# Public Safety Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Public Safety Committee
**Date:** March 30, 2022 11:00 AM EDT (2022-03-30T11:00:08-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5017/public-safety-committee-mar-30-2022
**Outcome:** The Public Safety Committee recommended a resolution to increase the police background check contract to $140,000 and heard an update on violent crime trends.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Public Safety Committee met on March 30, 2022, to review departmental contracts and receive updates on crime trends. The agenda included the approval of previous meeting minutes, a review of a funding increase for police background checks, and a presentation on violent crime data and forensic technology.

**Key Decisions**
The committee voted unanimously (3 Ayes) to approve the minutes from the February meeting. The committee also voted unanimously (3 Ayes) to recommend the adoption of a resolution allowing the Asheville Police Department (APD) to increase funding for an existing contract with USS ISS Agency for background investigation services. The resolution increases the total contract value from $80,000 to $140,000 and allows the City Manager to approve any future increases due to volume or contract renewal. Although a friendly amendment was proposed to remove the provision for automatic approval by the City Manager, the chair called for a vote on the original motion, which passed.

**Discussion Highlights**
Police Chief David Zak and Captain Kevin McGowan presented an update on violent crime trends, emphasizing that APD’s approach is "very targeted" and relies less on routine traffic stops for evidence recovery. Chief Zak stated that the department aims to continue its 2021 successes by building community trust through transparency, accountability, and responsiveness. Captain McGowan highlighted the acquisition of Ballistics IQ technology, which provides real-time data to detectives, eliminating the need to re-interview witnesses or re-examine evidence.

During the contract discussion, Councilwoman Kim Roney proposed a friendly amendment to remove the clause allowing the City Manager to automatically approve future cost increases, stating she wanted those increases to return to City Council for review. Councilwoman Sandra Kilgore expressed a similar view, noting that while she was prepared to approve the current contract, she did not want to include automatic approval for future periods without a review of outcomes.

**Community Input**
Two members of the public provided comments. A resident spoke at the beginning of the meeting, arguing that previous police data regarding crime in encampments was falsified to justify sweeps that pushed people to the margins. She disputed the notion that increased police presence creates safety, citing data on police killings during traffic stops and referencing the Southside community’s experience with gentrification and policing. She suggested the committee look at Denver’s STAR program, which uses mental health professionals for non-violent calls, and noted that APD had charged 15 individuals with felonies in retaliation for protesting the treatment of unhoused folks. Members did not respond to these specific points.

A second public commenter, identifying himself as a candidate for Asheville City Council, spoke at the end of the meeting. He referenced a newspaper article by a mayoral candidate regarding a desire to avoid "zero tolerance" policies and noted that APD has not had fatalities during interactions, though he acknowledged a serious injury occurred during the June 2020 civil unrest. He requested that the committee review a 20-year graph of all crime and stated that the ban on discussing organized crime in Asheville is over, particularly regarding illegally manufactured fentanyl operations. Members did not respond to these specific points.

**Follow-ups and Impact**
No members or staff explicitly agreed to specific follow-up tasks, such as drafting new policies or requesting specific reports, during the meeting. Police Chief David Zak stated that APD is "still working with community leaders and trying to identify community partners to assist us in violence interruption" and noted that the department is "always looking for partners," though some leaders who had expressed interest have since changed their minds.

The approval of the background investigation contract ensures that APD has the necessary funding to conduct checks on new hires, with the total cost rising to $140,000. The resolution allows for future adjustments to the contract value based on volume or renewal terms, subject to the City Manager’s approval.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9QtpqNtPxW4
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2818/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9QtpqNtPxW4)
