# Historic Resources Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Historic Resources Commission
**Date:** December 8, 2021 4:00 PM EST (2021-12-08T16:00:07-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5088/historic-resources-commission-dec-8-2021
**Outcome:** The Commission approved three projects in the Montford Historic District, including a new bungalow and landmark window restorations, and recommended to the City Council that a vacant commissioner seat be filled.

## Summary

**Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: December 8, 2021**

The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened on December 8, 2021, to conduct evidentiary hearings for five projects within the Montford Historic District or involving local landmarks. The meeting began with the unanimous adoption of the minutes from the previous November session. The Commission then reviewed applications for new construction, restorations, and modifications, resulting in approvals for three projects, a withdrawal of one, and a continuance for another. Additionally, the Commission voted unanimously to recommend to the City Council that the seat of a non-attending city-appointed commissioner be vacated.

**Key Decisions and Votes**

The Commission approved Certificates of Appropriateness (CA) for two projects. For the Von Ruck House, a local landmark, the Commission unanimously voted to approve window modifications, specifically the restoration of two interior conservatory openings and the replacement of five non-original windows with new wood 1-over-1 double-hung windows. This approval included a condition that wood window specifications be submitted for staff review. Similarly, the Commission unanimously approved the CA for a new one-story bungalow at 6 Houston Street (1,320 sq. ft.). After debating the visual compatibility of the front porch railing height, which is dictated by building code at 36 inches, the Commission accepted the design based on precedent photographs showing the railing aligned with window sill heights.

For the project at 162 Flip Street, which involved a deck extension, roof covering, and outdoor fireplace, the applicant verbally amended the application to close the exposed gable end with cedar shakes and include an open window-like feature to maintain light. The Commission unanimously voted to approve the CA with the condition that revised drawings be submitted for staff review. In contrast, the application for a front yard metal picket fence at 327 Montford Avenue was withdrawn by the applicant after staff recommended against it, noting that front yard fences are rarely approved. No vote was taken on the fence, though staff agreed to review the remaining minor work items separately. Finally, the application for a new 3,000 sq. ft. primary structure at 43 Elizabeth Place was continued to the February meeting at the applicant’s request to address design feedback.

**Discussion Highlights**

Significant debate occurred regarding the new construction at 6 Houston Street, where staff and members discussed whether the 36-inch railing height would appear visually disproportionate to neighboring historic properties. Staff clarified that while building code provisions allow historic buildings to retain lower railing heights, new construction must comply with the 36-inch standard. Staff noted that the design’s success relied on the railing aligning with the window sill height rather than an exact measurement. Chair Emily Kite commented that the project had a "really nice balance" and was "not very often" that a first attempt at new construction in the district was so in line with Commission standards.

Regarding the 43 Elizabeth Place resubmittal, the Commission discussed design concerns including front gable windows, roofing materials, and rear landscaping. Chair Emily Kite suggested considering the relevance of natural cedar to determine if it was a significant impact to the project. Commissioner Gail Lazarus argued that it would not be difficult to justify using non-matching materials in the rear because the area is not highly visible and matching materials would be "logistically unfeasible." Staff also addressed the 327 Montford Avenue fence application, stating, "I am not recommending in favor of this fence," and noting that such approvals are limited to extraordinary circumstances and are often "hotly debated."

**Follow-ups**

Staff agreed to several specific follow-up actions. For 43 Elizabeth Place, staff will follow up with the applicant regarding stream buffer and landscaping plans from an adjacent condo project and provide grading plans for a Broadway development to help resolve rear yard landscaping uncertainty. For the Von Ruck House, staff will review the wood window specifications once submitted. For 162 Flip Street, staff will follow up in the next few days to review revised drawings for the gable end and brick samples for the fireplace. For 327 Montford Avenue, staff will follow up in the next couple of days to finalize the minor work CA for the remaining landscape improvements, specifically confirming the material for the parking bumper. Finally, staff will follow up with the applicant for 6 Houston Street in the next few days regarding next steps. The Commission’s vote to vacate the non-attending commissioner’s seat serves as a formal recommendation to the City Council.

**Impact**

These decisions directly affect the physical development and preservation of properties within the Montford Historic District and local landmarks. The approval of new construction at 6 Houston Street and modifications at the Von Ruck House and 162 Flip Street allows for the expansion and restoration of these properties in a manner deemed appropriate by the Commission. The withdrawal of the fence at 327 Montford Avenue preserves the current open front yard, while the continuance of the 43 Elizabeth Place project allows the applicant time to address design concerns before a final decision is made. The recommendation to vacate the commissioner seat addresses the vacancy created by a member who has not attended meetings or responded to correspondence since her appointment in August.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4-fkEcnJX-o
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2892/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4-fkEcnJX-o)
