# Noise Advisory Board

**Body:** City of Asheville — Noise Advisory Board
**Date:** March 14, 2022 1:00 PM EDT (2022-03-14T13:00:15-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5027/noise-advisory-board-mar-14-2022
**Outcome:** The Noise Advisory Board accepted a proposal to examine trash collection, construction, and amplification near schools and medical facilities over the next three months and established a working group to develop noise mitigation resources.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Noise Advisory Board met on March 14, 2022, to review recent noise complaint data, discuss the City’s proposal to restructure advisory boards, and plan for upcoming ordinance reviews. The meeting began with the approval of the minutes from the February 17, 2022 meeting, which passed unanimously. Staff presented a report on recent noise complaints, highlighting changes in how the Asheville Police Department categorizes calls and the challenges associated with complaints where no contact information is provided. The board also discussed the distinction between noise volume and content, specifically regarding street performers and preachers.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the City’s proposal to consolidate various advisory boards into four larger working groups. Board members expressed concern that this restructuring could dilute the board’s ability to fulfill its specific mandate. Rick Freeman stated, “I’m a bit concerned that this really dilutes our ability to do what we were asked to do.” Jessica Tomasin, serving as Chair, added, “I think it’s premature for them to go off and restructure... I hate to see companies or organizations or governments go off and do something that they announce and then haven't thought it all the way through.” Assistant City Manager Ben Woody responded by emphasizing the value of community involvement, stating, “I do think, you know, I think the advisory boards are an important function... I like there's community involvement. It shouldn't be just staff.”

The board also addressed data accessibility and training needs. Staff presented a spreadsheet containing 750 lines of complaint data, and the board discussed the need for better visualization and training to effectively analyze this information. Rick Freeman offered his time to help other members learn how to filter and sort the data, noting, “If anybody needs some training on how to filter the data or sort the data... I would offer my time.” He also expressed frustration with recurring complaints that lack contact information, saying, “I just hate to see this here every month for the next nine and do nothing about it. That's my concern.”

In terms of specific actions, the board accepted a staff proposal to examine three non-seasonal components of the noise ordinance in detail over the next three months: trash collection, construction, and amplification near schools and medical facilities. Staff confirmed they would begin with waste collection at the next meeting. Additionally, a working group was established to develop community-facing noise mitigation resources. This group consists of board members Jeff Santiago, Carmelo Papalonio, and Jessica Tomasin, along with staff member Granye Miser. Granye Miser proposed the small group to leverage technical expertise, stating, “I think it would be a shame to pass over some of the technical expertise we have on this board... I would really like to ask that of the board... that maybe I would work with three of you in a small group.”

During the public comment period, one emailed comment was read aloud by the Chair. A resident of a condo on South Market Street stated that the current ordinance allowing front-end loaders to operate between 7 p.m. and 5 a.m. is “not working.” The commenter reported that metal dumpsters being emptied before 6:30 a.m. wake residents and exceed the 62 decibel limit for that time period, requesting that the ordinance be changed to allow later hours or that heavy-duty plastic dumpsters be used in the Central Business District to reduce noise. The Chair noted that this comment relates to the trash collection topic scheduled for detailed discussion at the next meeting. No other members or staff responded directly to the content of the comment during the meeting.

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Staff members Granye Miser and Daniel Oropesa agreed to bring a detailed report on waste collection to the next meeting. Staff member Haley Mahoney agreed to resend the board and commission restructuring information to board members and will share updates once the City packages feedback from recent engagement sessions. Board members Jeff Santiago, Carmelo Papalonio, and Jessica Tomasin agreed to participate in the mitigation working group. Additionally, all board members agreed to review the data dashboards and reports before the next meeting. Assistant City Manager Ben Woody offered to speak to the channel of communication if the board is restructured into a working group.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UpT8GQ3yLW8
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2835/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UpT8GQ3yLW8)
