# Downtown Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Downtown Commission
**Date:** February 11, 2022 9:30 AM EST (2022-02-11T09:30:11-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5049/downtown-commission-feb-11-2022
**Outcome:** Downtown Commission elected its new officers and unanimously recommended a 24/7 public restroom for downtown Asheville.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Downtown Commission met on February 11, 2022, to address several key items regarding downtown development, board governance, and public safety. The agenda included updates on the PAC Square improvements, a development impact review for a proposed building at 72 Broadway, and a proposal from City Council to restructure advisory boards. The commission also elected its new officers and discussed ongoing efforts related to homelessness and public space management.

**Key Decisions**
The commission approved the draft action minutes from the January 14, 2022 meeting via a unanimous roll call vote. The body then held elections for its leadership positions. In a roll call vote for Vice Chair, Andrew Fletcher was elected with 7 votes, defeating nominee Guido Rodriguez who received 4 votes. For the Chair position, Brian Moffitt was the sole nominee; the vote passed unanimously, though one member noted they "should have voted against" the nomination but ultimately voted in favor, resulting in a unanimous tally. Additionally, the commission unanimously passed a motion recommending the need for a 24/7 outdoor public restroom facility in downtown Asheville. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn.

**Discussion Highlights**
Staff presented an overview of the PAC Square improvements project, which aims to reimagine the area following the removal of the Vance Monument. A staff member noted that the city and county are currently seeking a project manager to lead community engagement and planning, with a request for proposals due on February 21. Regarding the proposed nine-story mixed-use building at 72 Broadway, Commissioner Steven Lee Johnson expressed strong skepticism, stating that the project is "dead in its tracks" and that the architecture firm must realize the current design "is just not going to float." Commissioner Andrew Fletcher added that the submitted drawings make it difficult to place the building in its context, increasing his skepticism of the project.

The commission also discussed a City Council proposal to restructure advisory boards and commissions to improve efficiency. Commissioner Andrew Fletcher raised concerns that the process was not community-led and that the plan had "almost nil" elasticity. He emphasized that the success of these boards depends on whether council liaisons attend meetings and whether dedicated staff are attached to them, warning that the city cannot ignore citizens and then ask why they have been ignored. On the topic of homelessness, Commissioner Sage Turner stated that the people experiencing homelessness are not the problem, but rather the infrastructure and cultural conditions that allow the issue to persist. Commissioner Andrew Fletcher expressed disappointment that the city’s primary tool appears to be shuffling the locations of homelessness rather than changing the conditions that lead to it, noting that housing is the solution. Commissioner Guido Rodriguez shared that he has heard many visitors comment on their perception that downtown is no longer safe due to homelessness, stating that he is listening and beginning to change his views.

**Follow-ups**
Staff member Dana agreed to add links to the Board Restructuring PowerPoint presentation, FAQ document, and project page to the downtown update report so all members can review them. Dana also agreed to work to fill remaining slots on the Public Space Management Committee and send out a scheduling poll for a meeting within the next two weeks. Commissioners Robin Raines and Megan Rogers agreed to serve as liaisons for homelessness issues, coordinating with the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee and Affordable Housing Advisory Committee to report back to the Downtown Commission. Staff member Shannon noted that the 72 Broadway project will return to the Design Review Committee for further design development.

**Impact**
These decisions and discussions highlight the commission’s focus on balancing development with community needs and public safety. The unanimous recommendation for a 24/7 public restroom addresses a specific infrastructure gap in downtown. The critical feedback on the 72 Broadway project signals that the commission expects significant design changes before the project can move forward. Furthermore, the commission’s engagement with the board restructuring proposal and the appointment of specific liaisons for homelessness indicate an active effort to align advisory bodies with the city’s comprehensive plan and to address the complex social and infrastructural challenges facing the downtown district.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x_BBuxD1tTo
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2858/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x_BBuxD1tTo)
