# Neighborhood Advisory Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Neighborhood Advisory Committee
**Date:** January 24, 2022 5:05 PM EST (2022-01-24T17:05:21-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5066/neighborhood-advisory-committee-jan-24-2022
**Outcome:** The Neighborhood Advisory Committee approved the November 29 minutes with a correction and discussed the proposed Open Space Ordinance Amendment.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Neighborhood Advisory Committee (NAC) held a virtual meeting on January 24, 2022. The primary focus of the session was a detailed review of the proposed Open Space Ordinance Amendment, alongside staff updates regarding ongoing hiring and grant programs.

**Key Decisions**
The committee’s only formal vote concerned the approval of the minutes from the November 29, 2021 meeting. Initially, a motion was made to approve the minutes as written. However, a committee member raised a concern that the document did not accurately reflect the committee’s previous position on the open space ordinance, specifically noting the omission of the word "not" in the phrase "we recommend not going as low as 5 to 15%." Staff offered to postpone adoption to correct the error. The committee subsequently moved to approve the minutes with this specific correction. The motion was seconded and passed unanimously.

**Discussion Highlights**
Staff planner Videla Ceveska presented the proposed changes to the zoning code, which aim to reduce barriers to infill development to increase housing supply. The amendment proposes tiered open space requirements, lowering the minimum for smaller residential projects, while incentivizing better stormwater management and tree planting. Ceveska clarified that the amendment targets private open space on private property, such as in apartment complexes or subdivisions, rather than public parks. She explained that current high open space requirements can discourage developers from building smaller, more affordable units, leading to fewer, more expensive units instead.

Committee members engaged in extensive debate regarding the proposal. Sharon Summerall expressed strong disagreement, arguing that the committee had not agreed to lower minimums to the state status quo and that the "fee in lieu" provisions allow developers to bypass open space requirements by paying money. She urged for more public input and a distinction between neighborhood and commercial standards. Another member remained skeptical of the housing examples, noting that in their neighborhood, developers are already building fewer units. When asked about trees, staff clarified that the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance is separate and requires replanting if trees are removed, but trees are not required to be within the open space area. Staff also addressed concerns about the "fee in lieu" provision, explaining it is based on property value and that the city is currently holding funds due to a lawsuit regarding how such funds can be managed. In response to a suggestion that permeable parking lots could count toward open space requirements, staff acknowledged the idea but noted it would require further study.

**Community Input**
No public comments were submitted via voicemail or email for this meeting.

**Follow-ups**
Several members and staff members agreed to specific actions following the meeting:
*   Staff member Dawa Hitch agreed to share the list of neighborhoods that received grants by the end of the week.
*   Dawa Hitch stated she is reviewing applications for the Neighborhood and Community Engagement Manager position and will be scheduling interviews shortly.
*   Dawa Hitch offered to take feedback regarding the "Neighborhood News" article on homelessness and share it with the communications team.
*   Committee member Sharon Summerall stated she will bring the open space ordinance concerns to her neighborhood association (Easton Valley) at their next meeting.
*   Committee member Wendy Hainer stated she will write congratulatory notes to grant-receiving neighborhoods.
*   Committee member Greta Bush stated she is working with neighbors to revive the Parkway Forest Neighborhood Association.
*   Chair Bobbette Kilgore Mays stated she will speak with a neighbor about the open space ordinance concerns.
*   Staff planner Videla Ceveska offered to answer specific questions via email or phone for members interested in the technical details of the open space ordinance.

**Impact**
This discussion is significant for residents because the proposed Open Space Ordinance Amendment will directly affect how new housing and commercial developments are zoned in Asheville. The amendment seeks to balance the need for increased housing supply with the preservation of green infrastructure and stormwater management. While the City Council is scheduled to hold a work session on this topic, followed by Planning and Zoning review in the spring, the NAC’s role is to ensure that neighborhood perspectives are considered in these regulatory changes.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EkaWBaf-pc4
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2870/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EkaWBaf-pc4)
