# Design Review Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Design Review Committee
**Date:** December 16, 2021 12:30 PM EST (2021-12-16T12:30:55-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5082/design-review-committee-dec-16-2021
**Outcome:** The Design Review Committee continued three development projects to a future meeting and allowed a historic building repair to proceed to final review.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Design Review Committee held a virtual meeting on December 16, 2021, to review four development projects. The committee began by unanimously approving the minutes from its November 18, 2021 meeting. The primary focus of the session was the evaluation of three major projects, all of which were continued to a future meeting to allow applicants time to address design concerns and provide additional information.

**Key Decisions**
The committee voted unanimously (5 ayes) to continue the review of 48 South Market Street to the January 20, 2022 meeting, as the applicant requested additional time to file a variance application regarding fenestration. Similarly, the committee voted unanimously (5 ayes) to continue the Level 1 review for 123 Haywood Street, a project converting a residential condominium building into a hotel, to the January 20, 2022 meeting. The committee also voted unanimously (5 ayes) to continue the formal review of 363 Hilliard Avenue (The Avery), a 184-unit residential development, to the January 2022 meeting. For the informal review of the Star Building, a historic preservation project on Broadway, no formal vote was taken; the committee agreed to allow the project to proceed to final review, noting it was a straightforward repair and replacement effort. The meeting concluded with a unanimous vote to adjourn.

**Discussion Highlights**
Significant debate arose regarding the 123 Haywood Street project, with members questioning how the modern design fits within the historic context of Asheville. Chair Jane Matthews, who is concluding her term on the committee, stated, "I guess I would ask the other committee members, what makes this feel like it belongs in Asheville? It doesn't make me feel like it belongs in Asheville. I think that is the key question. I think that's what citizens will ask us." Member Bryan Moffitt echoed these sentiments, noting, "I'm struggling to conceptualize and communicate that clearly... How do they take it and make it of its time and of its style, but still Asheville?" Member Steven Lee Johnson emphasized the need for clarity on the streetscape, stating, "I think that the design review committee needs to know exactly what the streetscape experience is going to be on the project in order to approve it." Staff member Shannon, the Assistant City Manager, explained that changing the use of the project creates its own hardship and that she did not think it was a good candidate for a Board of Adjustment variance.

For the 363 Hilliard Avenue project, staff member Will Palmquist, a new urban planner, presented details on stormwater management, noting, "They have actually cut some curbs internal to the site trying to get stormwater to go to areas that can't officially be bioretentions... but it can still be very beneficial to slowing water down, cleaning water, cooling water." Member Robin Raines offered a design suggestion regarding the building's access, stating, "If the roof deck goes away, I would vote for continuing the cage up the side all the way to the roof and having that be your access. I think that could be an interesting feature."

**Follow-ups**
Applicants for the continued items agreed to return with specific revisions and information. For 123 Haywood Street, the applicant agreed to provide additional information and responses to concerns regarding streetscape landscaping, the north elevation, and material colors at the January 20, 2022 meeting. For 363 Hilliard Avenue, the applicant team agreed to return with a final landscape plan, further details on bike lane and sidewalk integration, and clarification on green screen buffers. For the Star Building, the applicant agreed to address a minor design issue regarding an awning on the College Street side before the final review.

**Community Input**
There were no public comments recorded during the meeting. Staff confirmed that no one was in the queue for public comment during the designated periods.

**Impact**
These decisions mean that residents will not see final approvals for the 184-unit residential development at 363 Hilliard Avenue or the hotel conversion at 123 Haywood Street until at least January 2022. The committee’s focus on streetscape integration, material choices, and stormwater management indicates that future reviews will closely examine how these large-scale projects interact with the surrounding neighborhood infrastructure and historic character.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cATdqnUQQPQ
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2885/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cATdqnUQQPQ)
