# Affordable Housing Advisory Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Affordable Housing Advisory Committee
**Date:** March 3, 2022 9:30 AM EST (2022-03-03T09:30:10-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5033/affordable-housing-advisory-committee-mar-3-2022
**Outcome:** The Affordable Housing Advisory Committee unanimously recommended that the city adapt incentive programs for small-scale development and amended the CDBG manual to allow manufactured housing on non-permanent foundations to qualify for rehabilitation funds.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) held a virtual meeting on March 3, 2022, to address strategic housing policies, market data, and specific project updates. The agenda covered the consolidation of city advisory boards, the scarcity of affordable housing inventory, and the implementation of incentive programs for developers. The committee also reviewed updates on several key housing projects, including the 319 Biltmore development and a new permanent affordable housing project on West Haywood Street.

**Key Decisions**
The committee took three formal votes during the meeting. First, a motion to accept the previous meeting’s action minutes was made, seconded, and passed unanimously via roll call vote. Second, the committee voted unanimously to recommend that the city adopt or adapt existing incentive programs to promote small-scale development or rehabilitation for affordable housing. Third, the committee unanimously voted to amend the City of Asheville Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) manual. This amendment removes the requirement that manufactured housing be on a permanent foundation to be eligible for CDBG-funded home rehabilitation, aligning local rules with federal guidelines to allow organizations to serve the approximately 15% of the community living in manufactured housing.

**Discussion Highlights**
A significant portion of the discussion focused on the local housing market and the challenges facing developers. Committee member Andy Barnett noted that HUD’s home sales price limits are now "way below what appraised values are coming back at," meaning state and federal funds cannot be used for many locally built homes because local appreciation is rising faster than HUD’s annual calculations. Committee member Chris Day reported a "huge uptick" in developers moving projects to surrounding counties such as Henderson, Haywood, and Transylvania, noting it is "significantly more than I've seen in the last 16 years." Chair Barry Bialik expressed concern about the scarcity of affordable inventory, stating, "It's amazing. I mean, I feel like it's like watching something slide away from us."

The committee also debated the restructuring of city advisory boards, with Chair Barry Bialik expressing concern that the conversation is happening during a time when in-person interaction is limited. He stated, "I really hope that, you know, we're allowed to have physical meetings about this before decisions are made for us." Regarding incentive programs, Committee member Andy Barnett argued that requiring 20-30 year deed restrictions for small fee rebates or short-term construction loans is a barrier to production, stating, "It seems, it almost seems wrong because it discourages production to go towards the right thing." Committee member Brandy Woodard expressed frustration with the lack of tangible outcomes, stating, "I'd like to see more action... make some true action and move forward in that way."

On the topic of manufactured housing, planner Ricky highlighted a critical issue where mobile home spaces in non-conforming parks lose their status if vacant for 180 days, stating, "We're losing opportunity for housing stock one at a time. It's a very gradual erosion." Staff explained the urgency of the CDBG manual change, noting, "It would be great if we could get that done as the HCD is reviewing the upcoming rounds of CDBG funding so that organizations that operate those kinds of repair programs are able to finally be able to serve the 15 or so percent of our community that calls manufactured housing home."

**Community Input**
A public commenter from Children First Museum Schools expressed concern about the shrinking of federal housing resources. They noted that Congress is considering fiscal plans, including the Build Back Better Act, that offer opportunities to expand rental vouchers, Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) projects, and rehabilitation funding. The commenter requested that the committee contact the congressional delegation to advocate for these resources or recommend that City Council take a stand, arguing that local funds are insufficient. Members did not respond to the comment.

**Follow-ups**
Several staff members agreed to specific follow-up actions. Staff member Nikki agreed to follow up with a contact at "Lostar" regarding a spring meeting to discuss the "street sheet" and rental data. Staff member David agreed to work with realtors and use internal data, such as evictions and client contacts, to create a rental report, with an intern assigned to assist this summer. Staff member Jonathan Jones agreed to make the latest home sales price calculations, effective May 2021, publicly accessible via a link, removing the previous password requirement. Staff member Vadila offered to prepare slides to discuss specific concerns regarding flag lot standards if the committee wishes to pursue the topic. Staff member Sasha and planner Ricky agreed to discuss the "non-conforming" use issues, specifically the 180-day vacancy rule, to determine if it can be addressed in the work plan. The committee agreed to continue the broader conversation on manufactured housing policy in April.

Regarding specific projects, staff intends to work with Laurel Street Residential to achieve a developer agreement for the 319 Biltmore project, aiming to present it to City Council in the summer. Staff is targeting an April timeframe for the completion of the staff review of the Luigi micro-unit application through the Housing and Community Development (HCD) department. Additionally, staff stated an intent to have the Affordable Housing Officer and Specialist positions filled by the end of the fiscal year, with onboarding expected in April. The Chair stated that a request for a joint meeting with the HCD department has been sent, with a potential date in April.

**Impact**
These discussions and decisions reflect the committee's focus on addressing the acute shortage of affordable housing in Asheville. The amendment to the CDBG manual is significant as it expands eligibility for rehabilitation funds to a larger portion of the community, specifically those in manufactured housing. The recommendation to adapt incentive programs aims to encourage small-scale development by reducing long-term restrictions that may discourage production. The updates on the 319 Biltmore and West Haywood Street projects indicate ongoing efforts to secure permanent affordable housing units, with the West Haywood Street project featuring mixed-income units and a $2.5 million total investment from the City and County. The committee’s attention to data collection, such as rental prices and home sales, aims to provide a clearer picture of the local market to inform future policy decisions.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BWSh9l3ucCE
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2837/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BWSh9l3ucCE)
