) stated she would follow up with information on other communities that have reached "functional zero" for specific populations, such as veterans or the chronically homeless, and send it to the commission.
*   **Megan Rogers** (Downtown Association) stated she would share the link to the recorded State of Downtown Luncheon and the summary data from the business survey with the group. She also stated she would follow up with Emily Ball regarding the survey results on homelessness and safety to discuss how to move those issues forward.
*   **Megan Rogers** agreed to look into including a comparison of current survey results to 2019 data in the mid-year survey to understand the impact of the pandemic.
*   **Dana** (Staff) stated she would conduct a survey of commission members regarding their preferences for returning to in-person meetings and the new meeting time (9:30 AM vs. pre-pandemic 8:30 AM).

**Impact**
This meeting provided the commission with critical data on the current state of downtown Asheville, particularly regarding the shifting priorities of local businesses and the stability of the homeless population. The discussions on lighting and bird safety highlight the intersection of environmental concerns and urban development, while the review of the Public Space Management Task Force priorities signals a focus on targeted improvements for public spaces in the coming year.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B1ufer5V3Ws
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2821/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B1ufer5V3Ws)
