# Transit Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Transit Committee
**Date:** December 15, 2021 3:30 PM EST (2021-12-15T15:30:06-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5083/transit-committee-dec-15-2021
**Outcome:** The Transit Committee heard updates on postponed service expansions due to driver shortages and the status of a bus shelter grant, but took no formal action because it lacked a quorum.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Transit Committee held a virtual meeting on December 15, 2021, from 3:30 PM to 5:30 PM. The session was conducted for informational purposes only, as the committee did not have a quorum; only three voting members were present. Consequently, the chair confirmed that while the group could review the agenda, no formal votes could be taken, and no official motions could be passed.

**Key Decisions**
No decisions were made or votes taken during this meeting. The committee reviewed the minutes from the previous meeting on August 17, but because of the lack of quorum, the minutes were not approved. All other agenda items were discussed for information only, with no formal action taken on any of them.

**Discussion Highlights**
The meeting covered several operational and structural topics. Staff provided updates on recent schedule changes and on-time performance, noting that planned service expansions were postponed due to driver shortages. Transit Projects Coordinator Haley Burton stated, "The reason we needed to postpone those changes was due to the lack of drivers... We were not able to get enough drivers that we needed to be able to make these improvements." She added that there is currently no timeline for these improvements due to staffing unknowns.

The committee also discussed the status of a $1 million grant for bus shelter upgrades and the purchase of three new buses. In a discussion regarding the committee’s future structure, member John Besson noted concerns that the transit committee was not stable enough and that there was a desire to see regular meetings with full attendance. Chair Harvey responded, "Yes, we're working on that diligently. I guess it's just like the drivers with transit, they have a shortage. We used to have an overage, but we got a shortage."

New applicant Bill Daniluk was introduced to the committee. Daniluk, a Lieutenant Colonel in the Air Force and avid cyclist, shared his perspective on Asheville’s mobility needs, comparing it to Honolulu. Chair Harvey clarified that while the committee welcomes Daniluk, he still must be voted in by the Multimodal Committee. Additionally, staff provided clarification on advertising policies, with Transit Planning Manager Eunice Lovey explaining that city ordinance prohibits advertising on the outside of buses, allowing it only on the inside.

**Community Input**
There were no formal public comments during the designated public comment periods. However, committee members provided feedback regarding rider experiences. Member Sandy Aldrich reported feedback from approximately 12 riders concerning the W1 route, which goes to the VA. Riders expressed concern that the bus no longer turns into the Walmart lot first, forcing disabled or injured riders to walk a significant distance to the stop on the right side of the road after the bridge. In response, Transit Planning Manager Eunice Lovey stated, "Haley indicated we will talk to LaShawn and follow up with you in terms of the comment you made and make sure that you provided ample information based on the feedback you received from other writers."

Member Sandy Aldrich also raised safety concerns regarding driver conduct, praising several drivers for their demeanor but noting that others were speeding, specifically mentioning a driver nicknamed the "roller coaster driver." The chair responded, "These will be taken in earnest from staff and they will get back with you. I'm quite sure they will."

**Follow-ups**
Staff agreed to several specific follow-up actions during the meeting:
*   **W1 Route/Walmart Stop:** Staff (Eunice Lovey) agreed to consult with LaShawn Abraham (RATP Dev) and follow up with the committee member regarding the rider feedback about the Walmart stop location.
*   **Bus Stop Presentation:** Staff (Haley Burton) agreed to forward the slide presentation on the Bus Stop Improvement Project to John Besson so he could share it with the Multimodal Committee.
*   **Fare Collection:** Staff (Eunice Lovey) stated that the team is planning to put together a presentation for the committee in January regarding fare collection improvements and next steps.
*   **New Member Documents:** Staff (Eunice Lovey) offered to send Bill Daniluk specific documents and information about transit if he requests them.

**Impact**
This meeting highlights the ongoing challenges the transit system faces in maintaining service levels and stability. The postponement of service expansions due to driver shortages indicates that residents may not see planned route improvements in the near future. Additionally, the discussion regarding the committee’s status as a commission reflects internal efforts to address attendance and stability concerns. For residents, the immediate impact is limited to the informational updates provided, as no new policies or services were authorized. The upcoming January presentation on fare collection is the next scheduled item that may affect riders.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KzHxHSpqOXM
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2882/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KzHxHSpqOXM)
