# Multimodal Transportation Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Multimodal Transportation Commission
**Date:** December 16, 2021 2:15 PM EST (2021-12-16T14:15:12-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5081/multimodal-transportation-commission-dec-16-2021
**Outcome:** The Multimodal Transportation Commission discussed the Public Space Management Framework and deferred a proposal to prioritize pedestrians over parking to full membership meetings.

## Summary

On December 16, 2021, the City of Asheville’s Multimodal Transportation Commission held a joint work session with the Downtown Commission. The meeting focused on two primary areas: the Downtown Public Space Management Framework and updates to the Asheville Shared Space Program. The session was chaired by Randy Warren of the Multimodal Transportation Commission and Brian Moffitt of the Downtown Commission.

## Key Decisions
No formal votes, motions, or official resolutions were adopted during this joint session. While a member proposed that the commissions adopt a guiding direction for the Public Space Management Committee to "prioritize the needs of space for pedestrians first and parking last," the proposal was seconded but not adopted. Bill Loftis of the Downtown Commission stated that the Downtown Commission was not fully represented at the joint session and that a resolution should not be taken without full membership discussion. Consequently, staff suggested that the chairs of both commissions consider adding this proposal to their upcoming individual agendas for formal discussion and potential adoption.

## Discussion Highlights
Staff presented a pre-pandemic Public Space Management Framework developed with a task force to serve as an internal decision-making tool for balancing competing interests in streets and sidewalks, such as outdoor dining, street performance, and pedestrian mobility. Staff also provided updates on the transition of temporary pandemic-era programs to permanent status, including outdoor dining encroachment permits, parklets, and shared streets on locations like Wall Street and South Market.

Members debated specific streets suitable for pedestrian priority zones, citing density, business presence, and existing successful closures. The discussion shifted from listing specific streets to developing broader criteria for selection, with emphasis on the fact that sidewalks vary drastically in width along the same street. Infrastructure, equity, and accessibility were central to the debate, with members emphasizing that while the city should incentivize biking and walking, car access must remain available for non-abled individuals and the growing senior citizen population.

Regarding business impact, members discussed the logistical challenges of closing streets to vehicles, specifically regarding delivery access for restaurants. There was consensus that alternative delivery routes must be established. On the topic of privatizing public space, Andrew Fletcher of the Downtown Commission stated, "If we're going to be privatizing public space, there has to be a public benefit to it. If the only benefit that can be identified from privatizing public space is to that particular business, then I think that that is not an appropriate use." Kenny Armstrong of the Multimodal Transportation Commission noted that space currently advocated for vehicles is a recent development and argued, "I would say it should be our prerogative to put pedestrians and people first over cars."

When asked which initiative has the most potential for advancing racial equity, supporting local businesses, and advancing multimodal goals, members generally favored shared streets. One member stated, "the shared streets embodies all the other three before it... So to me, that's a no-brainer." Randy Warren also pitched for sidewalk merchandise permits, noting, "if you want to talk about how people can generate business opportunities from almost nothing... this is something tangible the city could do."

## Follow-ups
Staff committed to sharing the presentation slides and the Public Space Management Framework document on both the Multimodal Transportation Commission and Downtown Commission websites. Staff will also re-establish the Public Space Management Committee to finalize the framework and determine representation. Additionally, staff is seeking funding through the budget process, including ARPA grants and supplemental requests, to develop a long-term, permanent parklet program with dedicated resources for enforcement and maintenance; this process will continue through July. Staff is working with the Urban Design Working Group to review urban design standards, review processes, and fee structures for outdoor dining, as well as program standards and permitting guidelines for parklets and street areas. Staff is also working with businesses that expanded into private property to create a "personalized road to permanency" for permitting.

On the commission side, a member of the Multimodal Transportation Commission volunteered to serve on the reconstituted Public Space Management Committee. A member of the Planning & Zoning Commission stated they would share information with other Planning & Zoning members to facilitate cross-commission information sharing. Members of the Downtown Commission agreed to consider the proposal to "prioritize pedestrians first and parking last" at their upcoming full membership meetings. Members of both commissions were encouraged to submit their annual reports to City Council by the end of January, which could include statements on these priorities.

## Impact
This session addressed how the city manages its public spaces, particularly as temporary pandemic measures transition to permanent programs. The discussions highlight the ongoing tension between accommodating commercial expansion, such as outdoor dining and parklets, and maintaining accessible, pedestrian-friendly public spaces. By developing clearer criteria for shared streets and reviewing fee structures and permitting guidelines, the commissions aim to move away from one-off decisions toward a more equitable and consistent framework for managing the city’s streets and sidewalks.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EId4Yz3Rn8U
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2879/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EId4Yz3Rn8U)
