# Governance Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Governance Committee
**Date:** February 8, 2022 2:00 PM EST (2022-02-08T14:00:23-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5053/governance-committee-feb-8-2022
**Outcome:** Governance Committee approved the October 2021 minutes and heard an update on initiatives to improve public access to government information.

## Summary

**Key Decisions**
The only formal action taken at the February 8, 2022, Governance Committee meeting was the approval of the minutes from October 2021. A motion was made to approve these minutes, and a roll call vote was taken, resulting in unanimous approval. No other motions, votes, or formal approvals were recorded during the meeting, as the primary agenda item was an informational presentation.

**Discussion Highlights**
The committee focused on a single agenda item: Initiatives on Access to Government. Dawa Hitch, Director of Communications & Public Engagement, presented an update on the City’s efforts to enhance public access to government information and decision-making. The presentation covered three levels of access:
*   **Department Level:** Staff reviewed website project pages, the virtual engagement hub, social media, and neighborhood meetings. Key challenges identified included inconsistent formatting, PDF-only documents, and the need for better reporting on how public input influenced decisions.
*   **Board and Commission Level:** The discussion addressed virtual meeting accessibility, web page consistency, and the difficulty of coordinating schedules across more than 30 boards and commissions.
*   **City Council Level:** The review noted that while streaming and closed captioning are available for council meetings, sign language interpretation and accessible document formats remain significant gaps.

The presentation concluded with a summary of "continuous improvement" opportunities, distinguishing between short-term fixes, such as consistent communication templates, and long-term projects, including creating a searchable document system, implementing sign language interpretation, and building a stakeholder database. Dawa Hitch stated, "The City of Asheville is committed to inclusive participation in government... Staff is committed to continuously improving options to enhance access to government with several short-term and longer-term efforts currently underway."

During the discussion, Councilmember Whistler asked, "If we're exploring hybrid meetings, how do you prioritize a person who's in person versus a person that is virtual?" Mayor Manheimer responded, "We're incredibly generous [compared to other cities]... We're obviously not, you know, we're obviously continuing to do better." Councilmember Roney commented, "I hear that as a no, we are not going to have our advisory boards present to council that we are going to use strictly the in writing report." Mayor Manheimer clarified, "We don't have a written policy about it. And there are times where advisory boards have made presentations under the presentation portion of the agenda. I don't know why you'd wanna cut off that opportunity for council to ask for that if we need to do it." Councilmember Roney added, "I see some of the concerns that have been brought up addressed here. And that's great because that means that we're hearing and we're responding. It's a great start."

**Community Input**
Three members of the public called in to comment. A public commenter representing a community group from East West Asheville stated that their group, which developed an "Open Meetings Policy," had requested to present this policy as a formal agenda item. The commenter reported that despite multiple follow-ups with staff and committee members in January and February, they had not received a clear "yes" or "no" regarding their request. The commenter expressed disappointment that the process to add a presentation to the agenda was not operating with integrity and requested that the committee provide specific feedback if the proposal lacks support. The commenter reiterated their request to present the policy at the March Governance Committee meeting. No member of the committee responded directly to this specific comment during the meeting.

A second public commenter, representing a local accountability organization from Montford, requested that meeting materials be made available earlier than the current Friday release. The commenter explained that the narrow window between the release of agendas and the meeting makes it difficult for volunteers to analyze complex issues and inform the public in time to submit public comments. The commenter noted that earlier release would lead to better-informed and more effective public engagement. No member of the committee responded directly to this specific comment during the meeting.

A third public commenter expressed concern about the potential elimination of advisory committees and the impact on transparency. The commenter requested that the committee continue to offer virtual engagement options, specifically suggesting that the sign-up deadline for City Council public comment be removed to increase accessibility. The commenter also asked how many of the 30 recommendations made by 18 advisory boards in the previous year were adopted by Council. No member of the committee responded directly to this specific comment during the meeting.

**Follow-ups**
Dawa Hitch, Director of Communications & Public Engagement, committed that the first iteration of an "engagement and stakeholder database" project will be completed by June 30. This system aims to centralize public input and allow staff to track community feedback and stakeholder interests more effectively. Additionally, a public commenter stated that her team is currently polling other local governments across the state to research how they handle the prioritization of in-person versus virtual public commenters in hybrid meetings. She committed to bringing that research back to the committee once concluded. Rachel Wood, Assistant City Manager, indicated that the March Council Retreat (March 17-18) would be an opportunity to discuss organizational priorities, including whether staff should draft a formal policy regarding public engagement and board presentations. Mayor Manheimer suggested that Councilmember Roney speak with fellow council members to gauge interest in adopting a formal policy regarding when and how the City hears from boards and commissions.

**Impact**
This meeting highlighted the City of Asheville's ongoing efforts to improve transparency and public access to government information. By identifying specific gaps in accessibility—such as the lack of sign language interpretation and inconsistent document formatting—the committee acknowledged areas where residents may currently face barriers to participation. The commitment to build a stakeholder database and the discussion around formalizing policies for board presentations and hybrid meeting prioritization indicate a focus on creating more structured and inclusive channels for civic engagement.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rWgp__KGjDc
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2853/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rWgp__KGjDc)
