# Urban Forestry Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Urban Forestry Commission
**Date:** February 22, 2022 1:00 PM EST (2022-02-22T13:00:38-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5041/urban-forestry-commission-feb-22-2022
**Outcome:** The Urban Forestry Commission formed working groups to develop a spending framework for tree preservation funds and draft a statement opposing the city's proposed board restructuring.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Urban Forestry Commission held a special meeting on February 22, 2022, structured as an annual planning retreat. The session focused on strategic planning, data utilization, the health impacts of urban trees, and the proposed restructuring of city boards and commissions. As a closed planning retreat, no public comment period was held, and no formal votes were taken on ordinances.

**Key Decisions and Working Groups**
While no formal votes occurred, the commission established several working groups to address ongoing priorities. The Chair proposed and confirmed the formation of a working group to develop a framework for spending "Fee-in-Lieu" funds, which will begin with meetings involving the Chair, Ed Macy, and Zoe Hoyle. Additionally, the commission decided to form a temporary working group to draft a formal statement opposing the city’s proposed restructuring of boards and commissions; this statement will be brought to a regular meeting for a vote. A new working group was also established to begin preliminary discussions on the structure of the Urban Forest Master Plan. The existing budget working group will continue for the current cycle, with the goal of dissolving it once the urban forester position and master plan funding are secured. Regarding the draft rules and procedures manual, the commission agreed to use a shared Google Document to collect comments, which will be reviewed at a regular meeting rather than through a formal working group.

**Discussion Highlights**
Special guest presenters from Planet Geo discussed trends in urban forestry, emphasizing the need for a long-term vision that is actively used rather than shelved. Dr. Ray Yeager from the University of Louisville presented on the "Green Heart Study," a clinical trial investigating how neighborhood greenery reduces cardiovascular disease risk, advocating for viewing tree canopy as essential to community health. City staff from Development Services presented on the status of the Tree Canopy Protection Ordinance’s "Fee-in-Lieu" program, noting that legal advice confirmed funds can be used for land acquisition to preserve mature trees. Staff and members also discussed data metrics, noting that while individual departments track planting and removal data, there is no centralized city-wide repository for this information.

The commission spent significant time discussing the City of Asheville’s proposal to restructure its boards and commissions. Members expressed concern that the proposal reverses the traditional bottom-up flow of ideas and could eliminate the commission’s unique role in tree protection. One member urged all attendees to oppose the restructuring, describing it as an effort by development interests to limit community input. Another member highlighted that the commission is a "highly functioning" board that does not require additional staff support. A member noted that combining the commission with Planning and Zoning would subordinate tree protection priorities to development interests, as Planning and Zoning holds quasi-judicial power.

**Follow-Ups**
Several staff and members agreed to specific follow-up actions. The Chair agreed to initiate the Fee-in-Lieu working group, and commission members Ed Macy, Zoe Hoyle, and the Chair agreed to form the working group for the Urban Forest Master Plan. Commission members Perrin, Sharon, and Ed agreed to collaborate on drafting the formal statement opposing the board restructuring, with the chair sending existing drafts to the group. Staff member Nancy Watford agreed to check if square footage of removed trees is currently tracked on all plans or only percentages to help determine realistic reporting metrics. Additionally, staff members Nancy Watford, Chris Collins, and Ricky agreed to sit down with the commission’s "wish list" of data metrics to determine what information can be gathered. Dr. Ray Yeager agreed to share his presentation slides (excluding preliminary, unreviewed data) with the commission. Assistant City Manager Ben Woody agreed to consult with the clerk’s office regarding how the commission’s ongoing priorities will be handled if the board restructuring proceeds, committing to providing an answer at the next regular meeting.

**Impact on Residents**
This meeting addressed the future of urban tree management in Asheville, particularly in the face of proposed administrative changes. The discussions highlighted the tension between development interests and tree protection, with members expressing concern that restructuring could diminish community input and eliminate the commission’s role in alternative compliance. The focus on the "Fee-in-Lieu" program and land acquisition underscores the city's intent to use collected funds to preserve mature trees, which residents may see as a more effective strategy than planting new trees. Furthermore, the emphasis on data centralization and health impacts reflects a growing recognition that tree canopy is a critical component of public health and environmental justice, rather than merely an aesthetic amenity.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JHhhZh-GQ7I
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2851/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JHhhZh-GQ7I)
