# Historic Resources Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Historic Resources Commission
**Date:** February 9, 2022 4:00 PM EST (2022-02-09T16:00:10-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5052/historic-resources-commission-feb-9-2022

## Summary

The City of Asheville Historic Resources Commission (HRC) held a virtual meeting on February 9, 2022, to review preservation applications and discuss regional planning issues. The Commission began by approving the minutes from its January 12, 2022 meeting by a unanimous 6-0 vote. The agenda then moved to two public hearings regarding applications for Certificates of Appropriateness (CA) within the Montford Historic District, followed by a strategic discussion on the Buncombe County Comprehensive Plan and the receipt of a local historic landmark application for the Walton Street Pool.

The Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness for new construction at 43 Elizabeth Place. The approval included conditions requiring the applicants to submit door specifications, a revised site plan, a revised front elevation drawing, and a final color palette to staff for review. During the hearing, Chair Emily Kite noted that traditional Montford exteriors typically feature stronger contrast between trim and siding colors. Vice Chair Emily Sprang expressed concern that the proposed gable window looked odd compared to neighborhood norms, suggesting a single window on the side of the house would be preferable. Staff member Alex Dalsimer noted that the Commission has never allowed textured siding on new construction because it can resemble faux wood rather than actual smooth wood.

For the second item, the Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness for fenestration and rear elevation changes at 265 Cumberland Avenue. This approval was contingent on the submission of revised elevation drawings, floor plans, and manufacturer specifications for new doors and windows. The discussion focused on maintaining the balance of the building’s facades. Commissioner Will Hornaday expressed less concern with the kitchen side of the building but raised issues with the standard requiring the retention of original openings, noting that everything was moving a couple of inches. Commissioner Sarah Gross stated that while retaining the framing of deleted windows helps show where openings were, it still throws off the balance of the elevation. Staff member Alex Dalsimer remarked that he had not seen a project with this many proposed window changes and recommended the applicant treat the existing architecture more sensitively by keeping window openings intact.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the Commission’s relationship with Buncombe County planning staff. Commissioners expressed frustration that their engagement with the county’s comprehensive plan process was "scripted" and limited, preventing them from articulating the value of historic preservation. A key concern raised was that the county’s plan may make little or no reference to existing historic fabric. Staff member Alex Dalsimer explained that the county’s planning department does not have historic preservation embedded within it, unlike the City’s department, and that while the County Planning Manager has been receptive, the project consultant has not been as accessible. Chair Emily Kite described the situation as a "circular problem" where a lack of funding prevents the Commission from conducting reconnaissance surveys to justify preservation goals.

The Commission also received a local historic landmark application for the Walton Street Pool, a 1938 Works Progress Administration project that was the first public pool for Black residents. Although the pool is no longer usable for swimming, the Parks Department is planning improvements to surrounding facilities using $500,000 from City Council. Staff proposed integrating the HRC’s community engagement for the landmark designation with the Parks Department’s upcoming engagement for park improvements to ensure the community feels ownership over the process. Commissioner Will Hornaday noted that while City Council has the final say on landmark designation, neighborhood input would likely carry weight. Staff member Alex Dalsimer described the site as a "really amazing opportunity" for the city to retain the intact pool house as a community gathering space.

No members of the public called in to speak during the public comment periods for either the 43 Elizabeth Place or 265 Cumberland Avenue hearings, and no public comments were recorded for the Walton Street Pool discussion.

Staff member Alex Dalsimer agreed to several follow-up actions. For 43 Elizabeth Place, staff will follow up with the applicants within the next few days regarding the required submissions. For 265 Cumberland Avenue, staff will similarly follow up with the applicants to receive revised drawings and specifications. Regarding the county relationship, staff stated they are drafting formal memos to the County Planning Director to outline the Commission’s goals and request additional funding, and agreed to reach out to the County Planning Manager to see if project consultants can meet with the HRC to hear their concerns directly. Staff also agreed to send the Walton Street Pool landmark application file and a process flow chart to Commission members and to set up a poll to determine dates for a site visit. Additionally, staff proposed forming a subcommittee to move the Walton Street Pool application along, with the goal of having members attend the Parks Department’s community engagement sessions.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IG1b_IWPCqc
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2857/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IG1b_IWPCqc)
