# Boards & Commissions

**Body:** City of Asheville — Boards and Commissions Committee
**Date:** March 8, 2022 10:00 AM EST (2022-03-08T10:00:36-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5032/boards-commissions-mar-8-2022
**Outcome:** The committee recommended several board appointments unanimously and re-advertised the electrical journeyman seat after withdrawing a nomination over a potential conflict of interest.

## Summary

On March 8, 2022, the City of Asheville’s Boards and Commissions Committee convened to address vacancies on various city boards, review annual reports, and discuss the ongoing restructuring of boards and commissions. The committee began by approving the minutes from its previous meetings on January 11 and February 8, with both sets of minutes passing by unanimous vote.

## Key Decisions and Appointments
The committee took action to fill several vacancies across different commissions. Unanimous votes were cast to recommend the appointment of Ashley Wilberding to the African American Heritage Commission, Allison Smith to the Citizen Police Advisory Commission (replacing Robert Cooper), and Shelly Jackson to the Historic Resources Commission. For the Design Review Committee, the committee unanimously voted to reassign Kimberly Hunter from the Downtown Commission representative seat to an At-Large seat. Additionally, the committee unanimously recommended Catherine and Kiah for the Asheville Area Riverfront Redevelopment Commission representative seats, and Ricardo Cejo and Christina Booher for At-Large seats on the Design Review Committee.

Regarding the Board of Electrical Examiners, the committee unanimously voted to move Rick Sluder from the journeyman seat to the electrical contractor seat. However, the appointment of Jonathan Knox to the resulting journeyman seat was not finalized. Councilwoman Mosley suggested keeping the seat open for another month to allow for other applications, citing a potential conflict of interest because Knox and Sluder work for the same company. Councilwoman Roney supported this suggestion, and the motion to appoint Knox was withdrawn. The committee agreed to re-advertise the position.

## Discussion Highlights
Staff provided updates on the submission of annual reports by boards and commissions and the public workshops regarding the restructuring of boards and commissions. During the discussion on the Board of Electrical Examiners, Councilwoman Roney asked if there were legal requirements for appointees to be from different companies. Staff member Rachel Wood responded that there is no legal requirement for appointees to be from different companies, but noted that if there is a financial interest or conflict of interest, both individuals might have to recuse themselves if it is beneficial to one.

Concerns regarding the board restructuring were raised by Councilwoman Mosley, who noted that the committee had received several emails not in support of the current proposal, with several specifically mentioning the African American Heritage Commission. Councilwoman Roney, serving as liaison to the Urban Forestry Commission, stated that the Urban Forestry Commission made a formal recommendation not supporting the restructure as proposed and would like to consider taking on stormwater issues as part of an umbrella consolidation.

## Follow-ups
Staff member Sarah Gross agreed to communicate to boards that the committee is flexible with the timing of annual reports, in response to Councilwoman Roney’s suggestion that the January 31st deadline might be too tight due to holiday rescheduling. Gross also stated that recordings of the restructuring workshops (excluding the first one due to technical issues) and the "jam boards" used for discussion will be posted to the project page following the week. Additionally, in response to Councilwoman Mosley’s request, Gross agreed to reach out to Brenda, the liaison, to facilitate a discussion at the African American Heritage Commission’s upcoming meeting to get a formal recommendation regarding the restructuring proposal.

## Impact
These decisions ensure that key city commissions, including those focused on heritage, public safety, design, and historic resources, have the necessary representation to continue their work. The decision to re-advertise the journeyman seat on the Board of Electrical Examiners reflects a commitment to addressing potential conflicts of interest and allowing for broader community participation. The ongoing dialogue regarding the restructuring of boards and commissions highlights active engagement with community feedback and formal recommendations from specific commissions, such as the Urban Forestry Commission, as the city considers changes to its governance structure.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rlgrzku3vGE
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2833/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rlgrzku3vGE)
